Forums

The purpose of this thread is to accommodate adding and removing items on the club list. If there are something you believe should be on the list or shouldn't be, make a post here. If you want to add something on the reject list or remove something already on the club list, please present an explanation.

A series will be accepted if there are 3 or more members vouching for the series being a harem and there are no admin objection.

Golden Rules:

1. No Hentai (pornography)
   
2. Must have at least 3 girls liking (as a guy), loving, or in a physical relationship with the main lead
   
3. If you are requesting material that maybe considered mature, first check the other sticky thread containing the list of borderline cases: http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=209152
   

If an admin verifies that the following items should be added/removed, please make a post so that I can update this list (or update it yourself).

Recommended to be added:


Tentative (All-female harem)
Steel Angel Kurumi 2
Queen's Blade Rebellion

Requested to be Removed:
Elfen Lied (2 vote)

Rejected:

This should definitely be added.

http://myanimelist.net/anime/1944/Photon


Maybe these since they do contain elements of a harem.

http://myanimelist.net/anime/5079/Kurokami

http://myanimelist.net/anime/1158/Geobreeders



Maybe even this series.

This starts out like a harem with Lum and Shinobu fighting over Ataru and eventually Shinobu loses interest and Lums friend tries to get with Ataru(although it is for malicious reasons. To a certain degree it could also be a reverse harem as well with all the male characters interested in Lum. and the male lead Ataru does want a harem which is one of the reasons he seeks out different girls.



http://myanimelist.net/anime/1293/Urusei_Yatsura

For Urusei Yatsura, I am going to go for reject for the same reason you mentioned. I have read the manga and I know that it never got beyond the love triangle that you mentioned. As much as Ataru wants a harem, there weren't any girl that are interested in him except Lum. I guess you can call it a harem-wannabe. It may have been a reverse-harem, but that doesn't really have anything to do with a harem club. If you have further arguments, feel free to present them.

Technically there was also Kurama and Ryoko Mendo who besides Ran and Shinobu who were romantically interested in Ataru..

I don't see neither of them romantically interested in Ataru at any point. Kurama clearly stated she hates his guts and Ryoko is more a prankster enjoying games with Ataru, especially seeing as she says the same thing to other guys. I took a quick look at a few other sites and the anime and manga seems to be consistent with each other on this view.

WTH o.O .... why do u want to remove hand maid may ?????
there are four girls ... okay three arent humans
but who cares xD its one guy and four girls fighting over him
and lots of others around its harem.

*edit* hand maid may is a part of the harem anime history un cant remove that o.O

I think you misread something. Hand Maid May is on the verify list, which is basically a list of stuff that was added (most likely recently) but the person who added it haven't actually watched it. Until now, it was not on the club list.

The 'to be removed' list is currently empty.

On another note, Akikan! rejected, there is only a love triangle straight till the end.

Black God (Kurokami) is definitely not a harem since the only girl's Keita has a relationship with are: Kuro (his companion) & Akane (his ONLY love interest). Excel doesn't count because she's merely an acquaintance and has an intimate relationship with Steiner. This is why more people need to read manga.

ah ... ? ah well whatever ... its harem and not only that its in fact a show u need to be a real harem fan to like it ^^

hahaha akikan the anime should be rejected. but I don't know about the manga. since on the last ep a new girl comes into the harem.

Perhaps we should establish some system like 3 votes from members and it goes in.

xhx:
The new girl at the end of the anime is an anime-original character. Apparently in the light novel, the main guy does get another Akikan although she is more the loli-sister type. Either way, I can't seem to find more than 5 chapters scanlated.

As for history's strongest disciple, I personally think there are too much action although I can see the reasoning behind calling it a harem. Your call.

El Hazard: The Magnificent World is a harem.
http://myanimelist.net/anime/117/El_Hazard:_The_Magnificent_World

So far I haven't seen El-Hazard:The Magnificent world 2, El-Hazard: The Alternative World and El-Hazard: The Wanderers, so I do not know if those series are harems.

I haven't read Kurokami in a while, but last time I checked, it wasn't Harem.

I think your right,I think the anime is more of a love triangle.Its been a awhile since I seen it.

Have you try reading "kiss x sis" It not much an nude manga.

I agree with Luxila.
"Kiss x sis" is a good and funny ecchi harem manga but it's not hentai so I think we can add it to the manga list. (I don't know anything about anime though.)

Yes I have read kiss x sis, and I would label it more on a border case, between ecchi and hentai. Nudity isn't the only concern, the 'activities' for which they participate in is also a problem.

The anime is named since the boundary between ecchi and hentai is much more clear for animes in general. I haven't seen the anime either but I am willing to bet it isn't anywhere near as extreme as the manga.

http://myanimelist.net/anime/115/El_Hazard:_The_Alternative_World


http://myanimelist.net/anime/118/El_Hazard_2:_The_Magnificent_World


I have only seen four episodes of this but it looks like it will follow the same pattern as the others.
http://myanimelist.net/anime/116/El_Hazard:_The_Wanderers

i still think that Isekai no seikishi monogatari should be added to the harem list it has 5+ girls over the main charector sadly no one can finish the last 2 eps bc there not subbed yet but u can still watch the other 11 and know that this is deffenitly a harem its also a tenchi muyo relation

Isekai no Seikishi Monogatari hasn't been rejected and your vote is counted. Two more votes or an admin's vote and it will go on the list.

I am busy at the moment, if no one else wants to watch it, I will check it out sometime later. Fortunately for me, I found Chinese subs for the last two episodes.