| did I miss any questions in this thread? |
 |
Chione said: Hm. The more this progresses, the more I actually get the feeling that most scum hides behind inactivity. Won't they be at risk of modkill then? "To be deemed active you must make 5 meaningful posts per phase. After 72 hours of being inactive, without a notification, I will either modkill you or replace you." |
 |
aa-dono said: Chione said: Hm. The more this progresses, the more I actually get the feeling that most scum hides behind inactivity. Won't they be at risk of modkill then? "To be deemed active you must make 5 meaningful posts per phase. After 72 hours of being inactive, without a notification, I will either modkill you or replace you." Only a stupid mafia member would risk being killed modkilled. I think she (Chione, she or he?) is referring to people who are minimally inactive, but active enough to not get modkilled, but aren't actually being active in discussion. To me, the thoughts come out like: if you aren't putting effort in the scum hunting, then what else are you doing -- discussing/planning in the mafia clubs, or avoiding being questioned-too afraid to slip up? |
 |
| It is strange for us to not have a last 30 min lynch espically in a game of this size not sure if that is a good thing or not since we normally have great success with them . But it is fair to say grr has no intrest in saving himself and seems to want to catch the charmer for some reason maybe for the hopes of a tie. Because not sure where this confidence is coming from but it is giving me no reason to change my vote. |
|
| It doesn't seem like people want to save grrr, seeing how the highest vote count after his only has 3 votes. The twins, where one is Town and one is 3rd Party, have their votes elsewhere. The lynchee himself shares single-minded thoughts, as though he's not conspiring with others. Hmmmmmm..... |
Jackrito said: It is strange for us to not have a last 30 min lynch espically in a game of this size not sure if that is a good thing or not since we normally have great success with them . But it is fair to say grr has no intrest in saving himself and seems to want to catch the charmer for some reason maybe for the hopes of a tie. Because not sure where this confidence is coming from but it is giving me no reason to change my vote. You're in this game? Where have you been! O_O |
BestPanda said: I have a plan. I don't want to comment too much because some people are hateful and will mess up my idea. Hmmm interesting, I'd like to get to know more about this so called plan soon (which better be pro-town is all I'm saying). Given that this is pretty cryptic, I can't say Pokeit's concerns don't have a source though. |
|
grave_robber said: Jackrito said: It is strange for us to not have a last 30 min lynch espically in a game of this size not sure if that is a good thing or not since we normally have great success with them . But it is fair to say grr has no intrest in saving himself and seems to want to catch the charmer for some reason maybe for the hopes of a tie. Because not sure where this confidence is coming from but it is giving me no reason to change my vote. You're in this game? Where have you been! O_O I don't know why this surprises you if anyone knows my meta you do and with so many different ways to die attention is not something I want so early. |
|
grrr said: Okay let me say it like this. I was the charmer the previous game. I wasn't able to make a decisive vote and I didn't like it. Please let me help the charmer this game :( . Are you claiming motivator? Grr! Seriously? |
Cody said: Vote Count: SoulEaterQUEEN (1): Zurel KOtA (1): redwillow grrr (7): Rinto-kun, coromandel, PentaFlare, grave_robber, Jackrito, Chione, BestPanda Karote (1): Verumir grave_robber (1): Soren Rei (2): tinglespalace, SoulEaterQUEEN NepBandit (2): Luna, Blonde Pokeit (3): Dr_Iss, Karote, El-Psy_Congroo Mkim (1): Suzune-chan Soren (1): Sleipnirr BestPanda (3): aa-dono, grrr, Pokeit Time until Day 1 Ends Final VC |
|
BestPanda said: It doesn't seem like people want to save grrr, seeing how the highest vote count after his only has 3 votes. The twins, where one is Town and one is 3rd Party, have their votes elsewhere. The lynchee himself shares single-minded thoughts, as though he's not conspiring with others. Hmmmmmm..... He seems to have hinted at a role that can help the charmer, but it's too late now so we might have just lynched a townie -_- Did soren post or contribute in any way since he voted for me? I gotta check, if he hasn't, soren is bad. |
| sorry for the wait. I had to check some stuff before I posted the results. |
SwimminglyDoneJan 25, 2016 10:22 AM
|
| If he is Town then I will doubt those voting for him. 7 seems like a pretty overkill number. |
grave_robber said: BestPanda said: It doesn't seem like people want to save grrr, seeing how the highest vote count after his only has 3 votes. The twins, where one is Town and one is 3rd Party, have their votes elsewhere. The lynchee himself shares single-minded thoughts, as though he's not conspiring with others. Hmmmmmm..... He seems to have hinted at a role that can help the charmer, but it's too late now so we might have just lynched a townie -_- Did soren post or contribute in any way since he voted for me? I gotta check, if he hasn't, soren is bad. I was actually going to ask you if you knew why he lynched you? I remember he chose to lynch me, but I don't recall reading why he chose to change his vote. |
|
| Lol I know who he is. |
| Well, looks like we fed Misa a kill... |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
| *sigh* I don't even know. |
 |
| I still don't know what was wrong with my idea ... I regret nothing. |
| |
Verumir said: -->Says that I have no interest in catching scum -->Votes for the same person that I did. You are act like you are trying to get control of town, and is even being defensive about the votes on you, I think you should take Suzune's advice and just chill, I'm going nowhere. Ever since the start of the phase you were trying to kill me, I hadn't even posted yet. I much prefer Coro's logic, I have all townies (which is a pretty significant amount) looking at my actions and willow's actions eventually it will be obvious who is who, and since host is a troll the only way I can prove my innocence is with The exorcist killing willow, but you wouldn't want that would you? 1) Your vote didn't carry much reason or weight for me and I voted for him after he demonstrated suspicious behavior and to break a tie. 2) The exorcist dies if they target a townie, the day vig doesn't. So No, the exorcist isn't going after either of you unless they feel like risking their life. 3) I got excited because I haven't played or even felt like playing a long time, I didn't get defensive. When Chione and Mkim pointed the flaws in my logic and assumptions, I accepted it and moved on, you're just mad because I want you dead. I totally get that, I wouldn't normally go after the survivor but the chance of them turning into a mafioso is higher than that of then surviving to day 4 with no mafia deaths. Anyhow, chill pill taken =3 PentaFlare said: grave_robber said: Actually both lynches give us no reads on the mafia, so the vig kill option is way better. I don't see how Misa will benefit from their lynches. Could you explain that please? Misa wants to kill people using her ability. The twins are immune. If they are lynched, that means that someone who is a valid target for Misa's ability is not being lynched. This gives her more chances to a use her ability. The way I see it, no matter who is being lynched, misa's target pool remains the same, everyone but herself and the twins. Wait, Host-sama, can Misa kill herself to win? She can't, right? The same can be said about lynching mafia, Misa's more likely to kill a townie anyway. |
| Roleblocker just needs to roleblock PentaFlare. We're all good. |
Jackrito said: It is strange for us to not have a last 30 min lynch espically. The thread was like dead 1 hour ago, and then I got distracted for 30 minutes... just my luck : D. |
| |
BestPanda said: Lol I know who he is. PentaFlare said: Well, looks like we fed Misa a kill... I just realize those. So even if we do figure out who is which Town role, we can't say it here! Sorry, had to put my thoughts here to remind myself to prevent myself from ever blurting out a Townie role and feed Misa a free kill. |
|
| I tried to act scummy to get some votes on so I can push my plan. I am not sure where I made a mistake. I think I did good okay :| . Good bye to all you who didn't kill me :( . |
| |
Cody said: No lynch occured! Ok, Grr is town! Day vig, you're mean for not going with the plan. -_- ======================== So now we just have basically no real VCA and we have to worry about potential conversions and death! Yay >_> grrr said: I still don't know what was wrong with my idea ... I regret nothing. Which idea? I really think soren and suzune might be bad, they're not even pretending to care about the game. I'll be back later to re-read day 1, I hope the diplomat invited someone trustworthy. Panda, I look forward to your VCA, it's been a while <3 |
grave_robber said: Wait, Host-sama, can Misa kill herself to win? She can't, right? The same can be said about lynching mafia, Misa's more likely to kill a townie anyway. She can not. Nor does her being on a lynch kill count towards her win condition. |
|
Really. How do you expect me to claim anything at day 1. If anything I could be the charmer, push for even votes. But very few cared to save me :( . |
| |
grrr said: I tried to act scummy to get some votes on so I can push my plan. I am not sure where I made a mistake. I think I did good okay :| . Good bye to all you who didn't kill me :( . Wow, okay. Clearly I am missing something here... My first guess was that you were the cat. But guess I need to look this up again. |
|
SoulEaterQUEEN said: Wow, okay. Clearly I am missing something here... My first guess was that you were the cat. But guess I need to look this up again. I am most likely the cat. Though I can still be madoka or two of the Satsuki guys. |
| |
Tied votes... uhg I am too sad to talk now : D . |
| |
grrr said: I tried to act scummy to get some votes on so I can push my plan. I am not sure where I made a mistake. I think I did good okay :| . Good bye to all you who didn't kill me :( . That was your plan? There was 15+ hours left in the phase, you could have defended yourself and saved this for later. We could have kept poking people till we hit a better target. It's ok, it's still only day 1. I'll be back later, can you go back and read Day 1 then tell me who stands out for you? |
| No... my plan was to gradually accumulate votes and then force it for tied votes. I don't want to defend myself so no one votes me. Whatever. So far I only find chione scummy. She perfectly read my reason for voting Penta. (He was online and I wanted to poke him.) But then she voted me anyway. I can't get much from day 1 :/ |
| |
| i woke up too late |
| "This is boring...I'm bored..." |
| hahah~ and I woke too early. going back to sleep~~ I hope there'd be only 2 additional pages to catch up to later >o< Also, sorry grr for doubting you >< |
|
| Uh, are we allowed to keep posting even in the night phase? |
|
SoulEaterQUEEN said: Uh, are we allowed to keep posting even in the night phase? Nope. I'm modkilling everyone that has posted since night started including you. |
|
SoulEaterQUEEN said: Uh, are we allowed to keep posting even in the night phase? it's okay but talking too much might gives mafia a hint |
| "This is boring...I'm bored..." |
coromandel said: @Psy: Why are you voting for Pokeit, when you don't even find him scummy? "Mkim even though he is not voting I think he trying to help town, that's something I see, would be better if votes someone." How is Mkim trying to help town? I'm not exactly scum-reading him, but he hasn't posted enough to really have an opinion on, imo. So I find it odd you're already having a town-read on him. I answered that question previously. Does no one see the "But"? Regarding Mkim, it's not a strong town read, just a gut feeling, maybe I get this feeling because the image he posted stuck in my mind. |
| Hosts, in case of tied votes on day 1 what happens? And what happens to tied voted on day 2 or later? |
| day 1 tied votes will result in no lynch. day 2 and after will result in randomized lynch among all players. |
|
Cody said: day 1 tied votes will result in no lynch. day 2 and after will result in randomized lynch among all players. Thank you Tay <3 |
| Thanks Grrr. Thanks for wasting our Lynch -____________________________________________- SoulEaterQUEEN said: aa-dono said: Won't they be at risk of modkill then? "To be deemed active you must make 5 meaningful posts per phase. After 72 hours of being inactive, without a notification, I will either modkill you or replace you." Only a stupid mafia member would risk being killed modkilled. I think she (Chione, she or he?) is referring to people who are minimally inactive, but active enough to not get modkilled, but aren't actually being active in discussion. To me, the thoughts come out like: if you aren't putting effort in the scum hunting, then what else are you doing -- discussing/planning in the mafia clubs, or avoiding being questioned-too afraid to slip up? It's not about the thing you just mentioned, cause we have people whose play style doesn't fit in with being active in general. It'd be unfair to deem everyone who isn't 100% active to be scum. It's more cause most most people that I think that could be townies are active. We'll see. (and yes, I'm female) grrr said: No... my plan was to gradually accumulate votes and then force it for tied votes. I don't want to defend myself so no one votes me. Whatever. So far I only find chione scummy. She perfectly read my reason for voting Penta. (He was online and I wanted to poke him.) But then she voted me anyway. I can't get much from day 1 :/ I took a look at you as objectively as possible, and now you're lynching me for that. Duh thanks. I'm so pissed right now, and I can't find the perfect emoticon for it -.- I never defended you when I stated why I think Penta interpreted it wrong, nor was it a town read. I simply stated how I interpreted the thing. Idk how you got that idea, but "She perfectly read my reason" -> "She voted for me" -> "scum read" doesn't really makes sense for me. I did give you a chance to defend yourself. It's your own fault for "soft claiming". @PentaFlare Chione said: Please provide evidence where Nep is making genuine contributions and is offering opinions. I'd like you to give your honest opinion on Nep, why he seems to be town, cause I can't really see how he made the things you stated. Don't worry, I'll accept anything you give me, even if it's just gut feeling. Satsuki, you better kill one of the twins or anyone you deem to be scum next day phase. Don't waste your kill. |
 |
Cody said: I think that u didnt answered this from 2nd page.did I miss any questions in this thread? redwillow said: To explain more this question, I wanted to ask if by that version Shion would be removed from game leaving only Mion in it.Host Shion Sonozaki[Corrupted Twin] Win condition: Survive to day 4 If none of mafiosos are killed till D4 will Shion win and end game without joining neither of Mafia? |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
RedTie said: Which type are u then?In my experience there's only so much concrete stuff you can get from Day 1. Once several more days pass and people start dying there's more material on the table. Some playstyles are just different. You don't know if they're mafia just because they're not discussing as much or with the same intensity. |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
RedTie said: I see. But while there are low-key players like u say there are also those who tries to get as little attention as they can to not be suspected for smth. So " You don't know if they're mafia just because they're not discussing as much or with the same intensity." goes same for townies.I'm a bit more low-key but I do post. I haven't put my thoughts out as much since others have already said what I've thought. I'm sure that could be the case with other players. |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
More topics from this board
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1162 |
by SoulEaterQUEEN
»»
Sep 14, 5:38 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8752 |
by Aswin_Ash
»»
Jan 23, 11:52 AM |
|
» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fo - Jul 10, 2014 |
3741 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 11, 3:55 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2870 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 8, 11:22 AM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 2024 9:42 PM |