BestPanda said: I see people voting for Verumir, and it's interesting considering one of the twins was converted due to the loss of a Mafia member. The last day phase it wasn't worth it, but this phase it suddenly is.
Sleip, did u mean this? Shion was 3rd party and after 1st mafioso died he turned to mafioso of that team. Better read all roles..
Wat.
nothing. Apparently Sleip didn't read roles, so that made a little confusion. That's why ya need to read roles...
BestPanda said: I see people voting for Verumir, and it's interesting considering one of the twins was converted due to the loss of a Mafia member. The last day phase it wasn't worth it, but this phase it suddenly is.
Sleip, did u mean this? Shion was 3rd party and after 1st mafioso died he turned to mafioso of that team. Better read all roles..
Wat.
Well best it does not really matter i think we should lynch both of the twins cuz either way we will never be able to trust the one remaining so it is better to get rid of them both
BestPanda said: She probably is. I mentioned that it was interesting how people wanted to lynch Verumir today, as opposed to yesterday, when there wasn't a conversion in place. Unless Mafia's going to sacrifice their new member, if I see Verumir leading in votes, I might believe that Verumir is the good twin.
whataa, srsly -.-
What makes u think that Verumir is good despite that u think that I am bad?
If you're the good twin I expect you to be leading in votes. Everyone already knows that one of you is Mafia, so either way the evil twin is going to die. The plan should be to post-pone the death and get a free kill.
BestPanda said: If you're the good twin I expect you to be leading in votes. Everyone already knows that one of you is Mafia, so either way the evil twin is going to die. The plan should be to post-pone the death and get a free kill.
^Now I won't be surprised if none of baddies will vote me lol. Maybe that's good lol
Tell me who you suspect, or I'll vote for you. I want at least 2 names, and reasons.
Nya nya i'm a neko desu
Hmm, why?
I suspect aa-dono because she has never done any scum-hunting in this game (At least I think) and mostly contributes on game-setup, that kind of stuff.
She did vote for El-psy, but that more like seems like just following someone else .. 820
Her biggest suspect is BestPanda, but I think he hasn't done anything that fishy yet. Did I mention she doesn't give much reasoning when voting?
SoulEaterQUEEN gives me the same vibes kinda, posts a lot and her thoughts but I don't think it's that neccessary to post that much, makes me think she wants to get town cred for it but maybe just her playstyle.
She also focuses on Soren almost whole game and doesn't really have any other suspects :|
Then few times tried to change attention to Rei, before and after they spoke.
Lol, now that I have re-read the thread, I don't suspect him that much anymore.
Well, playstyle is different because isn't as aggressive and plays more neutral. Does asks questions and pressure, but doesn't try to lead town (I think he would do this)
Doesn't do much to prove that he's town but is just his usual self, whereas willow is opposite. (This could be a point against willow tho)
I wonder if Veru thinks willow will slip on her own and people will suspect her more as game goes on or thinks to prove himself town is to be simply being himself.
I am having a headache now, so I will go to sleep so I might not come back for this day, tho if I will try to wake up and check if there is something what would make me change my mind for vote, cant promise tho.
Both Hime and Soren got back at me with stuff to say about my reads, so they dont look as suspicious to me. I would like to hear more from Soren tho.
I was thinking for some time if I should leave my vote on Rei or vote Chaos who I think is Misa as mentioned before.
@El-Psy
you're really fishing around on the questions for Dio, do you think grave_robber is hiding something besides which role was targetted, or do you think this is a bluff?
Just seems like the questions are written out of panic, but I am willing to give you the benefit of the doubt if I knew more about your approach.
What?
I kinda misinterpreted what she meant, and asked her why did she reveal, when there was a better alternative.
I thought souleaterqueen question made sense, and when el-psy replied with he misinterpret it, my reaction was "huh.. is that it?".
And he didn't say what the better alternative was.
@El-Psy
you're really fishing around on the questions for Dio, do you think grave_robber is hiding something besides which role was targetted, or do you think this is a bluff?
Just seems like the questions are written out of panic, but I am willing to give you the benefit of the doubt if I knew more about your approach.
What?
I kinda misinterpreted what she meant, and asked her why did she reveal, when there was a better alternative.
I thought souleaterqueen question made sense, and when el-psy replied with he misinterpret it, my reaction was "huh.. is that it?".
And he didn't say what the better alternative was.
Now you're misinterpreting it. El-psy is responding to Soul saying that El-psy misunderstood grave_robber.
redwillow said: What are your thoughts so far? Anyone who could be bad or who looks townish? What do u think about Chaos? (if I didn't miss while looking, he commented from 1 to a few posts in 2,5,6,10,12,13 and 17 pages)
Got a few town reads, no real scum reads as of yet because I wasn't focused on that. Chaos is too inactive to have a read on.
redwillow said: Where is Pokeit, Karote, Sleipnir and Tingles? Y so silent?
Lots of commenting awaits me. *gets ready*
I am here. I caught up with the game yesterday and i felt like i did not reall want to joing the discussion yesterday since what i thought was already said by some other players. I also said that in my last post if you want to learn something from me just wrtoe my name and i will come here after seeing the notification. So dont just say he posted something and disappear. I had stated that i would come after i was mentioned since i was not i did not come to the thread
P.S for the ones who does not know @sleipnirr this is a mention.
wan wan i am a inu desu
Well, you shouldn't only post when others ask you something. This looks like you're just lurking which is suspicious. Do you have anything to add now?
Well that is how i usually play. I usually dont like to talk unless i am asked because it usually end up me being lynched even if i am town. It just became a phobia now. Anyway about the current situation i feel like soren right now is playing extremly scummy and he is doing it opnely. And i find that extremly weird. Everyone knows soren here and he does not play that way unless he is after something. I did not read all of the roles so i dont know but is there any role that can benefit from being lynched. Something like jester. Maybe one of the characters have that as a hidden passive. About the twins i believe willow is the good one but i alo think if one of the twins is converted i believe it is willow. Because if i was a mafia she would be the person i would want in my team. I mean even if willow is not the good twin she would still be the one i would convert. That is my current opinion is there anything specific you want to know?
You failed to address the things that you find scummy about me.
I deicded to vote soren for now cuz i believe he is playing this way because he wants to be voted and i want to see what that leads to. If it is just a misunderstanding and he plays that way for another reason i will change my vote to someonelse probably verumir as i think we have to get rid of the twins early game (sorry willow but it is too risky to keep you guys around)
Clearly I want to lynch the twins to get myself lynched...
And why are you voting me if you think my goal is to get myself lynched...?
You just can't help but scum read me every game can you.
@Suzune-chan do you still scum read mkim? Specifically, what do you think of Mkim's read on rinto and thinking that rinto is attempting to breadcrumb a fakeclaim and what does that tell you about Mkim's alignment?
I deicded to vote soren for now cuz i believe he is playing this way because he wants to be voted and i want to see what that leads to. If it is just a misunderstanding and he plays that way for another reason i will change my vote to someonelse probably verumir as i think we have to get rid of the twins early game (sorry willow but it is too risky to keep you guys around)
Clearly I want to lynch the twins to get myself lynched...
And why are you voting me if you think my goal is to get myself lynched...?
You just can't help but scum read me every game can you.
That is true :3 You and Kaito 2 people i wont trust nomatter what also about why i voted you if you wanted to be voted i wanted to see what kind of reaction you will give. Like after seein my vote are you going to just accept as given or are you going to question me about it. Since you are asking this question that means your real goal is not to be voted then if you dont want votes on yourself what is the reason for playing like this. If it was just me i would just pass it as my classic soren biased opion but there are others as well. So why?
Should I have bothered with something? xD
I'm already pretty accustomed to accusations such as yours.
So I try to act in more cold-blooded manner.
As we're basically at nowhere with the lynches etc, I suggest we go with one of dem Twins.
Honestly, both are acting way too fishy though redwillow is more interested in helping the town, rather than disclosing possible suspicion on them which is the way with Verumir. Vote Lynch: Verumir
Sadly, my special ability didn't work for some reason or rather, though I used it on grave_robber.
OMGUS vote. Besides that you completely ignored my questions, I don't like you soft claimed without a necessity either.
I deicded to vote soren for now cuz i believe he is playing this way because he wants to be voted and i want to see what that leads to. If it is just a misunderstanding and he plays that way for another reason i will change my vote to someonelse probably verumir as i think we have to get rid of the twins early game (sorry willow but it is too risky to keep you guys around)
Clearly I want to lynch the twins to get myself lynched...
And why are you voting me if you think my goal is to get myself lynched...?
You just can't help but scum read me every game can you.
I deicded to vote soren for now cuz i believe he is playing this way because he wants to be voted and i want to see what that leads to. If it is just a misunderstanding and he plays that way for another reason i will change my vote to someonelse probably verumir as i think we have to get rid of the twins early game (sorry willow but it is too risky to keep you guys around)
Clearly I want to lynch the twins to get myself lynched...
And why are you voting me if you think my goal is to get myself lynched...?
You just can't help but scum read me every game can you.
That is true :3 You and Kaito 2 people i wont trust nomatter what also about why i voted you if you wanted to be voted i wanted to see what kind of reaction you will give. Like after seein my vote are you going to just accept as given or are you going to question me about it. Since you are asking this question that means your real goal is not to be voted then if you dont want votes on yourself what is the reason for playing like this. If it was just me i would just pass it as my classic soren biased opion but there are others as well. So why?
I deicded to vote soren for now cuz i believe he is playing this way because he wants to be voted and i want to see what that leads to. If it is just a misunderstanding and he plays that way for another reason i will change my vote to someonelse probably verumir as i think we have to get rid of the twins early game (sorry willow but it is too risky to keep you guys around)
Clearly I want to lynch the twins to get myself lynched...
And why are you voting me if you think my goal is to get myself lynched...?
You just can't help but scum read me every game can you.
Why are you so defensive?
He scums reads me every game with no rhyme or reason. It's getting old.
Also, I'm in the lead of votes.
I deicded to vote soren for now cuz i believe he is playing this way because he wants to be voted and i want to see what that leads to. If it is just a misunderstanding and he plays that way for another reason i will change my vote to someonelse probably verumir as i think we have to get rid of the twins early game (sorry willow but it is too risky to keep you guys around)
Clearly I want to lynch the twins to get myself lynched...
And why are you voting me if you think my goal is to get myself lynched...?
You just can't help but scum read me every game can you.
Why are you so defensive?
He scums reads me every game with no rhyme or reason. It's getting old.
Also, I'm in the lead of votes.
Soren yeah i scum read you every game but this time it was not me started to this i was even the last person to vote so why dont you try to defend yourself to them why me? Also if you are trying to catch scum this way i must say this your worst play by far if you ask me.
I deicded to vote soren for now cuz i believe he is playing this way because he wants to be voted and i want to see what that leads to. If it is just a misunderstanding and he plays that way for another reason i will change my vote to someonelse probably verumir as i think we have to get rid of the twins early game (sorry willow but it is too risky to keep you guys around)
Clearly I want to lynch the twins to get myself lynched...
And why are you voting me if you think my goal is to get myself lynched...?
You just can't help but scum read me every game can you.
Why are you so defensive?
He scums reads me every game with no rhyme or reason. It's getting old.
Also, I'm in the lead of votes.
Soren yeah i scum read you every game but this time it was not me started to this i was even the last person to vote so why dont you try to defend yourself to them why me? Also if you are trying to catch scum this way i must say this your worst play by far if you ask me.
I defended against them already. Maybe you should read that post.
I don't like either of the leading trains right now. Soren has been acting very strange, but I feel like he is drawing too much attention to himself to be mafia. I don't feel confident in this, but I want a better read before lynching him.
I don't want to lynch one of the twins. We won't get anywhere by doing so.
I'm going to go with this:
Vote Lynch: Rinto-kun
I'm skeptical of the way you've been acting. You keep dropping hints. Then you'll brush it off like it was nothing. Either you are being careless with your information, or you are trying way too hard to appear town like.
We can't confirm anything you are saying, so I struggle to see why you are saying it at all.
I'm going to sleep, too many players make my head spin, I had to force myself to remember some players, anyway here is my useless read list.
Leaning Scum
KOtA
--> Said was going to vote, and didn't vote, he appears to now enjoy being the center of attention either.
PentaFlare
--> I have played two games where he was scum, he changed his approach in every one of them, so he playing differently right now means nothing to me
--> I'm biased but I'll see him as mafia, his actions that most got me suspicious is his approach regarding the twins, overall not a bad lynch target but my tricks won't work in him anymore as I tried them on day one.
Chione/grrr
-->Chione changed a bit of attitude during this day phase, I think she (now grrr) was converted unfortunately I can't ask anything about it because she was replaced with grrr.
El-Psy_Congroo
-->Voted for me without really explaining why, as so most people here, I wonder when mafia games got to the point where it doesn't matter to ask people question or anything at all, you are just going to vote for them because you will, seem he just hoped in to a nice opportunity.
Rinto-kun
--> Doesn't reply to my question or Mkim, softclaims, and overall doesn't have any pro-town attitude.
redwillow (confirmed Scum)
--> I can get much information about other scum with her as mostly she just sheep the votes.
ChaosSaviour
--> I suspect him for most of the reasons which have been already said.
Neutral
Mkim
--> Makes good jokes
Soren
-->Soren is trying to lynch me for merely some sort of chance of catching scum that he thinks it should be higher with my posts, I thought he was doing some kind of plan, but it seems he barely read the game, I don't expect him playing so poorly if scum either.
SoulEaterQUEEN
--> Panicked with Soren's vote
--> Played differently then on day one saying it was experimenting
--> I pressured her and she decided to vote
All of her replies to me were mostly honest, however the only one that got my attention was when she said her change of pattern on day one was a mistake without giving good reasons.
NepBandit
--> I have to agree with Jack on this one (not an opinion he gave this game), this is a difficult player to read where he could simply hide suspicious behavior in his absence and way to be, so that's why its just easier for cop to chem them out.
RedTie and Sleipnirr
--> I have no good reads in these two didn't focused in any of them.
tinglespalace
--> Said was catching up with the game and disappeared.
Hime-sama
--> There isn't much to analyse but her vote on Rei had reasonable arguments however if her votes from now one are with players with not much votes on, its something to take notice.
Townie
aa-dono
--> Has collected and more independent opinions from most players, I guess this could get her seeing as scum, but as of now most of her reasons were legit, and
Pokeit
--> While he had some actions that caught some people's attention, his reaction to the build up lynch train and arguments was legit, and made me think he was town.
Suzune-chan
--> It seems that a lot of people got masters degree in reading Suzune and I lost this class somewhere, she didn't stand out much on day one, although her vote for Luna was something that seemed odd to me (hiding OMGUS) her reasoning was good, and overall her interaction with player have been mostly pro-town.
Rei
--> Is the type of player who likes to hold information, it give them sensation of control and its at the very least not a mafia trying to appear town.
Karote
--> I always thought of Karote as a player who peruses scum in his own way at his own pace, he seems to have been changing now, most of his vote as well as his reasoning look townish to me
grave_robber
--> Is ever since the started of the game trying to get me killed, acts pro-town most of the time, I'm waiting for her to answer my questions so I can give a better view.
Luna
--> I have no idea with this one, all of her posts seems generic somehow, but my gut tells me she is town.
coromandel
--> Nya nya I'm neko desu
--> coromandel is the voice of reason, she is questioning players and while she doesn't appear to want to control town I can't actually say this is a bad thing.
BestPanda
--> He ask the most interesting questions, so far if we ignore his peruse with the twins he is the player whom I got most town reads from.
--> Said was going to vote, and didn't vote, he appears to now enjoy being the center of attention either.
am i really center of attention?
well i didn't vote yet because i don't want to follow any of the current votes that i don't agree with, and i'm having hard time getting reads on people.
==
am i going to not vote d2 ? No
who am i gonna vote ? IDK, i'm working on it
I'm keeping my vote on Rinto (for his actions) I don't know which twin should be lynched anymore and I feel like mafia are manipulating it.
Even if we lynch one of them, we won't gain any info whatsoever. One of them is mafia, but we can still keep close eye on them, so their actions are limited.
Satsuki Kiryuuin decided that ChaosSaviour was unworthy of continuing the fight.
The group of anime characters decided Russian Roulette was the best way to solve their issues. BAM! A bullet had lodged itself into SoulEaterQUEEN's head. Luckily the bullet was coated in garlic and shaped like a cross.
Dio Brando[Vampire] - SoulEaterQUEEN was lynched! Saber[Servant] - ChaosSaviourl has died!
Soren said: @Suzune-chan do you still scum read mkim? Specifically, what do you think of Mkim's read on rinto and thinking that rinto is attempting to breadcrumb a fakeclaim and what does that tell you about Mkim's alignment?
Yes I still scum read mkim. I think his actions this phase have been questionable especially considering the little stunt with the picture.
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween!