6,5

I'm really in the blind here. This show has so many fans and most of the people are giving it praise. I personally found it to be boring, annoying most of the time and it's story was subpar. What am I missing?

When you take a terrible anime and make the specials even more terrible. Specter Graham is one of the most annoying characters in anime I ever had to watch.

7,5

7,5

Still waiting on season 2.

Another one of those shows that would be even better with good production.

6,5

7,5

Very good anime, yet a bit overhyped.

Another one of those shows I just don't see what others see in it. It's not that I don't like shows like this, Asobi Asobase was great for example. This just didn't have any comedy in it. It just had 12 episodes of boring, can't wait for it to end.

One of the anime staples that is heavily overhyped.

Yes... I am a metalhead.

7,5

7,5

6,5. This anime started so good and I could call in a masterpiece for the first 10 episodes. Then it started to lose it's mystery and they tried way too hard to over complicate the story. At same time most of the episodes from ep 10 on were a snorefest.

5,5

Brotherhood might be better overall, but this was original and I kinda prefer the plot here.

Death of Lust - one of the best animated scenes.

6,5. Dude just wants to kill goblins.

First anime where I actually knew I was watching anime.

Sherlock loli? No, thanks.

7,5. While it has way worse production that Hellsing Ultimate, at least it's a good anime compared to the nonsense Ultimate is.

6,5 If it wasn't for insane production this show has it would have been a big flop.

6,5