Forum Settings
Forums
New
Jul 31, 2017 5:32 AM
#1

Offline
Mar 2015
341
INTRO

Let's be honest, shall we? We all are here because we have seen a common problem on fanfiction writing: a lack of reviews. We have seen wonderfully beautiful stories get virtually ignored or overlooked for some reason or another. So, we are here to help rectify that issue.

HOW DOES REVIEW SCORECARD WORK

This is a point-system review scorecard meant to give you points for the fics you read and review. The fics must be from the club's database, and the reviews have to be posted at fanfiction.net. It's to help the admins to do the quality check.

BASIC POINT SYSTEM

  • Reviewing a one-shot/two-shot gives you 1 point for each chapter.
  • Reviewing a drabble/poem collection gives you 1 point for each chapter.
  • Reviewing a multi-chapter (consists of three or more chapters, not drabble/poem collection) gives you 2 points for each chapter.
  • After gathering 500 points, your scorecard will be reset to 0.
  • Review Tag and other club event reviews don't count.


BONUS CONDITIONS

  • Reviewing a Story of the Month doubles your points as long as the timestamp of your reviews is within the month of the chosen fic.
  • There will be a quality check every Sunday. You'll get 1 bonus point for each "Superior" reviews submitted, and you'll be notified at the comment section of the club.
  • Spin the prize wheel at The Casino.


REVIEW STANDARD

Your review has to consist of at least 100 words with two specifics for the scorecard. Aim to get at least "Upper Borderline" to qualify.

Refer to this thread for more info about reviews.

PRIZES

You will obtain a prize as you reach a particular tier. How do you reach a tier and what is it worth?

Tier 1: 50 points
Get an admin review.

Tier 2: 150 points
Get another admin review OR another chance to recommend another fanfic by others during this week.

Tier 3: 300 points
Get two admin reviews OR a chance to pick a Story of the Month next month.

Tier 4: 500 points
Get three admin reviews OR have a fic of yours chosen for the Story of the Month next month.

When you reach a tier, PM either me or impmontamer03 to redeem your prizes.

A few notes:

  • When a chapter goes over 8k words threshold, the admins reserve the right to do more than one review. Meaning, if you have a chapter consisting of 8k words, you need to get two admin review prizes to get the whole chapter reviewed.
  • More than 10k words, the admins reserve the right to do more than two reviews for the chapter.
  • The admin will start reviewing from the first chapter.
  • For Tier 3 prize, you get to pick a fic written by others for the Story of the Month.


AFTERWORD

To get started, post your scorecard in this thread. Edit it whenever you've reviewed something.

That's all for now! Have fun!

Credit goes to The Reviews Lounge, Too at fanfiction.net.
The_BiologistAug 1, 2017 4:45 AM
Loitering around FFnet and AO3

Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members
Jul 31, 2017 5:40 AM
#2

Offline
Mar 2015
341
Sample Scorecard:

One-shot/Two-shot: (1pt/chapter)
Story Title (link) - Review (link) - Total: 1pt

Drabble/Poem Collection: (1pt/chapter)
Story Title (link) - Review for Ch1 (link), Ch2 (link), Ch3 (link) - Total: 3pts

Multi-chapter: (2pts/chapter)
Story Title (link) - Review for Ch1 (link), Ch2 (link), Ch3 (link) - Total: 6pts

Bonus:
Story Title (link) - Reviewed Multi-chapter Story of the Month ch1-3 (2x2x3=12pts)
Submitted 5 "Superior" reviews during this week (5pts)
The Casino (Total Prize: 5pts)

Total pts: 32
The_BiologistAug 1, 2017 4:44 AM
Loitering around FFnet and AO3

Jul 31, 2017 8:14 PM
#3

Offline
Dec 2015
212
Prepare your scorecards here! In a few hours you can rack up 6pts by reviewing SotM, up to 9pts if you truly put a lot of efforts into writing the reviews!

Just copy paste Biologist's sample to your post here and remove the stuff in each section.

@bloodyshadowz13 @Boudhir @Knight_Miklotov @LIGHTNINGTORPEDO @nekkoMaster @OtakuOne @peetza @rhcharicharan @Rosalie279 @Scrounger @SongstressSL @TheImmortalOne50 @YourImoutoYuki
"Who wouldn't want to be like me? Handsome and free like a bird in a tree! Badaboom!"
Aug 3, 2017 7:20 AM
#4

Offline
Jan 2015
20
One-shot/Two-shot: (1pt/chapter)


Drabble/Poem Collection: (1pt/chapter)

Multi-chapter: (2pts/chapter)

Bonus:
August SotM-Heaven-Smiting Masked Magician- 2 Pts
A Different Kind of Dish-Rec Fic- 1 Pt {for Overview/Pros-Cons (Approved by impmontamer03)}

Total pts: 3 Pts
rhcharicharanAug 3, 2017 7:25 AM
Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members

More topics from this board

Sticky: » Fanfic Database - Post here to get a personal thread for your fanfic

impmontamer03 - Jul 18, 2017

12 by SomeoneFromHeLL »»
Nov 2, 2017 11:44 AM

Sticky: » Story of the Month

The_Biologist - Jul 31, 2017

3 by impmontamer03 »»
Aug 31, 2017 10:29 PM

Sticky: » Review Assessment

The_Biologist - Aug 3, 2017

1 by impmontamer03 »»
Aug 6, 2017 9:41 AM

» [Complete] [Gungrave/Trigun] Wintertime Business

impmontamer03 - Aug 4, 2017

1 by impmontamer03 »»
Aug 4, 2017 9:26 PM

» [WIP] [Kuroko no Basuke] The Next Miracle

The_Biologist - Aug 4, 2017

1 by The_Biologist »»
Aug 4, 2017 9:15 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login