THE GREAT DEBATE: Which film has better overall art? 5 cm per second vs. The Place Promised in Our Early Days
| Hey everyone, *Please check out the pictures and AMVs below if you haven't seen either film.*  vs.  5 cm per second  More pictures The Place Promised in Our Early Days  More pictures Happy debating! |
madskizzlesSep 4, 2009 5:12 PM
 |
| 5cm per sec<3 That's the anime for me with the greatest art @_@; i still haven't watched many animes but w/e But in Kumo no mukou the art is so good 2 @_@; yea <3 But still i choose 5cm per sec :3 |
     |
| The Place Promised In Our Early Days. I found though I loved the visuals in 5 Centimeters Per Second, there was that bit more variation in TPPIOED, using lot's of different locations and still imprinting them into the memory effectively. Although I think 5CMPS did the whole mood through colours and soft visuals, I just really enjoyed the elements of clever lighting and how the story was told much more efficiently through its art over dialogue. I also preferred the character designs in TPPIOED, I think Makoto Shinkai really refined his style there. edit: also I thought mention how nice it is to see an AMV to maybeshewill XD (massive post rock fan alert >.>) |
KrystalSep 4, 2009 3:42 PM
| 5 cm per second <3 |
 |
| five cm per second |
Neko-Girl said: 5 cm per second <3 |
 |
| 5cm/sec OF COURCE!! That movie s briliant!! |
| I know I have a fickle heart and a bitterness And a wandering eye, and a heaviness in my head |
| this was a really hard decision but in the end my vote will have to lean slightly toward 5 cm per second....it was a really hard decision though....there are zero to no discrepancies in these animes but my personal preference has to go to 5 cm :P |
Krystal said: The Place Promised In Our Early Days. I found though I loved the visuals in 5 Centimeters Per Second, there was that bit more variation in TPPIOED, using lot's of different locations and still imprinting them into the memory effectively. Although I think 5CMPS did the whole mood through colours and soft visuals, I just really enjoyed the elements of clever lighting and how the story was told much more efficiently through its art over dialogue. I also preferred the character designs in TPPIOED, I think Makoto Shinkai really refined his style there. edit: also I thought mention how nice it is to see an AMV to maybeshewill XD (massive post rock fan alert >.>) Wow. This was a great post, and I think Krystal makes some very good points. However...like madskizzles said, I found almost no discrepancies with 5 cm's art. The detail shown is impeccable. In my eyes, TPPiOED seemed a little less refined the 5 cm, but the color scheme TPPiEOD had was better than 5 cm's... The Place Promised in Our Early Days was definitely up there, but if 5 cm's art was a 10, I would give TPPiOED a 9.8. Maybe because 5 cm was done later than TPPiOED... This decision was unbelievably hard, as both films' art simply blew me away. I'm a sucker for fantastic scenery... So, 5 cm per second. |
| |
| 5 cm ^^ |
 |
| 5 cm per second |
| Both are awesome movies. But I think that 5 cm per second was simply amazing. Every scene in the movie is beautiful. Although to be fair I did watch this one with DIVX. |
NiiSep 5, 2009 1:02 AM
| Didn't watch both :S. |
| Deiciding his life style by rolling the dice. |
capslock said: five cm per second omg this is so hard >.< i loved both of them alot...but ill go with 5cm... |
 |
| 5 cm per second. |
aznHoopsfan said: Wow. This was a great post, and I think Krystal makes some very good points. However...like madskizzles said, I found almost no discrepancies with 5 cm's art. The detail shown is impeccable. In my eyes, TPPiOED seemed a little less refined the 5 cm, but the color scheme TPPiEOD had was better than 5 cm's... The Place Promised in Our Early Days was definitely up there, but if 5 cm's art was a 10, I would give TPPiOED a 9.8. Maybe because 5 cm was done later than TPPiOED... This decision was unbelievably hard, as both films' art simply blew me away. I'm a sucker for fantastic scenery... So, 5 cm per second. Yeah I know what you mean, scenery done well actually amazes me more than character designs themselves, I just love really stunning aesthetics. Like some of the carefully chosen backdrops in Ef ~ A Tale of Memories~ perhaps not my favourite anime plotwise but the way the art emphasises the mood is done very cleverly. I guess I just found that a lot more in APPIOED over 5cm. I think despite 5cm being done after I guess it was the variation of the scenes in APPIOED that won me over. XD Though you are quite right, it is a difficult decision to make since they are both so flawless. |
Neko-Girl said: 5 cm per second <3 |
 |
| The Place Promised in Our Early Days |
| the two of them are masterpieces. i love them both i cant decide :/ |
| 5 cm per second... I think. I'm really lazy now to explain why... |
 |
| 5 CM Per Second. I liked both films, and they both has astounding art, but there was just something about the scenes in 5cm that just blew me away. |
| 5 cm |
| Midori ^^ |
More topics from this board
Poll: » THE GREAT DEBATE: Who is the better strategist? Lelouch vi Britannia vs. Light Yagami ( 1 2 )madskizzles - Jul 29, 2009 |
53 |
by Beat_Jerker
»»
May 6, 2021 2:52 PM |
|
Poll: » THE GREAT DEBATE: Which eye ability is better? Sharingan (Naruto) vs. Geass (Code Geass)? ( 1 2 )aznHoopsfan - Aug 2, 2009 |
65 |
by A231
»»
Nov 18, 2019 12:34 AM |
|
Poll: » THE GREAT DEBATE: Is Kira/Light's view of the world correct or is killing of criminals wrong?aznHoopsfan - Nov 28, 2009 |
45 |
by MATTY_22
»»
Jun 1, 2017 7:59 PM |
|
Poll: » THE GREAT DEBATE: Who's more psycho? Shion Sonozaki (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni) vs. Lucy (Elfen Lied)?aznHoopsfan - Sep 18, 2009 |
39 |
by toothless1504
»»
Jan 27, 2017 12:32 AM |
|
Poll: » THE GREAT DEBATE: Which is better? Girls with guns or guys with swords? ( 1 2 )aznHoopsfan - Nov 6, 2009 |
59 |
by Menchrese
»»
Oct 24, 2015 8:02 PM |