New
Jun 21, 2016 9:42 AM
#601
_Claire_ said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. Shinichi-Kun said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: PentaFlare said: Hmm, if Shinichi is scum, what do you think about his attempt to make a counter train so early? Is that too obvious to be an attempt to save a ally? Not entirely sure if it would be to save an ally directly, or just to mess with the voting. Messing with the voting is fun, i just didn't wanna see kasai get day 1 lynched yet again cause im tired of that >_>, but i mean you can see the counter vote however you want This post I find odd. I heard Kasai always played scummy and such but it didnt mean you couldnt pressure him day 1 and it was just a quarter part of the game yet you seem like you are scared/provide a distraction out of Kasai. You know half phase of day 1, the vote is most likely gonna change. Are you defending him? *cough* but anyway its noted. I dont see how Queen was acting different probably because ive not played with her for close to two months, but I cant see how she is very scummy and I would rather her alive now as she is a goodscumhunter. She has proven that in previous games and she could be a great asset to town. Soren, Soren. Is it just me or most are totally townreading you? I couldnt deny that I am townreading you a bit from your post but neither has anyone pressured you into anything. I am cautious now. It reminds me of how Jack was so trusted in prev games, which sometimes isnt always a good thing. I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. @Crossbell @Bee-boy I have not played with you before. I am looking forward to it :P Nah it was different because Kasai basically became a policy lynch for people to fall back on when they couldn't trust their reads it was so unfair for him >_> Also Playstyle change shouldn't be alignment indictive but like im being scum read for it and alice is being town read smh Yeah I got what youre trying to say. I know you have huge view on that one, but thing is we should not overlook Kasai in this case because even tho it seems he is always acting scummy and ppl tend not to be able to read him there is a possibility he could be a scum, so why not pressure him and try to see his reaction? It totally seems you are trying to get attention off him. Even though why you should do that is beyond me, I could understand if ppl pressure him and then just stay on him the whole phase without clear reasoning, but it isnt the case here right? See I don't mind that but everytime someone says they are just pressuring the train always leads to lynch on him like literally everytime. You know this is a lie. It does not always lead to lynching him cause most people know he plays scummy. Well it's obvious you dont know me. When you joined that phase had already passed but there used to be a time in Mafia Society that me and El-psy-Congroo would always lynched day 1 Edit: Just fixed typos. Yeah but I know in recent games where I was there, you were "ignored" because of your scummy play, like they accept the fact you were always playing scummy even if you are town. I could still remember where you won that game alone. Dont remember which I think you were SK or Arsonist or sth. I want to see more of Lamby, aa-dono, and Togs. They barely said anything. Even though if its from Lamby I mostly wont understand him. haha yeah that game was a blast. Anyway you know the saying you cant teach an old dog new trick. So if start to day 1 lynch me again I think that wave would continue till the end of the summer. Maybe he is trying to prevent that. Other than that I dont know any reason why would he protect me. That is why I decided to put my vote on you :> Shinichi defending you is very weird, and I see no reason why he would do that, except his strong point of view. But most people already know how you play, it shouldnt be a problem. I will see if I can get something out of this. Should I start by, what is your general view atm? aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Doesn't that contradict with your tendency to use meta?Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I think that only applies to my first and second game. After that everything I do is deemed scummy, be it lurking or asking questions.I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. To be honest, a lot of people use meta-read to some extend. Some not so much, some more. Once again, I really don't want to have another meta-read argument, its like repeating me vs Queen all over again which I would rather not repeat. Kasai said: aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Doesn't that contradict with your tendency to use meta?Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I think that only applies to my first and second game. After that everything I do is deemed scummy, be it lurking or asking questions.I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. But last time I checked most players in the MS were against using metas in games and reason for voting. I mean it failed for so many times and as said before it can be changed easily. Why would claire be using it? If she did that would just be stupid. After RNG meta is the worst way to vote. I play the games the way I see most fit. If most people dont agree, they cannot make me agree to something I dont want to agree. atta girl! Keep doing that. For that very same reason I became the so called lynch hot spot but won in the end so I guess you can do the same Now my general view is I dont have any thing. I am reading as I am posting right now what picked my attention the most was your statement saying that nobody checked soren and quickly labeled him as town. I have seen this before with other experienced players namely jack and grave. People tend to pick them as town leaders and if they turn up to be scums it would mean insta loss for town so for now I am trying to find Soren's posts other than that I found Izaya's (Kaito's) arguement with queen very intresting. Thats all I can say before completly catching up. Yep I think that is one point where everyone literally overlooks. How they are like townreading Soren so fast. Like so fast. Yeah Jack, I know right. Lol.. And as usual, nobody takes notice of that. :') Well our players usually have herd mind so I guess nothing can be done. They just like to follow someone. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:42 AM
#602
PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:43 AM
#603
Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. Shinichi-Kun said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: PentaFlare said: Hmm, if Shinichi is scum, what do you think about his attempt to make a counter train so early? Is that too obvious to be an attempt to save a ally? Not entirely sure if it would be to save an ally directly, or just to mess with the voting. Messing with the voting is fun, i just didn't wanna see kasai get day 1 lynched yet again cause im tired of that >_>, but i mean you can see the counter vote however you want This post I find odd. I heard Kasai always played scummy and such but it didnt mean you couldnt pressure him day 1 and it was just a quarter part of the game yet you seem like you are scared/provide a distraction out of Kasai. You know half phase of day 1, the vote is most likely gonna change. Are you defending him? *cough* but anyway its noted. I dont see how Queen was acting different probably because ive not played with her for close to two months, but I cant see how she is very scummy and I would rather her alive now as she is a goodscumhunter. She has proven that in previous games and she could be a great asset to town. Soren, Soren. Is it just me or most are totally townreading you? I couldnt deny that I am townreading you a bit from your post but neither has anyone pressured you into anything. I am cautious now. It reminds me of how Jack was so trusted in prev games, which sometimes isnt always a good thing. I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. @Crossbell @Bee-boy I have not played with you before. I am looking forward to it :P Nah it was different because Kasai basically became a policy lynch for people to fall back on when they couldn't trust their reads it was so unfair for him >_> Also Playstyle change shouldn't be alignment indictive but like im being scum read for it and alice is being town read smh Yeah I got what youre trying to say. I know you have huge view on that one, but thing is we should not overlook Kasai in this case because even tho it seems he is always acting scummy and ppl tend not to be able to read him there is a possibility he could be a scum, so why not pressure him and try to see his reaction? It totally seems you are trying to get attention off him. Even though why you should do that is beyond me, I could understand if ppl pressure him and then just stay on him the whole phase without clear reasoning, but it isnt the case here right? See I don't mind that but everytime someone says they are just pressuring the train always leads to lynch on him like literally everytime. You know this is a lie. It does not always lead to lynching him cause most people know he plays scummy. claire u started playing long after he stopped lol how you gonna tell me? I already told her she just doesnt understand. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:43 AM
#604
Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. Shinichi-Kun said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: PentaFlare said: Hmm, if Shinichi is scum, what do you think about his attempt to make a counter train so early? Is that too obvious to be an attempt to save a ally? Not entirely sure if it would be to save an ally directly, or just to mess with the voting. Messing with the voting is fun, i just didn't wanna see kasai get day 1 lynched yet again cause im tired of that >_>, but i mean you can see the counter vote however you want This post I find odd. I heard Kasai always played scummy and such but it didnt mean you couldnt pressure him day 1 and it was just a quarter part of the game yet you seem like you are scared/provide a distraction out of Kasai. You know half phase of day 1, the vote is most likely gonna change. Are you defending him? *cough* but anyway its noted. I dont see how Queen was acting different probably because ive not played with her for close to two months, but I cant see how she is very scummy and I would rather her alive now as she is a goodscumhunter. She has proven that in previous games and she could be a great asset to town. Soren, Soren. Is it just me or most are totally townreading you? I couldnt deny that I am townreading you a bit from your post but neither has anyone pressured you into anything. I am cautious now. It reminds me of how Jack was so trusted in prev games, which sometimes isnt always a good thing. I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. @Crossbell @Bee-boy I have not played with you before. I am looking forward to it :P Nah it was different because Kasai basically became a policy lynch for people to fall back on when they couldn't trust their reads it was so unfair for him >_> Also Playstyle change shouldn't be alignment indictive but like im being scum read for it and alice is being town read smh Yeah I got what youre trying to say. I know you have huge view on that one, but thing is we should not overlook Kasai in this case because even tho it seems he is always acting scummy and ppl tend not to be able to read him there is a possibility he could be a scum, so why not pressure him and try to see his reaction? It totally seems you are trying to get attention off him. Even though why you should do that is beyond me, I could understand if ppl pressure him and then just stay on him the whole phase without clear reasoning, but it isnt the case here right? See I don't mind that but everytime someone says they are just pressuring the train always leads to lynch on him like literally everytime. You know this is a lie. It does not always lead to lynching him cause most people know he plays scummy. claire u started playing long after he stopped lol how you gonna tell me? I have been the victim of the game, please now. Get into the game and lets get over this Shinich-defending-Kasai-by-getting-off-the-attention whole thing. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:45 AM
#605
SoulEaterQUEEN said: Shinichi-Kun said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: Shinichi-Kun said: Honestly I don't whats different from this game and how i played in the lol mafia its pretty much the same. league of legends mafia? Do you mind pulling up examples from here? Ur the one that think's im scum but you havent cross referenced any games to prove my meta change is scum smh -___- WTF! I wasn't in that game, I read past games, but I haven't read every game. I don't know how many times I told you that I am not voting you for your meta change, like OMG. You refuse to listen to what people say, and you still have showed me for the third time you have not read my posts. I've have enough of this because you are distracting me with your anti-town behaviour, if you are town, please for the love of god start doing something instead of being on the defense. There's more than 24 hours to go, I don't see scum hunting from you either, I can't fully blame you because you have been attacked but I need to see something more from you rather than responses to posts when it comes to yourself, or defending an inactive player. I don't have a sense of where your reads are even at for the other players, you are tunnelling me, and you got pissed at Jack for doing the same thing, so stop acting like a hypocrite and playing the victim card. You also latched on to Beeboy's reasonings on the alignment - playstyle thing, and Penta's reasonings on why they had suspected me. You are not even showing independent thinking, and you are acting like you have. Your interactions with me earlier on just showed neutral responses, and it feels to me that when suspicion of me came to light you jumped on me like an opportunist. Also, don't be afraid to attack Soren's case either, you are playing chicken and I don't like it. been to distracted to make reads on top of that gotta keep defending myself lol. Sorry but tell me why im scummy then because i can't find it any posts no amtter how much i back read it all mosts to my behavior being strange. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:46 AM
#606
_Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. Your tone was rhetorical. You were very clearly expecting me to answer with a yes. Even though I have been spending most of this game stating that I don't want to vote someone I am not reading as scum and that I have been working hard digging up things to support my votes. That should have been evident from my vote on you, which you definitely read. I am voting with lynch intent right now. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Jun 21, 2016 9:46 AM
#607
Kasai said: aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. But last time I checked most players in the MS were against using metas in games and reason for voting. I mean it failed for so many times and as said before it can be changed easily. Why would claire be using it? If she did that would just be stupid. After RNG meta is the worst way to vote. Not sure if she change the way she plays during her breaks and mine, but the Claire I remember used to rely a lot on meta. Most players in MS were against using meta? I didn't know that. I see more people using it than not :/ I can't say it failed. I don't use meta coz I have bad memory of other people's game including my own but my last game, they caught mafia just by meta. And Soul also pointed out how she thinks scum Jack plays differently than town Jack. Shinichi defended you because of meta too, so meta is something a lot of players like to use. Question: Did you not notice that? Why? Even if you think MS players doesn't like it, it has been brought up in this game. Were you reading posts selectively? |
Jun 21, 2016 9:48 AM
#608
aa-dono said: Shinichi-Kun said: Was your vote justified? If you cared about your vote, you wouldn't forget your own vote.Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: PentaFlare said: I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. I would say it is more the fact he is acting strange in general and is happy to train someone but not suffer the conquesences for the actions. normally he does not train someone like he did on crossbell so I would say this is a bit different. Trains are fun idk what your talking about and my counter wagon was RVS i don't scum read cross at all still back reading tho. A counter train by nature is not RVS so don't even pretend it is you are voting to take pressure off another. Also you seemed happy for it to build on someone you did not scum read Idk was just random lol he was the first that came to mind when i thought of creating a counter train whats wrong with that? Is it that weird for me to choose crossbell? Not sure just a strange option, Crossbell is not someone I would consider voting tbh and espically when not even posted. My point of view I guess is if I was going to do a counter train I would have more reason on the person I pick. I can change my counter train to someone else if thats the problem like alice for example but not yet. @_claire_ What do you think about my meta change compared to alice meta change? Based off the last vote list you are voting Alice so why say you will change to them later. Oh i totally forgot I changed my vote to her :D Mostly a place holder because shes a slight scum read |
Jun 21, 2016 9:49 AM
#609
Kasai said: Shin-chan's not drunk. Are you defending him? Sarcasm? (I'm a baka, so I have to ask)aa-dono said: Shinichi-Kun said: Is it that weird for me to choose crossbell? Are you asking for confirmation if that vote is weird? Why do you question your own vote? Maybe he drunk voted? |
Jun 21, 2016 9:50 AM
#610
aa-dono said: Kasai said: aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Doesn't that contradict with your tendency to use meta?Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I think that only applies to my first and second game. After that everything I do is deemed scummy, be it lurking or asking questions.I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. But last time I checked most players in the MS were against using metas in games and reason for voting. I mean it failed for so many times and as said before it can be changed easily. Why would claire be using it? If she did that would just be stupid. After RNG meta is the worst way to vote. Not sure if she change the way she plays during her breaks and mine, but the Claire I remember used to rely a lot on meta. Most players in MS were against using meta? I didn't know that. I see more people using it than not :/ I can't say it failed. I don't use meta coz I have bad memory of other people's game including my own but my last game, they caught mafia just by meta. And Soul also pointed out how she thinks scum Jack plays differently than town Jack. Shinichi defended you because of meta too, so meta is something a lot of players like to use. Question: Did you not notice that? Why? Even if you think MS players doesn't like it, it has been brought up in this game. Were you reading posts selectively? I did not say they dont use it. They are just against using it because it is too unstable. In some cases it works and in some it does not. Also its mostly wrong than right. That was why some players were against using it. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:52 AM
#611
aa-dono said: Kasai said: Shin-chan's not drunk. Are you defending him? Sarcasm? (I'm a baka, so I have to ask)aa-dono said: Shinichi-Kun said: Is it that weird for me to choose crossbell? Are you asking for confirmation if that vote is weird? Why do you question your own vote? Maybe he drunk voted? Sarcasm. I tend to do that a lot. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:52 AM
#612
Quite annoying how every game where im town i get called anti town but when im actually scum no one pressures me this much lol i just can't be a townie without being anti town. Someone wants to pin point what makes me antitown game then go ahead but not gonna keep rereading the thread over and over to find more reasons that make me anti town cause i've come to conclusion i am anti-town townie accept that or lynch me so i can flip my town aligned role. So tempted to roleclaim because this dumb lmao |
Jun 21, 2016 9:53 AM
#613
Claire is trying way to hard to move attention onto Kasai. It reminds me of what Soul said about Jack usually pushing someone until they appear scummy when he is mafia. She is pushing a lot for someone she adamantly insist is a nullread for her. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Jun 21, 2016 9:54 AM
#614
Jun 21, 2016 9:55 AM
#615
PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. Your tone was rhetorical. You were very clearly expecting me to answer with a yes. Even though I have been spending most of this game stating that I don't want to vote someone I am not reading as scum and that I have been working hard digging up things to support my votes. That should have been evident from my vote on you, which you definitely read. I am voting with lynch intent right now. You cant even hear my tone, lol. I think if I said now that I expected you to answer it either with a yes or no, you would not believe me. But it was a pressure vote as I think we are tunneling vision Shinichi and Queen a bit too much, I was interested and Kasai. How could I find him very suspicious if he has not even said a word? I was trying to get him talking. |
Jun 21, 2016 9:58 AM
#616
_Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. Your tone was rhetorical. You were very clearly expecting me to answer with a yes. Even though I have been spending most of this game stating that I don't want to vote someone I am not reading as scum and that I have been working hard digging up things to support my votes. That should have been evident from my vote on you, which you definitely read. I am voting with lynch intent right now. You cant even hear my tone, lol. I think if I said now that I expected you to answer it either with a yes or no, you would not believe me. But it was a pressure vote as I think we are tunneling vision Shinichi and Queen a bit too much, I was interested and Kasai. How could I find him very suspicious if he has not even said a word? I was trying to get him talking. The way you said "were you seriously" implies that you had massive doubts I could have been doing anything else. You were not expecting either answer. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Jun 21, 2016 9:58 AM
#617
PentaFlare said: Claire is trying way to hard to move attention onto Kasai. It reminds me of what Soul said about Jack usually pushing someone until they appear scummy when he is mafia. She is pushing a lot for someone she adamantly insist is a nullread for her. Penta, if anything I dislike from you is how you seem to conclude a bit too much sometimes, or exaggerating. It is still 23 hours more, I can pressure-vote a bit before I actually vote for someone I think is scum right? :> |
Jun 21, 2016 10:02 AM
#618
PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. Your tone was rhetorical. You were very clearly expecting me to answer with a yes. Even though I have been spending most of this game stating that I don't want to vote someone I am not reading as scum and that I have been working hard digging up things to support my votes. That should have been evident from my vote on you, which you definitely read. I am voting with lynch intent right now. You cant even hear my tone, lol. I think if I said now that I expected you to answer it either with a yes or no, you would not believe me. But it was a pressure vote as I think we are tunneling vision Shinichi and Queen a bit too much, I was interested and Kasai. How could I find him very suspicious if he has not even said a word? I was trying to get him talking. The way you said "were you seriously" implies that you had massive doubts I could have been doing anything else. You were not expecting either answer. If you say I dont. I think I know myself better than you do, Penta. I expect you to elaborate yes or no. |
Jun 21, 2016 10:04 AM
#619
Shinichi-Kun said: aa-dono said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: PentaFlare said: I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. I would say it is more the fact he is acting strange in general and is happy to train someone but not suffer the conquesences for the actions. normally he does not train someone like he did on crossbell so I would say this is a bit different. Trains are fun idk what your talking about and my counter wagon was RVS i don't scum read cross at all still back reading tho. A counter train by nature is not RVS so don't even pretend it is you are voting to take pressure off another. Also you seemed happy for it to build on someone you did not scum read Idk was just random lol he was the first that came to mind when i thought of creating a counter train whats wrong with that? Is it that weird for me to choose crossbell? Not sure just a strange option, Crossbell is not someone I would consider voting tbh and espically when not even posted. My point of view I guess is if I was going to do a counter train I would have more reason on the person I pick. I can change my counter train to someone else if thats the problem like alice for example but not yet. @_claire_ What do you think about my meta change compared to alice meta change? Based off the last vote list you are voting Alice so why say you will change to them later. Oh i totally forgot I changed my vote to her :D Mostly a place holder because shes a slight scum read For a slight scum read, you seem to be focused on her. Do you have other reads? |
Jun 21, 2016 10:12 AM
#620
Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. Shinichi-Kun said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: PentaFlare said: Hmm, if Shinichi is scum, what do you think about his attempt to make a counter train so early? Is that too obvious to be an attempt to save a ally? Not entirely sure if it would be to save an ally directly, or just to mess with the voting. Messing with the voting is fun, i just didn't wanna see kasai get day 1 lynched yet again cause im tired of that >_>, but i mean you can see the counter vote however you want This post I find odd. I heard Kasai always played scummy and such but it didnt mean you couldnt pressure him day 1 and it was just a quarter part of the game yet you seem like you are scared/provide a distraction out of Kasai. You know half phase of day 1, the vote is most likely gonna change. Are you defending him? *cough* but anyway its noted. I dont see how Queen was acting different probably because ive not played with her for close to two months, but I cant see how she is very scummy and I would rather her alive now as she is a goodscumhunter. She has proven that in previous games and she could be a great asset to town. Soren, Soren. Is it just me or most are totally townreading you? I couldnt deny that I am townreading you a bit from your post but neither has anyone pressured you into anything. I am cautious now. It reminds me of how Jack was so trusted in prev games, which sometimes isnt always a good thing. I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. @Crossbell @Bee-boy I have not played with you before. I am looking forward to it :P Nah it was different because Kasai basically became a policy lynch for people to fall back on when they couldn't trust their reads it was so unfair for him >_> Also Playstyle change shouldn't be alignment indictive but like im being scum read for it and alice is being town read smh Yeah I got what youre trying to say. I know you have huge view on that one, but thing is we should not overlook Kasai in this case because even tho it seems he is always acting scummy and ppl tend not to be able to read him there is a possibility he could be a scum, so why not pressure him and try to see his reaction? It totally seems you are trying to get attention off him. Even though why you should do that is beyond me, I could understand if ppl pressure him and then just stay on him the whole phase without clear reasoning, but it isnt the case here right? See I don't mind that but everytime someone says they are just pressuring the train always leads to lynch on him like literally everytime. You know this is a lie. It does not always lead to lynching him cause most people know he plays scummy. Well it's obvious you dont know me. When you joined that phase had already passed but there used to be a time in Mafia Society that me and El-psy-Congroo would always lynched day 1 Edit: Just fixed typos. Yeah but I know in recent games where I was there, you were "ignored" because of your scummy play, like they accept the fact you were always playing scummy even if you are town. I could still remember where you won that game alone. Dont remember which I think you were SK or Arsonist or sth. I want to see more of Lamby, aa-dono, and Togs. They barely said anything. Even though if its from Lamby I mostly wont understand him. Oh also before I forget remember Soren's first vote and what Jack commented about it. Jack said I was his first choice as a lynch if not for Soren's vote. Even from this you can see the remains of my being voted for day 1 continuosly. As I said you cant teach an old dog new tricks. I wouldnt be suprised if I would get voted today. They is a very different reason for why I wanted to vote you and it has nothing to do with a lynch, if I wanted that why would I not vote you with Soren. |
Jun 21, 2016 10:12 AM
#621
_Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. Your tone was rhetorical. You were very clearly expecting me to answer with a yes. Even though I have been spending most of this game stating that I don't want to vote someone I am not reading as scum and that I have been working hard digging up things to support my votes. That should have been evident from my vote on you, which you definitely read. I am voting with lynch intent right now. You cant even hear my tone, lol. I think if I said now that I expected you to answer it either with a yes or no, you would not believe me. But it was a pressure vote as I think we are tunneling vision Shinichi and Queen a bit too much, I was interested and Kasai. How could I find him very suspicious if he has not even said a word? I was trying to get him talking. The way you said "were you seriously" implies that you had massive doubts I could have been doing anything else. You were not expecting either answer. If you say I dont. I think I know myself better than you do, Penta. I expect you to elaborate yes or no. Do I have to repeat it again? No. The only time I voted this game without suspicions or with lynch intent was my RVS vote. I have been very clear this game that I want to focus on analyzing the behaviour of others as the basis for my votes. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Jun 21, 2016 10:13 AM
#622
PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. Your tone was rhetorical. You were very clearly expecting me to answer with a yes. Even though I have been spending most of this game stating that I don't want to vote someone I am not reading as scum and that I have been working hard digging up things to support my votes. That should have been evident from my vote on you, which you definitely read. I am voting with lynch intent right now. You cant even hear my tone, lol. I think if I said now that I expected you to answer it either with a yes or no, you would not believe me. But it was a pressure vote as I think we are tunneling vision Shinichi and Queen a bit too much, I was interested and Kasai. How could I find him very suspicious if he has not even said a word? I was trying to get him talking. The way you said "were you seriously" implies that you had massive doubts I could have been doing anything else. You were not expecting either answer. If you say I dont. I think I know myself better than you do, Penta. I expect you to elaborate yes or no. Do I have to repeat it again? No. The only time I voted this game without suspicions or with lynch intent was my RVS vote. I have been very clear this game that I want to focus on analyzing the behaviour of others as the basis for my votes. By that, you mean meta-reading? |
Jun 21, 2016 10:18 AM
#623
_Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: _Claire_ said: PentaFlare said: @_Claire_ Why are you voting for Kasai? What reason do you have for that scumread? Edit: ninja'd Penta you really really need to read my post. I said my vote was a pressure vote. .__. I am not scumreading him. Not yet at least. I have not concluded yet, he just arrived. So what is your read? I can't imagine you would pressure someone if you weren't suspicious of them. Penta, during your first few votes, were you seriously suspicious of them? Werent you just voting for them for "pressure" and reaction? Cause that is what I am doing. Shinichi has been pressured long enough, I think we need to get out of this tunnel vision of Shinichi and Queen whole thing and try to get new information. I have cast three votes this game. My first one was RVS, my second was on Soul and I was legitimately suspicious, and my final was on you and I am scumreading you quite heavily. I really dislike how quickly you jump to incorrect conclusions. At this point in the game, I would not vote a null read unless it was the only way to ensure a lynch. Can you explain "incorrect conclusions"? You said I wasn't suspicious of the people I was voting for. That is incorrect. Umm, there was a question mark there? lol. Your tone was rhetorical. You were very clearly expecting me to answer with a yes. Even though I have been spending most of this game stating that I don't want to vote someone I am not reading as scum and that I have been working hard digging up things to support my votes. That should have been evident from my vote on you, which you definitely read. I am voting with lynch intent right now. You cant even hear my tone, lol. I think if I said now that I expected you to answer it either with a yes or no, you would not believe me. But it was a pressure vote as I think we are tunneling vision Shinichi and Queen a bit too much, I was interested and Kasai. How could I find him very suspicious if he has not even said a word? I was trying to get him talking. The way you said "were you seriously" implies that you had massive doubts I could have been doing anything else. You were not expecting either answer. If you say I dont. I think I know myself better than you do, Penta. I expect you to elaborate yes or no. Do I have to repeat it again? No. The only time I voted this game without suspicions or with lynch intent was my RVS vote. I have been very clear this game that I want to focus on analyzing the behaviour of others as the basis for my votes. By that, you mean meta-reading? Yes. A significant portion of my read on you is meta. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Jun 21, 2016 10:19 AM
#624
Kasai said: aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. But last time I checked most players in the MS were against using metas in games and reason for voting. I mean it failed for so many times and as said before it can be changed easily. Why would claire be using it? If she did that would just be stupid. After RNG meta is the worst way to vote. I would not say Meta is a bad way to vote if it can be backed up. so not sure why you think meta is pointless. |
Jun 21, 2016 10:21 AM
#625
Jackrito said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. Shinichi-Kun said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: PentaFlare said: Hmm, if Shinichi is scum, what do you think about his attempt to make a counter train so early? Is that too obvious to be an attempt to save a ally? Not entirely sure if it would be to save an ally directly, or just to mess with the voting. Messing with the voting is fun, i just didn't wanna see kasai get day 1 lynched yet again cause im tired of that >_>, but i mean you can see the counter vote however you want This post I find odd. I heard Kasai always played scummy and such but it didnt mean you couldnt pressure him day 1 and it was just a quarter part of the game yet you seem like you are scared/provide a distraction out of Kasai. You know half phase of day 1, the vote is most likely gonna change. Are you defending him? *cough* but anyway its noted. I dont see how Queen was acting different probably because ive not played with her for close to two months, but I cant see how she is very scummy and I would rather her alive now as she is a goodscumhunter. She has proven that in previous games and she could be a great asset to town. Soren, Soren. Is it just me or most are totally townreading you? I couldnt deny that I am townreading you a bit from your post but neither has anyone pressured you into anything. I am cautious now. It reminds me of how Jack was so trusted in prev games, which sometimes isnt always a good thing. I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. @Crossbell @Bee-boy I have not played with you before. I am looking forward to it :P Nah it was different because Kasai basically became a policy lynch for people to fall back on when they couldn't trust their reads it was so unfair for him >_> Also Playstyle change shouldn't be alignment indictive but like im being scum read for it and alice is being town read smh Yeah I got what youre trying to say. I know you have huge view on that one, but thing is we should not overlook Kasai in this case because even tho it seems he is always acting scummy and ppl tend not to be able to read him there is a possibility he could be a scum, so why not pressure him and try to see his reaction? It totally seems you are trying to get attention off him. Even though why you should do that is beyond me, I could understand if ppl pressure him and then just stay on him the whole phase without clear reasoning, but it isnt the case here right? See I don't mind that but everytime someone says they are just pressuring the train always leads to lynch on him like literally everytime. You know this is a lie. It does not always lead to lynching him cause most people know he plays scummy. Well it's obvious you dont know me. When you joined that phase had already passed but there used to be a time in Mafia Society that me and El-psy-Congroo would always lynched day 1 Edit: Just fixed typos. Yeah but I know in recent games where I was there, you were "ignored" because of your scummy play, like they accept the fact you were always playing scummy even if you are town. I could still remember where you won that game alone. Dont remember which I think you were SK or Arsonist or sth. I want to see more of Lamby, aa-dono, and Togs. They barely said anything. Even though if its from Lamby I mostly wont understand him. Oh also before I forget remember Soren's first vote and what Jack commented about it. Jack said I was his first choice as a lynch if not for Soren's vote. Even from this you can see the remains of my being voted for day 1 continuosly. As I said you cant teach an old dog new tricks. I wouldnt be suprised if I would get voted today. They is a very different reason for why I wanted to vote you and it has nothing to do with a lynch, if I wanted that why would I not vote you with Soren. I did not say you wanted to lynch me. Even if you dont people still tend to vote me first day phase. More often then not. |
Jun 21, 2016 10:24 AM
#626
Jackrito said: Kasai said: aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Doesn't that contradict with your tendency to use meta?Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I think that only applies to my first and second game. After that everything I do is deemed scummy, be it lurking or asking questions.I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. But last time I checked most players in the MS were against using metas in games and reason for voting. I mean it failed for so many times and as said before it can be changed easily. Why would claire be using it? If she did that would just be stupid. After RNG meta is the worst way to vote. I would not say Meta is a bad way to vote if it can be backed up. so not sure why you think meta is pointless. Because just voting someone from meta is just dumb. If some evidence can be presented I dont have any problem. |
Jun 21, 2016 10:34 AM
#627
Aww man, I take a break for 2 days and the game starts without me. D: What exactly is happening right now?? |
**********Smile! ^^********* |
Jun 21, 2016 12:21 PM
#629
I am town. Soren is town for showing critical thought about the game. He is being actively engaged and I like how he pointed out unaligned pairs, which reminds me of how Bee-Boy did it in Angel Beats! PentaFlare is town because he is asking good questions and working on solving the game. Hmm I just ISO'd Jackrito and I can't find the reasons why I thought he was town early game. @Bee-Boy: Why are you townreading Jack as opposed to last game? deepinthelair is town because of posts 315 and 316 which reads as natural. Isn't one of my stronger reads though. Karote is here because of gut and the "good boy" when Bee-Boy townread him. I also like the "are you too scared to vote" which I think stems from a townie mindset. Once again, not one of my stronger reads. QUEEN is here because of playstyle changes and intentionally positioning herself as low hanging fruit. Bee-Boy is here for true conviction when he was scumreading QUEEN. I'm voting lamby because of his disappearance and voting no lynch. Voting no lynch is suspicious during RVS because it shows that you don't want to pressure someone. |
Jun 21, 2016 12:38 PM
#630
Crossbell said: I am town. Soren is town for showing critical thought about the game. He is being actively engaged and I like how he pointed out unaligned pairs, which reminds me of how Bee-Boy did it in Angel Beats! PentaFlare is town because he is asking good questions and working on solving the game. Hmm I just ISO'd Jackrito and I can't find the reasons why I thought he was town early game. @Bee-Boy: Why are you townreading Jack as opposed to last game? deepinthelair is town because of posts 315 and 316 which reads as natural. Isn't one of my stronger reads though. Karote is here because of gut and the "good boy" when Bee-Boy townread him. I also like the "are you too scared to vote" which I think stems from a townie mindset. Once again, not one of my stronger reads. QUEEN is here because of playstyle changes and intentionally positioning herself as low hanging fruit. Bee-Boy is here for true conviction when he was scumreading QUEEN. I'm voting lamby because of his disappearance and voting no lynch. Voting no lynch is suspicious during RVS because it shows that you don't want to pressure someone. I find it strange how I'm still a strong town read but you lost your reasoning for it. Surely that would make me more of a null read. |
Jun 21, 2016 12:41 PM
#631
Crossbell said: I am town. Soren is town for showing critical thought about the game. He is being actively engaged and I like how he pointed out unaligned pairs, which reminds me of how Bee-Boy did it in Angel Beats! PentaFlare is town because he is asking good questions and working on solving the game. Hmm I just ISO'd Jackrito and I can't find the reasons why I thought he was town early game. @Bee-Boy: Why are you townreading Jack as opposed to last game? deepinthelair is town because of posts 315 and 316 which reads as natural. Isn't one of my stronger reads though. Karote is here because of gut and the "good boy" when Bee-Boy townread him. I also like the "are you too scared to vote" which I think stems from a townie mindset. Once again, not one of my stronger reads. QUEEN is here because of playstyle changes and intentionally positioning herself as low hanging fruit. Bee-Boy is here for true conviction when he was scumreading QUEEN. I'm voting lamby because of his disappearance and voting no lynch. Voting no lynch is suspicious during RVS because it shows that you don't want to pressure someone. I feel at this point in the game you should maybe have a read on Shinchi, Kasai and Claire I think all 3 have done enough for at least some slight reads either side. |
Jun 21, 2016 12:42 PM
#632
QUEEN vs Bee Boy reads as a town on town quotewar. I like the backing off by Bee Boy as well. Shinichi-kun said: Buddying. :(<3 *hugs crossbell has a good heart thats why Shinichi-kun said: My paranoia regarding scum!Shinichi is real here. This feels like Caught for the Wrong Reasons (getting angry that people are scumreading you for the wrong reasons).Wait so bcause she posted a reason for her meta change shes off the hook but i'm scum for the exact same reason so unfair :'( Shinichi-kun said: This feels somewhat town, though.Tempted to let myself get lynched so people can see this persoanlity change isn't alignment indictive at all. _Claire said: I actually played with you in Shounen Crossover (I defended you when you were scum heh).@Crossbell @Bee-boy I have not played with you before. I am looking forward to it :P I have no idea what to think of Shinichi. There are things that make me think that he is town ("when I die and flip town" and the statement above) but the angriness of being caught for the wrong reasons is drowning all of that out. I keep waiting for something super genuine from Shinichi and I am not really getting it? I have no idea how to read Claire so I'll let others read her, I think. My townread on Karote is strengthening though. |
Jun 21, 2016 12:46 PM
#633
@Jackrito: I was gut town reading you yesterday (hence your inclusion on the "Gun to my head town" list) but I was re examining your posts today and I could not remember why I was townreadig you. Yeah, you should be moved closer to null, but I made that reads list before I reread you. |
Jun 21, 2016 12:47 PM
#634
Also yeah I'm reading the new stuff and forming reads on all three of those people. |
Jun 21, 2016 12:58 PM
#635
Shinichi-Kun said: Quite annoying how every game where im town i get called anti town but when im actually scum no one pressures me this much lol i just can't be a townie without being anti town. Someone wants to pin point what makes me antitown game then go ahead but not gonna keep rereading the thread over and over to find more reasons that make me anti town cause i've come to conclusion i am anti-town townie accept that or lynch me so i can flip my town aligned role. So tempted to roleclaim because this dumb lmao hmm... the more I am reading this the more I am thinking this is town frustration. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:00 PM
#636
I'm so lost because there's still not enough activity from the whole player base to get a better scope of the game. This is annoying. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:04 PM
#637
Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Kasai said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. Shinichi-Kun said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: PentaFlare said: Hmm, if Shinichi is scum, what do you think about his attempt to make a counter train so early? Is that too obvious to be an attempt to save a ally? Not entirely sure if it would be to save an ally directly, or just to mess with the voting. Messing with the voting is fun, i just didn't wanna see kasai get day 1 lynched yet again cause im tired of that >_>, but i mean you can see the counter vote however you want This post I find odd. I heard Kasai always played scummy and such but it didnt mean you couldnt pressure him day 1 and it was just a quarter part of the game yet you seem like you are scared/provide a distraction out of Kasai. You know half phase of day 1, the vote is most likely gonna change. Are you defending him? *cough* but anyway its noted. I dont see how Queen was acting different probably because ive not played with her for close to two months, but I cant see how she is very scummy and I would rather her alive now as she is a goodscumhunter. She has proven that in previous games and she could be a great asset to town. Soren, Soren. Is it just me or most are totally townreading you? I couldnt deny that I am townreading you a bit from your post but neither has anyone pressured you into anything. I am cautious now. It reminds me of how Jack was so trusted in prev games, which sometimes isnt always a good thing. I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. @Crossbell @Bee-boy I have not played with you before. I am looking forward to it :P Nah it was different because Kasai basically became a policy lynch for people to fall back on when they couldn't trust their reads it was so unfair for him >_> Also Playstyle change shouldn't be alignment indictive but like im being scum read for it and alice is being town read smh Yeah I got what youre trying to say. I know you have huge view on that one, but thing is we should not overlook Kasai in this case because even tho it seems he is always acting scummy and ppl tend not to be able to read him there is a possibility he could be a scum, so why not pressure him and try to see his reaction? It totally seems you are trying to get attention off him. Even though why you should do that is beyond me, I could understand if ppl pressure him and then just stay on him the whole phase without clear reasoning, but it isnt the case here right? See I don't mind that but everytime someone says they are just pressuring the train always leads to lynch on him like literally everytime. You know this is a lie. It does not always lead to lynching him cause most people know he plays scummy. Well it's obvious you dont know me. When you joined that phase had already passed but there used to be a time in Mafia Society that me and El-psy-Congroo would always lynched day 1 Edit: Just fixed typos. Yeah but I know in recent games where I was there, you were "ignored" because of your scummy play, like they accept the fact you were always playing scummy even if you are town. I could still remember where you won that game alone. Dont remember which I think you were SK or Arsonist or sth. I want to see more of Lamby, aa-dono, and Togs. They barely said anything. Even though if its from Lamby I mostly wont understand him. haha yeah that game was a blast. Anyway you know the saying you cant teach an old dog new trick. So if start to day 1 lynch me again I think that wave would continue till the end of the summer. Maybe he is trying to prevent that. Other than that I dont know any reason why would he protect me. That is why I decided to put my vote on you :> Shinichi defending you is very weird, and I see no reason why he would do that, except his strong point of view. But most people already know how you play, it shouldnt be a problem. I will see if I can get something out of this. Should I start by, what is your general view atm? aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Doesn't that contradict with your tendency to use meta?Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I think that only applies to my first and second game. After that everything I do is deemed scummy, be it lurking or asking questions.I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. To be honest, a lot of people use meta-read to some extend. Some not so much, some more. Once again, I really don't want to have another meta-read argument, its like repeating me vs Queen all over again which I would rather not repeat. Kasai said: aa-dono said: _Claire_ said: Doesn't that contradict with your tendency to use meta?Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: PentaFlare said: The way you word this feels very off to me.Soren said: PentaFlare said: I suggest re-reading my #307. But I'll re-iterate the points here. I don't want to lynch Shinichi. Am I correct in saying that one of the main reasons for that train is because he said he doesn't want to commit to a vote at the end of the phase? If so, that is null. Unfortunately, he does the same thing as town and scum. I don't agree with that course of action, but he does it all the time. 1. He says that he likes to wait until later in the day before he votes because he only wants to vote if someone is actually scummy and he has good reasons to suppose that they are scum. That did not happen this game as he voted early. I also recall a game (but don't remember the specific one so I could be wrong) where he was scum and voted early on day 1. 2. It was odd that Shinichi would create a counter wagon on someone, when he is known to defend people a lot. 3. Decides to take a "risk" because Alice said it was good. First off, the taking a risk displays a carefree attitude, which is entirely different to how I know Shinichi to play, he tends to be more of a skeptic, making him reluctant to make a stance unless there is indisputable evidence. Secondly why is he taking a risk just because someone else said it was good? This change in his behavior is rather telling, and it is telling me that this is not his town game. Okay. Those points seem to make sense, but I don't think I will join you on this. Not right now anyways. I'll wait and see how he reacts before making any judgement. Uhm btw your 1. is wrong cause i've literally voted at the start of games before i recall 1 game where i was the first post and i voted in that post. Counter Wagons are fun \ o / If I was scum would i really change my play style this drastically come on are you that dense XD. Can we apply reverse psychology here, changing playstyle doesnt mean you are not scum and same playstyle does not mean the alignment is the same even though I still cannot see how people see you, as I am not much alarmed by you yet. It is still a quarter of the phase, I will keep on looking. 3.5 hours sleep doesnt help my brain much in the game. _Claire_ said: I think that only applies to my first and second game. After that everything I do is deemed scummy, be it lurking or asking questions.I have not seen a lot of posts of aa-dono and Lamby and I would want some, especially aa-dono considering she is one of the most innocent-players-who-nobody-suspects. But last time I checked most players in the MS were against using metas in games and reason for voting. I mean it failed for so many times and as said before it can be changed easily. Why would claire be using it? If she did that would just be stupid. After RNG meta is the worst way to vote. I play the games the way I see most fit. If most people dont agree, they cannot make me agree to something I dont want to agree. atta girl! Keep doing that. For that very same reason I became the so called lynch hot spot but won in the end so I guess you can do the same Now my general view is I dont have any thing. I am reading as I am posting right now what picked my attention the most was your statement saying that nobody checked soren and quickly labeled him as town. I have seen this before with other experienced players namely jack and grave. People tend to pick them as town leaders and if they turn up to be scums it would mean insta loss for town so for now I am trying to find Soren's posts other than that I found Izaya's (Kaito's) arguement with queen very intresting. Thats all I can say before completly catching up. Interesting in what way? What does it tell you about either one of our alignment? |
Jun 21, 2016 1:04 PM
#638
I might be tempted to agree with QUEEN's read on Jack. I like PentaFlare's case on Claire and I am tempted to agree with it also because that question time Claire was a hallmark of Shounen Crossover. I did not know her town meta though. @PentaFlare: Can you support this with some posts from Idol/Harry Potter? I have no idea what to make of Kasai's posts. They don't appear to contain any scumhunting or analysis though. His fear of town leaders being scum seems to be real though. OK, all caught up. I want to see more from Shinichi. Some of his posts feel town but the caught for the wrong reasons thing is really concerning. Unvote, vote Shinichi I am also willing to vote for Claire since I think Penta's meta read on her might be of some merit. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:08 PM
#639
Kasai's posts seem so baseless for the most part, it is disappointing. Instead of appearing naturally scummy as he use to, feels like he is trying to hit a hard null with the way he's been playing, so strange. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:08 PM
#640
Vote Count ★ 1.7 Crossbell (1)// Togs SightlessReality (1) // SightlessReality SoulEaterQUEEN (2) // aa-dono,Shinichi-kun, Soren (1)// deepinthelair Shinichi-kun (4)// Soren, SoulEaterQUEEN, Jackrito, Crossbell _Claire_ (2)// Karote, PentaFlare Kasai (1) // _Claire_ No lynch (1)// no_chode_name Not voting // Kasai, magicalofmagic, Bee-boy › Time until Night 1 ‹ |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
Jun 21, 2016 1:11 PM
#642
_Claire_ has not struck me as being that odd, and I am a bit weary on Penta's aggression on her since that approach strikes me as a scum tell for him: passive as town, aggressive as scum. But he's getting strong town reads across the board which is making me feel inconfident in my own paranoia. _Claire_ is also behaving a bit defensive which seems to be her norm when she's town, but the asking of questions confuses me a little bit since I can't follow her thought process with it. @_Claire_ can I get some reads from you when you can? |
Jun 21, 2016 1:12 PM
#643
@Crossbell What happened to Togs? He's still in RVS. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:13 PM
#644
SoulEaterQUEEN said: Honestly, I am not sure what to expect of him. Does he normally play like this as town?Kasai's posts seem so baseless for the most part, it is disappointing. Instead of appearing naturally scummy as he use to, feels like he is trying to hit a hard null with the way he's been playing, so strange. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:14 PM
#645
Crossbell said: I might be tempted to agree with QUEEN's read on Jack. I like PentaFlare's case on Claire and I am tempted to agree with it also because that question time Claire was a hallmark of Shounen Crossover. I did not know her town meta though. @PentaFlare: Can you support this with some posts from Idol/Harry Potter? I have no idea what to make of Kasai's posts. They don't appear to contain any scumhunting or analysis though. His fear of town leaders being scum seems to be real though. OK, all caught up. I want to see more from Shinichi. Some of his posts feel town but the caught for the wrong reasons thing is really concerning. Unvote, vote Shinichi I am also willing to vote for Claire since I think Penta's meta read on her might be of some merit. I think I am going to cross check that myself. Though she rolled as scum only once which makes it a little harder. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:14 PM
#646
I am not sure. I haven't talked with him since yesterday morning. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:15 PM
#647
Jackrito said: Crossbell said: I am town. Soren is town for showing critical thought about the game. He is being actively engaged and I like how he pointed out unaligned pairs, which reminds me of how Bee-Boy did it in Angel Beats! PentaFlare is town because he is asking good questions and working on solving the game. Hmm I just ISO'd Jackrito and I can't find the reasons why I thought he was town early game. @Bee-Boy: Why are you townreading Jack as opposed to last game? deepinthelair is town because of posts 315 and 316 which reads as natural. Isn't one of my stronger reads though. Karote is here because of gut and the "good boy" when Bee-Boy townread him. I also like the "are you too scared to vote" which I think stems from a townie mindset. Once again, not one of my stronger reads. QUEEN is here because of playstyle changes and intentionally positioning herself as low hanging fruit. Bee-Boy is here for true conviction when he was scumreading QUEEN. I'm voting lamby because of his disappearance and voting no lynch. Voting no lynch is suspicious during RVS because it shows that you don't want to pressure someone. I feel at this point in the game you should maybe have a read on Shinchi, Kasai and Claire I think all 3 have done enough for at least some slight reads either side. oh really. I am wondering your read about me |
Jun 21, 2016 1:15 PM
#648
OK, thanks for cross checking. I would do so myself but I am confined to a phone for most of today. |
Jun 21, 2016 1:17 PM
#649
SoulEaterQUEEN said: Kasai's posts seem so baseless for the most part, it is disappointing. Instead of appearing naturally scummy as he use to, feels like he is trying to hit a hard null with the way he's been playing, so strange. Glad you noticed the change. I am doing that intentionally the reason is I am not caught up with the game so I dont want to say anything that can be used towards me later on About why I find your discussion with Izaya intresting it is because town was completly distracted by it. I think that is what would scum want right? |
Jun 21, 2016 1:19 PM
#650
Crossbell said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: Honestly, I am not sure what to expect of him. Does he normally play like this as town?Kasai's posts seem so baseless for the most part, it is disappointing. Instead of appearing naturally scummy as he use to, feels like he is trying to hit a hard null with the way he's been playing, so strange. He's normally super defensive if someone points a finger at him. He's also a bit lazy and won't initiate scum hunting on his own unless someone pushes him. He mentioned he learned a few things since last time he's played with us. I'm feeling kind of funky with the whole Kaito + Kasai + PentaFlare dance. Kaito defending Kasai even though Kasai did not post yet, but this could just be Kaito's defending stance he normally does. PentaFlare dancing around his read on Kaito and feeling inconfident about it, and then counter pressuring with a _Claire_ meta scum read when _Claire_ points fingers at Kasai. I need to re-read the thread to substantiate this more as I believe this is a merely a wild theory at this point. But I might as well put my thoughts out there. |
More topics from this board
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1162 |
by SoulEaterQUEEN
»»
Sep 14, 5:38 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8752 |
by Aswin_Ash
»»
Jan 23, 11:52 AM |
|
» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fo - Jul 10, 2014 |
3741 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 11, 3:55 PM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2870 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 8, 11:22 AM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 2024 9:42 PM |