Suzune-chan said: I believe that if karrote was the townie, he wouldn't kill himself and bryn based on suspicion alone, she can't be an original zombie, she would be the [converted] zombie and he somehow found out using his primary role abilities (remember lovers is a secondary role) or using the lovers role mechanics for this game (remember this data is hidden). Regarding Coro's statement, I believe she was talking about the zombies (read Section V: Secondary roles in the OP). If the biter dies while the decayer is alive, fake roles will given to zombies and they would all appear townie. ^ This is why I added the possibility that the thief has been stealing the town messages every night, the host will most likely want to test this rule so there's possibly a town crier/decayer combo in the roles being played. |
Verumir said: Grave, might think the contrary, there is something that isn't clear yet. Like I said earlier in the phase, I think lynching billy is wrong, I think I know the real reason soren voted for him but I'll keep quiet about ti for now. If you need billy to clear up something for you, just ask him (unless you think ti will give mafia ideas or help them). If you need me to clear up something, ask away, I'm online now ^^ |
grave_robber said: Verumir said: Grave, might think the contrary, there is something that isn't clear yet. Like I said earlier in the phase, I think lynching billy is wrong, I think I know the real reason soren voted for him but I'll keep quiet about ti for now. If you need billy to clear up something for you, just ask him (unless you think ti will give mafia ideas or help them). If you need me to clear up something, ask away, I'm online now ^^ Who do you suggest we lynch now? |
 |
Verumir said: I imagine the mess... It's gonna be so bad until it gets good. I will take full responsibility, but we need to get this info out of him before the night ends, you know what I'm saying? If they get pissed, they can kill/convert/lynch me, but the blow this will send to their plans would be too powerful and they will lose. Shrink, Please protect BornBlonde tonight! This is very important, you will know why as soon he gets online. |
Soren333 said: Who do you suggest we lynch now? I already made out my vote to Lucian who I suspect is the hooker. I'm not changing that vote, a defense of "bad memory" doesn't explain or excuse all those important details he got wrong. He has 3 people voting against now: myself, verumir & adeptbro. If you think all 3 of us are wrong and that Lucian is a certain townie role, tell us now and we will unvote. Do you completely trust Lucian? If I wasn't going to vote for lucian (based on the assumption that he was being framed, I would vote for the person I said would become a suspect in this case and that's coromandel). I can only tell you who I suspect but you don't need me to tell you who to lynch, you have good skills and theories and you might be on to something that I or others have missed. You can make this decision, I believe in you! |
grave_robber said: what makes you think that he is the hooker specifically?Soren333 said: Who do you suggest we lynch now? I already made out my vote to Lucian who I suspect is the hooker. I'm not changing that vote, a defense of "bad memory" doesn't explain or excuse all those important details he got wrong. He has 3 people voting against now: myself, verumir & adeptbro. If you think all 3 of us are wrong and that Lucian is a certain townie role, tell us now and we will unvote. Do you completely trust Lucian? If I wasn't going to vote for lucian (based on the assumption that he was being framed, I would vote for the person I said would become a suspect in this case and that's coromandel). I can only tell you who I suspect but you don't need me to tell you who to lynch, you have good skills and theories and you might be on to something that I or others have missed. You can make this decision, I believe in you! |
|
| Well I have looked through the phase to see what I have missed and it looks like this is between billy and Lucian both have thier own reasons to look suspect mainly from differing from core playing style. The thing both are releated because of the 1 day so if one turns up one side the other most likely will the same but nothing is certain. That added with the whole grrr voting billy when they knew they were dead as discussed before can be seen as grrr protecting a fellow mafia or grrr knowing we would think like that and pick a random town to frame it is hard to know which at this moment of time if they was a reason at all. But overall I think they are clean and people are just seeing them as a easy target mainly because the mayor's reasoning was poor to vote them imo and I think others jumped on it senseing a easy kill and lynch. Now onto Lucian where do I start with him he is always one of main suspects just because I don't like the way he does things a clash of playstyles I suppose and this leads me to always having doubts in their movites But I think they have been getting played for once and may be clean they could of been changed on night one since we don't know who got turned yet but that is not enough evidence on that for me to base anything. I do agree with some of graves points and to say Lucian's excuse was poor would be a understatement and for the whole mafia would not mess up yes they would so they can use that excuse I love to do that myself when bad but saying this I think they are safe but would not be surprised if I was wrong since how they play in a way I can't cope with and hard for me to judge their actions. I will go onto my main suspect someone who has stood out to me and I don't think has been mentioned so far today as a suspect and that person is Adeptbro I don't have a lot of evidence to back this apart from my normal gut feeling which has worked out for me and I could be wrong on this but he seems to follow lynch trains which is mafia behaviour and espically in a game where zombies can be identified by traits to do with voting which can affect lynch trains if not done well. They seem to vote Lucian a lot as well so if they are bad it would lessen my doubts on Lucian because they are still a lot. Vote adeptbro I know this is not the best reasoning but this is what I am going with and stuff like this has been paying off for me lately but I am happy to change if they is convinceing evidence for someone else though. I bet a lot has been posted while I did this like always lol |
 |
Soren333 said: what makes you think that he is the hooker specifically? He's trying to be helpful to the town but isn't very interested in the details of the roles and the rules of the game(it can't all be bad memory), he has an ulterior motive then, what role benefits from gaining the town's trust by helping them to get all the zombies but doesn't care about the actually townie/zombie role details? The 3rd party. |
grave_robber said: You're the hooker, I'm keeping my vote for now. How wrong you are. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| Vote: Jackrito [x1][x2] |
|
LucianRoy said: grave_robber said: You're the hooker, I'm keeping my vote for now. How wrong you are. I could be, but I will take responsibility for my vote. I'm keeping my promise of not letting the hooker win this game. That's the personal goal I set for myself this game. If you can show me why I'm wrong, it would be nice, because wine is just wine. |
Soren333 said: Vote: Jackrito [x1][x2] any reason for this or what I only gave my view on the game and the lynchs today and voted someone who has been standing out to me a bit confused. But you are mayor so do what you like I guess. |
|
grave_robber said: LucianRoy said: How wrong you are. I could be, but I will take responsibility for my vote. I'm keeping my promise of not letting the hooker win this game. That's the personal goal I set for myself this game. If you can show me why I'm wrong, it would be nice, because wine is just wine. How do you plan to take responsibility? |
|
Jackrito said: Soren333 said: Vote: Jackrito [x1][x2] any reason for this or what I only gave my view on the game and the lynchs today and voted someone who has been standing out to me a bit confused. But you are mayor so do what you like I guess. You are most likely to be converted by the zombies because your play style allows you to stay alive to late game, so you would be a good choice. |
|
| Day 1 - Part 2 A shuriken was thrown at grave_robber. He was pissed but he couldn't see the ninja, so he walked on by. |
 |
Jackrito said: People seem to forget that grrr88 voted for lucian on day 1 when lucian pointed out that grrr88 was suspicious then he voted for himself. It's most likely a play to make the town think he's protecting billy. How can you not see that his posts and action have been contradicting to say the least? If someone causes confusion on day 1 or 2, they're most likely a bad guy. Later on, I would buy it as a strategy to catch bad guys but not on day 1 or 2. You should think about that. He's still on my suspect list but I'm more inclined to get the hooker out of the way 1st. |
Soren333 said: Jackrito said: any reason for this or what I only gave my view on the game and the lynchs today and voted someone who has been standing out to me a bit confused. But you are mayor so do what you like I guess. You are most likely to be converted by the zombies because your play style allows you to stay alive to late game, so you would be a good choice. Ok that is a fair enough reason I would be a good target because of my exp but to say my playing style means I live longer is a bit false this playstyle leads to me dying a lot eariler if anything because of how suspect I appear and unhelpful early game. So that would make me less likely to be converted if that was their reason Grave Lucian, veru would be better options because they gain town's trust and would be protected by doctor because of how important they are to town so would explain why they don't die. |
|
Soren333 said: Vote: Jackrito [x1][x2] dangling a jackrito vote like that, that's mean! You know I always suspect him, you're making me want to change my mind. No, I won't let the hooker get away. >.< |
Soren333 said: How do you plan to take responsibility? If I'm wrong, then I'm no good to the town and should be lynched for costing them a great player like Lucian. No one can deny that he's a strong player who can lead successful lynches when he applies himself. |
mafiahost said: Day 1 - Part 2 A shuriken was thrown at grave_robber. He was pissed but he couldn't see the ninja, so he walked on by. I know who you are, the jailor helped me find you. Test someone who's actually a zombie! >.< Edit: Wait, are you trying to tell me sth? Was I wrong about the jailor? |
grave_robberJan 7, 2015 1:11 PM
| Lame ninja strikes again! |
 |
mafiahost said: Day 1 - Part 2 A shuriken was thrown at grave_robber. He was pissed but he couldn't see the ninja, so he walked on by. Why the different reaction? |
 |
Verumir said: mafiahost said: Day 1 - Part 2 A shuriken was thrown at grave_robber. He was pissed but he couldn't see the ninja, so he walked on by. Why the different reaction? I'm too cool for normal reactions. I even get called a he! :p |
CorruptedPurity said: Lame ninja strikes again! What if you're the ninja and host-sama is just messing with us? O_O I'm kidding! |
| I would laugh if the stories for the ninja were actually important. |
| "I am the Bone of my Sword Steel is my Body and Fire is my Blood I have created over a Thousand Blades Unaware of Loss, Nor aware of Gain. Withstood Pain to create Weapons, Waiting for one’s Arrival I have no Regrets. This is the only Path My whole life was Unlimited Blade Works" |
| Meh I asked questions to Soren and stated some stuff. I am just ignored by now. Pretty funny how I am a suspect after my statements, and so far one of them has been true. Grrr8 being a zomb. I also said (Don't remember what phase) Lucian is most likely the hooker. But w/e follow graves I guess. |
 |
| A samurai was seen collecting shurikens. This seems like an odd job, but someone has to do it, he thought. |
|
| Fuuuuuuuuuuuuu***k! was that a message from the ninja or not? Is the ninja still a townie? Dammit! I swear to God Ninja! You're confusing me, there's only 30 minutes left.... |
| I believe the ninja is still a townie. I have faith in the ninja. |
|
adeptbro said: Meh I asked questions to Soren and stated some stuff. I am just ignored by now. Pretty funny how I am a suspect after my statements, and so far one of them has been true. Grrr8 being a zomb. I also said (Don't remember what phase) Lucian is most likely the hooker. But w/e follow graves I guess. What questions? |
|
adeptbro said: Meh I asked questions to Soren and stated some stuff. I am just ignored by now. Pretty funny how I am a suspect after my statements, and so far one of them has been true. Grrr8 being a zomb. I also said (Don't remember what phase) Lucian is most likely the hooker. But w/e follow graves I guess. To be fair saying grrr was a zomb proves little of innocence espically since everyone suspected it off the whole no speaking thing any mafia would use that as a chance to make themselfs appear town. With Lucian zombies and town need the hooker dead so that proves little either if right. So both statements do not help you too much but this is more my personal doubts than anything and no one is going to follow me anyway. |
|
Soren333 said: adeptbro said: Meh I asked questions to Soren and stated some stuff. I am just ignored by now. Pretty funny how I am a suspect after my statements, and so far one of them has been true. Grrr8 being a zomb. I also said (Don't remember what phase) Lucian is most likely the hooker. But w/e follow graves I guess. What questions? From what i remember You stated one reason for loliboy being a maf is because of her being online the time the action was made. I asked how is that even valid? Maf actions can be performed any time and it won't be revealed what they did until the end of the phase? No? |
|
mafiahost said: A samurai was seen collecting shurikens. This seems like an odd job, but someone has to do it, he thought. I was wrong about the jailor and the ninja! The Samurai is a switch role or a secondary ability. I get the message now Vote change: coromandel |
Jackrito said: adeptbro said: Meh I asked questions to Soren and stated some stuff. I am just ignored by now. Pretty funny how I am a suspect after my statements, and so far one of them has been true. Grrr8 being a zomb. I also said (Don't remember what phase) Lucian is most likely the hooker. But w/e follow graves I guess. To be fair saying grrr was a zomb proves little of innocence espically since everyone suspected it off the whole no speaking thing any mafia would use that as a chance to make themselfs appear town. With Lucian zombies and town need the hooker dead so that proves little either if right. So both statements do not help you too much but this is more my personal doubts than anything and no one is going to follow me anyway. Maybe you don't get it and I don't expect anyone to remember or even have a good guess right now at who I am. There was a specific reason why I suspected grrr8 MOST LIKELY being a maf. |
|
adeptbro said: Soren333 said: What questions? From what i remember You stated one reason for loliboy being a maf is because of her being online the time the action was made. I asked how is that even valid? Maf actions can be performed any time and it won't be revealed what they did until the end of the phase? No? But the biter ability was activated and processed in the middle of the day. |
|
grave_robber said: mafiahost said: A samurai was seen collecting shurikens. This seems like an odd job, but someone has to do it, he thought. I was wrong about the jailor and the ninja! The Samurai is a switch role or a secondary ability. I get the message now Vote change: coromandel Vote: coromandel [x1][x2] |
|
grave_robber said: mafiahost said: A samurai was seen collecting shurikens. This seems like an odd job, but someone has to do it, he thought. I was wrong about the jailor and the ninja! The Samurai is a switch role or a secondary ability. I get the message now Vote change: coromandel What? o.o |
| Ok, I'm online, Grave tell them |
 |
| unvote x_at_home said: Does someone has a vote count? coromendal assumes the lead, that's all I know. >.> |
|
coromandel said: grave_robber said: I was wrong about the jailor and the ninja! The Samurai is a switch role or a secondary ability. I get the message now Vote change: coromandel What? o.o Why did you vote Lucian on day 1 but grrr88 on day 2? Are you a zombie? Are you the hooker? Are you framing Lucian? Please defend yourself, there's not much time left. |
| can someone do host a favour and count the votes ^.^ pweddy pwease? |
|
mafiahost said: can someone do host a favour and count the votes ^.^ pweddy pwease? Yes. |
|
| Vote Change: Lucian Is it too late or does it count Host? |
|
grave_robber said: coromandel said: What? o.o Why did you vote Lucian on day 1 but grrr88 on day 2? Are you a zombie? Are you the hooker? Are you framing Lucian? Please defend yourself, there's not much time left. Lucian isn't a confirmed townie - so why exactly do I have to defend myself for voting for him? He simply acted weird, especially on day 1 (and I'm not the only one here who thinks that way.. >_>). Why I voted for grr should also be obvious. Vote: Lucian |
BornBlonde said: Ok, I'm online, Grave tell them BornBlonde is the medium! ------------------------------------------- Questions to prove your role: (I would like answer to at least 2 of these) 1) What is the word that I picked up from Karrote? I keep saying now (karrote would know the answer to this, we only talked about it on skype, nowhere on this site) 2) What did I make Conq do in V.1 3) What bands did I recommend to Brynhildr Answer these and we'll ask more questions to check if you're still a townie. |
| Verumir, is it you or Lucian who dropped me the hint? I'm so confused right now! >.< |
More topics from this board
» Rate from 1-10 how approachable the user is above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )666 - Mar 16, 2021 |
4726 |
by mr_linear
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Rate the song above you v.7 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Aug 12, 2022 |
5900 |
by Thanatos1
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Rate 1-10 how chill is the above user ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )BloomingSong - Feb 18, 2022 |
1087 |
by mr_linear
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Last video you watched? ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )00001111qmpz - Sep 10, 2015 |
3234 |
by Noboru
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Alphabet Chat ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )FarCritical - Feb 18, 2018 |
1401 |
by JusticeBastard
»»
6 minutes ago |