|
Apparently my reviewing system is controversial, so let me offer the following disclaimer up front :). These are the take-home points:
- I am too lazy to add shows on here that I don't like very much, so all my scores are going to be biased towards the top end :).
- All scores are completely my own subjective opinion and are completely based on how much *I* liked a given show and/or show element. In other words, I make zero attempt to guess what kind of opinion the larger community might have on any matter. So if you hate all the shows that I give a high rating to, you perhaps shouldn't watch the other ones I give high ratings to either since we clearly have different tastes :).
- This system exists because I am mainly using this page as a record for my own benefit, rather than to provide a service to the community :). Nevertheless, if you find it useful then that is a nice side effect :).
|
All Comments (11) Comments
I wouldn't say you did a good job inspiring people to try it, but you did a good job at getting people to comment on your profile page.
Lol, so it's for balancing out SAO hate... Nevermind I'm responding to a child's play. I thought you were just being an idiot, but you've justified yourself in some way...
But still, a score of 10 to a series that objectively has a handful of flaws is a stretch. And if you "enjoyed it as much as [you] have enjoyed watching any show", why not rate everything a 10 if every show gave you the same amount of enjoyment?
Subjectively, sure giving it a 10 is fine if it's in your opinion. But if you're going to write a review for a larger community, giving it a subjective 10 when the show itself has a handful of flaws isn't fair game. Enjoyment should only be a factor in the equation of reviews.
And if you're going to review something, provide context that'll be helpful in the reader's evaluation of whether or not they should watch it. I'd look at the guidelines for reviews if I were you.
SAO does not deserve all the hate it gets from the anime community, but it is in no ways flawless & deserving of a perfect score.
I'd study up a bit in all honesty so your reviews can improve.