I basically just use this site to track which anime I've seen and my general impression of each of them. Don't give the scores too much weight; I generally just give whatever feels right after I finish a show. That being said, the meanings seem to be roughly as follows:
10 - I found myself floating the word "masterpiece" after watching the final episode.(Madoka Magica and Shiki)
9 - The show has significant flaws that I can't scrub from my brain, but still excellent and memorable. (Fullmetal Alchemist (2003), Shin Sekai Yori, Maria the Virgin Witch)
8 & 7 - Shows that do interesting things and succeed at doing them to a greater or lesser extent. Exact score is dependent on some combination of overall artistry and how well it speaks to me personally. (eg. Neon Genesis Evangelion, Hourou Musuko, Sora no Woto)
6 - Reasonably entertaining shows that don't do much worth noting or that are too deeply flawed for me to call unambiguously "good" but that I still enjoyed. (eg. El Cazador de la Bruja, Shigofumi)
5 - Like 6, except I didn't enjoy it as much.
4 & below - If I even finished watching this, it was either a) short or b) with the hope that it would eventually get better.
Avatar by zandraart.
|
All Comments (0) Comments