| "what do you think is the worst genre ever existed" Genre: Avant Garde Theme: Harem |
 |
| Like I already mentioned in another thread, the worst genre is BL because it has a lot of romanticized abuse/rape/non-con/dub-con and its fans tend to be rabid justifying these things by saying that it's LGBT and no one is allowed to criticize it because otherwise they'll immediately be labeled as homophobic. |
 |
| Any genre that is overused, lacks originality and have quantity over quality is unappealing, in anime it’s obvious that isekai, rom com(including harem) and fantasy are most overused genre. Yeah that too^ |
| My least favorite genre is yaoi, because I'm straight male. |
This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement. |
| My least favorite genre still to this day is romcom, never got the appeal of a romantic comedy. |
| Just an avid anime watcher of 18 years, not much else I could say about myself (that I don't want to reveal, of course, just ask if you wanna know more!) "So...look up, face forward, toward your chosen horizon and just...walk on." - Noah, Xenoblade Chronicles 3 |
| *People are really dumb and insane. |
Help! I need somebody. Help! Not just anybody. Help! You know I need someone. Helpppppp!  |
| isekai shouldn't have become a genre, fantasy is enough mecha shouldn't have become a genre, sci-fi is enough but "reincarnated as a villainess in an otome game" takes the cake |
| Battle shounen and Isikai. These two only knows how to copy other peoples homework and refuse to innovate yet people watch it anyways. The main differences is that one is a easy popularity bomb in different skins and the other has haram in a insultingly cliched fictional world with cool magic. |
Ratris_DecisionApr 20, 4:52 AM
| I am not into Boys Love/Yaoi and Hentai. ... |
 |
| Probably battle shonen I guess. Maybe whatever the original Pokemon anime is as well. |
 |
| I think battle shonen is a very boring genre. |
| There is no worst gender, that is very reductionist. The correct thing would be: what gender is not your cup of tea? Anyway, in my case it's the mecha and yaoi. |
| ラーメン食いに行こうぜ～ |
| Isekai. I have a few favorites from there, I don't deny it, but the majority belongs in the trash. I think the same about the ecchi-harem animes of the years 2000-2015. |
Citrone39Apr 20, 6:35 AM
 |
| My least favorite is gay/BL/Yaoi etc. I guess that makes me a homophobe. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time.  |
Reply to Sorachin
There is no worst gender, that is very reductionist. The correct thing would be: what gender is not your cup of tea? Anyway, in my case it's the mecha and yaoi.
| @Sorachin Ah yes. Those aren't very cool genders. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time. |
| There is no worst genre, but there are anime that give certain genres a bad name. |
 |
| It's hard to say what's the worst genre when every genre has had popular and respected shows come out of them. This even includes genres like "Avant Garde" for example. FZREMAKE said: Even the genres you mentioned have had really popular shows come out of them, so I can't say they are objectively the "worst" genres...My least favorite is gay/BL/Yaoi |
 |
Reply to MadanielFL
It's hard to say what's the worst genre when every genre has had popular and respected shows come out of them.
This even includes genres like "Avant Garde" for example.
This even includes genres like "Avant Garde" for example.
FZREMAKE said:
My least favorite is gay/BL/Yaoi
Even the genres you mentioned have had really popular shows come out of them, so I can't say they are objectively the "worst" genres...My least favorite is gay/BL/Yaoi
| @MadanielFL Popular in what sense? I have seen some BL and Yaoi being popular amongst the LBGT community or fujoshis but not much outside. Besides, popularity doesn't necessarily mean better. Almost every genre has had a couple of shows more popular than BL or Yaoi. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time. |
| Mecha and slice of life but Im sure most people would disagree |
| High school romance with tsundere protagonist. :3 |
 |
FZREMAKE said: Well according to MAL, the genre with the least popular "most popular" anime is actually GL not BL, with Citrus having 500k members. Popular in what sense? I have seen some BL and Yaoi being popular amongst the LBGT community or fujoshis but not much outside. Besides, popularity doesn't necessarily mean better. Almost every genre has had a couple of shows more popular than BL or Yaoi And according to scores, the genre with the lowest "highest score" is also GL with YuruYuri S3 at a 7.91 While BL has Given at an 8.32, which is even higher than the highest rated anime on the "Gourmet" genre, which is Food Wars! at 8.14 |
|
| Easily shounen. Teenagers screaming and beating each other up is the least interesting thing for a plot ever. |
| "Well, she's flatter than a pancake" -Mimi Alpacas "Woof" -Tobiichi Origami "Are you trying to turn the dormitory into a strip club!?! -Atena Saotome |
| I can't say what is objectively the worst because I don't believe that there is a universal objective worst. I can only say what are personally the worst to me, as in my least favorite, and those are Comedy, Sports, Ecchi, Harem (including Reverse Harem), and Hentai. There are always exceptions though. For example, I don't care for and am not even interested in starting to watch most Ecchi, yet love Kodomo no Jikan and consider it a high-ranked favorite. I don't care for most Sports genre series and yet like and appreciated various aspects of Hanebado! and Ping Pong the Animation a great deal. |
WatchTillTandavaApr 20, 7:37 PM
Reply to MadanielFL
FZREMAKE said:
Popular in what sense? I have seen some BL and Yaoi being popular amongst the LBGT community or fujoshis but not much outside. Besides, popularity doesn't necessarily mean better. Almost every genre has had a couple of shows more popular than BL or Yaoi
Well according to MAL, the genre with the least popular "most popular" anime is actually GL not BL, with Citrus having 500k members. Popular in what sense? I have seen some BL and Yaoi being popular amongst the LBGT community or fujoshis but not much outside. Besides, popularity doesn't necessarily mean better. Almost every genre has had a couple of shows more popular than BL or Yaoi
And according to scores, the genre with the lowest "highest score" is also GL with YuruYuri S3 at a 7.91
While BL has Given at an 8.32, which is even higher than the highest rated anime on the "Gourmet" genre, which is Food Wars! at 8.14
| @MadanielFL Firstly, GL is also gay so my point still stands. Secondly wtf. Why are you comparing scores and popularity from MAL. Mal isn't a good place to determine this stuff. Especially if we look at scores. BL has a small but dedicated fan base who are obviously going to score the genre highly. If your average anime viewer starting watching BL just like they consume mainstream anime like Kny or Jjk then most of the BL anime wouldn't have 7+ rating. Lastly, I still can't seem to understand how any of this proves that a specific genre is better than the other. You simply can't do that based on 1 or 2 anime. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time. |
FZREMAKE said: My original post already said this, it's very hard to determine what's the "worst genre" but using MAL as a sample, it's GL not BL. Lastly, I still can't seem to understand how any of this proves that a specific genre is better than the other. You simply can't do that based on 1 or 2 anime. And GL has as much of a dedicated fan base as BL, yet no GL anime ever got over 8.00... |
|
| These "x" is the worst genre threads are silly. There's no such thing as a bad genre, just bad anime. Even then, "bad" is completely subjective within the context of the viewer. For any genre, there are anime which succeeded in realizing a strong concept, and those which failed. Genres which have a larger number of "misses" are not bad genres, they're just harder to write a strong story for, while adhering to the formulas and themes which define the genre. |
Reply to MadanielFL
FZREMAKE said:
Lastly, I still can't seem to understand how any of this proves that a specific genre is better than the other. You simply can't do that based on 1 or 2 anime.
My original post already said this, it's very hard to determine what's the "worst genre" but using MAL as a sample, it's GL not BL. Lastly, I still can't seem to understand how any of this proves that a specific genre is better than the other. You simply can't do that based on 1 or 2 anime.
And GL has as much of a dedicated fan base as BL, yet no GL anime ever got over 8.00...
| @MadanielFL Well even if we are for some reasons using MAL as a reference, then shouldn't we look at the average rather than the highest of each genre. Anyways, it will still be pointless to do so since my 1st point in the previous post still stands. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time. |
FZREMAKE said: Well "gay" is not a genre, maybe a "theme", kinda like how isekai is a theme of fantasy.Well even if we are for some reasons using MAL as a reference, then shouldn't we look at the average rather than the highest of each genre. Anyways, it will still be pointless to do so since my 1st point in the previous post still stands. GL and BL are always counted as two distinct genres, in Japan the world of GL and the world of BL are two separate things. |
|
Reply to MadanielFL
FZREMAKE said:
Well even if we are for some reasons using MAL as a reference, then shouldn't we look at the average rather than the highest of each genre. Anyways, it will still be pointless to do so since my 1st point in the previous post still stands.
Well "gay" is not a genre, maybe a "theme", kinda like how isekai is a theme of fantasy.Well even if we are for some reasons using MAL as a reference, then shouldn't we look at the average rather than the highest of each genre. Anyways, it will still be pointless to do so since my 1st point in the previous post still stands.
GL and BL are always counted as two distinct genres, in Japan the world of GL and the world of BL are two separate things.
| @MadanielFL Bruh why are you explaining so much 😭. I meant I don't like both genre even if they are separate. If someone still wants me to pick the worst one from these two then I would pick BL. Its just that simple. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time. |
| Worst genre is subjective. Also you can find good animes in genres you dont like. I dont like watching shoujo but I liked Nana very much. So liking a series depends to genre but it is depends to the how good the anime is. |
 |
| Boys love since I actively avoid them. |
 |
| Is battle shounen a genre? If it isn't, whatever, I still don't like shows that belong in that category. |
"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio- |
| Harem and Isekai you say? Shocker. Also neither are genres, more like sub-genres if anything. To answer your question (sorta) , I've seen "award winning" pop up as a genre on here and that's just complete nonsense. |
| The worst genre in my opinion is isekai. |
More topics from this board
» Do we need more 30 year old waifus?Catalano - Today |
25 |
by DreamingBeats
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» World Masterpiece Theater are hidden gems.Zhenro - 1 hour ago |
6 |
by Soap
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» How can you spend time with your waifu if she's in the entertainment business?Catalano - 7 hours ago |
10 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Your favorite anime OPGoblingaming - Yesterday |
40 |
by GoddessLove
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » are mal reviews full of destructive criticism or constructive criticism?deg - Yesterday |
21 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
12 minutes ago |