I don't hate One Piece, this is just a perfect example of the shallowness consumers and companies have.
I'm not against "spicy things", I dislike lack of virtue when it comes to childhood, adolescence and sexuality.
I dislike ecchi being used as an excuse for selling lack of coherence and self-respect.
My rating system:
A)Overall:
- Resources (3D, clay, pattern, black and white, saturated, sepia, pattern, textures ...) : +0 to +1
- Moves and facial expression (people, animals, objects): +0 to +1
- Story originality : +0 to +1
- Drawing (proportion, harmony, variety, complexity..):+0 to +1
- Story evolution (unpredictability, turns, arcs, how charaters are introduced...):+0 to +1
- Development of social environment, political environment, economic environment and cultural environment :+0 to +1
- Main characters's complexity (coherence included): +0 to +1
- Secondary character's complexity (coherence included): +0 to +1
- Music (variety of styles, variety of instruments, usefulness, ...)= +0 to +1
- Connection between every element : +0 to +1
Total A=0 to 10 points
B) Extra positive points:
- Studied elements (symbolism, culture, history, mythology, etc..): +0 to +1
- Uncommon elements in anime (drawing, color, music...): +0 to +1
Total B= 0 to 2 points
C) Extra Negative points:
- Forcing main character's personality and/or actions to fit the plot : +0 to -2
- Forcing secondary characters's personality and/or actions to fit the plot: +0 to -2
- Inappropriate elements (light [-0 to -2 ], medium [-3 to -5], serious [-5 to -10])
Total C= +0 to -14 points.
D) Total D=Total A + Total B + Total C
E) Some extra points decide how I round it, MAL system doesn't accept decimals:
All Comments (0) Comments