guys i just want to thrown this out there but i believe soren is scum this game. First he did not played like himself this game. After we pressured him only then he strted to scum hunt like normally. Secondly even after it was obvious that i was blitz he said he was not going to believe me until i said so ı mean i can relate but still really? Thirdly even after thinking that naita was town he still wanted her to be smited. Why would you do that knowing that she is town? He even said that he was thinking she was town and despite that he was the one who triggered everyone to smite her. The only reason we think that soren is town is he caught the fizz right? I mean isnt that kinda suspicious? Dont you notice there is something intresting about that. Fizz is the only scum that the mafia does not know the identity of. So isnt it possible that soren caught her accidently. I mean everything soren did this game except for lynching grave was scummy to me so it would be nice that he would share the reads he was talking this whole game.
Night was not quiet cause year changed in Runeterra. Fireworks were shot in the skies. Still during night someone went to kill Vayne. KaitoKid - Vayne (Night Hunter) was killed.
KaitoKid said: @Tingle where did you place your first mushroom?
Asnwer this, tingle.
Vote: tinglespalace
Everyone else vote for her too.
I'll claim to be Thresh and tingles isn't the Teemo she claims, Pokeit was Teemo.
And I know the correct answer to that, there's a person in the game who will prove me right.
Tingles will get the answer wrong, unless gets super lucky to guess which person out of 19.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Only thing Arrisu told me that she investigated Soren who was town, so only role can be is Nocturne if he's scum or just town aligned.
If tingles flips Nocturne, Soren is to be 100% trusted but if not, then dunno. (Figure out that later)
I knew she was scum! Smart play on the teemo claim to ward of the attention though.
I did not think of using thresh to counter the janitor fake claim. Good job karote. Vote: tinglespalace
Uhum sorry I got it all wrong.. I was looking at my sent messages, but as I hadn't marked the nights I wasn't sure which happened when. I am not 100% sober right now, you can't judge me. I wanted to plant it in front of Soren night 2, when nothing happened. It was indeed Kaito night one, I wouldn't place it infront of anybody else, but my Senpai, night 1.
I like to comment on my reads so it took a little longer.
Goodies:
Sleipnirr (Confirmed Blitzcrank) - I have nothing to say about him atm. I think based on his announcement that night 2 would be silent and it actually happening, we could definitely assume that Sleipnirr is indeed telling the truth.
Semi-Goodies:
Heartman - Has given me an anti town vibe before, as I had seen him play more pro- town in my game. But after Soren’s explanation on why he couldn’t possible be bad, I kinda wanna trust him. He hasn’t shown any true anti-town behaviour afterwards. But then again, why would I trust someone’s reads of which I suspect? SuzakuTsubasa - While looking into this player’s alignment I tried to look at grrr’s action as little as possible. I don’t think they can be scum, as scum would know exactly what their role and their buddy’s do. And after reading this post, I had to look into the roles one more time to check if their speculations were correct. The one about Nocturne wasn’t. Nocturne’s 1-shot ability isn’t directed at one particular person but at everyone. A scummy couldn’t possibly get this wrong. This makes my read on this person pretty townie. Carrot - Seems to suddenly be playing this game very serious after having some people putting some suspicion on him for being slightly inactive before. I can’t fully place you on my town list yet, but you’re getting there. I’m sorry, do you hate me because I can’t draw :o
Semi-Bad/Third Party:
Tsundere - I have not much to say about this player. He has seemed to be playing more serious than normally and I adore that to a fantastic extend, but then again, would that be his town approach to the game? I haven’t played too many games with our tsundere, so I can’t really meta read him in any way, but the way he’s been playing has been serious, and he seems to be more of a person who would play more trolly when town. One of those people who are hard to read. But why do I get sucha town vibe from you now? I don’t like it. Jicko - I have simply not seen enough from this user to be able to place a good read on him. I’m sorry.
Bad/Third Party:
Soren - I kinda think he’s either Darius or scum. He was the first one to jump on the idea that I was Darius when I said jokingly that I had no problem with mister Darius as long as he killed scum. 1226 He has been leading town since pretty much the beginning and I do think that Sleipnirr had a point in saying that he has led us on lynch trains that made us kill some valuable townies. The only scum he really caught was Grave, which was Fizz, could’ve indeed been a mistake. I had a biased opinion concerning smiting Yenny, as I had been angry at her since she joined because she kept on telling me she’d post but she didn’t. Soren didn’t tho. And he was pretty quick on the both of smiting a player like that. Folie - Folie hasn’t been contributing too much to the game. She has only sheeped and her reads didn’t provide much input and seemed to be echoing what people had been saying before. Also the comments she made that would look like pressuring, were more funny remarks. Not actual questions which could make someone perhaps slip. I’ve seen her play like this before, but can’t recall if town or not. Anyway.. It’s just not a very pro-town-way of trying to play the game.
Sleipnirr said: After we pressured him only then he strted to scum hunt like normally.
What is your point?
Sleipnirr said: Secondly even after it was obvious that i was blitz he said he was not going to believe me until i said so ı mean i can relate but still really?
"Obvious" but not certain. I like to play with certainty in the game. This isn't even a strong point because it's not like I flung mud at your way. I gave you time to come into the thread and confirm that you are blitz.
Sleipnirr said: Thirdly even after thinking that naita was town he still wanted her to be smited. Why would you do that knowing that she is town?
I responded to this already. There's a chance that my reads are wrong, this helps me focus more on my other reads. And secondly, rules are rules. If you don't meet the activity rule, get smited.
Sleipnirr said: He even said that he was thinking she was town and despite that he was the one who triggered everyone to smite her.
Tingles and kaito both wanted to smite her too. And oh look, kaito flipped town. This is not a valid point to scum read me because it is null.
Sleipnirr said: The only reason we think that soren is town is he caught the fizz right? I mean isnt that kinda suspicious? Dont you notice there is something intresting about that. Fizz is the only scum that the mafia does not know the identity of. So isnt it possible that soren caught her accidently.
Yeah but how is that a reason to scum read me? Why is that something you see coming from scum!soren but not town!soren?
Sleipnirr said: I mean everything soren did this game except for lynching grave was scummy to me so it would be nice that he would share the reads he was talking this whole game.
Maybe. If I feel there is a need to. This game is about having an uninformed majority vs an informed minority. I don't want to give the informed minority any more information than they already have.
tinglespalace said: Uhum sorry I got it all wrong.. I was looking at my sent messages, but as I hadn't marked the nights I wasn't sure which happened when. I am not 100% sober right now, you can't judge me. I wanted to plant it in front of Soren night 2, when nothing happened. It was indeed Kaito night one, I wouldn't place it infront of anybody else, but my Senpai, night 1.
This is pretty reasonable, mistakes happens especially when you are drunk.
tinglespalace said:
I like to comment on my reads so it took a little longer.
Goodies:
Sleipnirr (Confirmed Blitzcrank) - I have nothing to say about him atm. I think based on his announcement that night 2 would be silent and it actually happening, we could definitely assume that Sleipnirr is indeed telling the truth.
Semi-Goodies:
Heartman - Has given me an anti town vibe before, as I had seen him play more pro- town in my game. But after Soren’s explanation on why he couldn’t possible be bad, I kinda wanna trust him. He hasn’t shown any true anti-town behaviour afterwards. But then again, why would I trust someone’s reads of which I suspect? SuzakuTsubasa - While looking into this player’s alignment I tried to look at grrr’s action as little as possible. I don’t think they can be scum, as scum would know exactly what their role and their buddy’s do. And after reading this post, I had to look into the roles one more time to check if their speculations were correct. The one about Nocturne wasn’t. Nocturne’s 1-shot ability isn’t directed at one particular person but at everyone. A scummy couldn’t possibly get this wrong. This makes my read on this person pretty townie. Carrot - Seems to suddenly be playing this game very serious after having some people putting some suspicion on him for being slightly inactive before. I can’t fully place you on my town list yet, but you’re getting there. I’m sorry, do you hate me because I can’t draw :o
Semi-Bad/Third Party:
Tsundere - I have not much to say about this player. He has seemed to be playing more serious than normally and I adore that to a fantastic extend, but then again, would that be his town approach to the game? I haven’t played too many games with our tsundere, so I can’t really meta read him in any way, but the way he’s been playing has been serious, and he seems to be more of a person who would play more trolly when town. One of those people who are hard to read. But why do I get sucha town vibe from you now? I don’t like it. Jicko - I have simply not seen enough from this user to be able to place a good read on him. I’m sorry.
Bad/Third Party:
Soren - I kinda think he’s either Darius or scum. He was the first one to jump on the idea that I was Darius when I said jokingly that I had no problem with mister Darius as long as he killed scum. 1226 He has been leading town since pretty much the beginning and I do think that Sleipnirr had a point in saying that he has led us on lynch trains that made us kill some valuable townies. The only scum he really caught was Grave, which was Fizz, could’ve indeed been a mistake. I had a biased opinion concerning smiting Yenny, as I had been angry at her since she joined because she kept on telling me she’d post but she didn’t. Soren didn’t tho. And he was pretty quick on the both of smiting a player like that. Folie - Folie hasn’t been contributing too much to the game. She has only sheeped and her reads didn’t provide much input and seemed to be echoing what people had been saying before. Also the comments she made that would look like pressuring, were more funny remarks. Not actual questions which could make someone perhaps slip. I’ve seen her play like this before, but can’t recall if town or not. Anyway.. It’s just not a very pro-town-way of trying to play the game.
Alright, I like this. It's a detailed read list that has something important to tell us who you think are town and scum. It's very pro town. And I think this is enough for me to unvote you. Since I do not see scum!tingles doing this. It's in her meta, she plays like this as town. And since she's teemo, this demonstrates genuine reads. Unvote: tinglespalace
I want to focus on three of your reads so that we can focus on the remaining scum.
What did you mean from this statement about Heartman? I'm having a little trouble without some clarity of the wording.
tinglespalace said: He hasn’t shown any true anti-town behaviour afterwards. But then again, why would I trust someone’s reads of which I suspect?
Is this towards me? Meaning that you're saying why would you trust my read on Heartman, since you suspect me being scum? If so, why is heartman a town read as oppose to a null read?
Onto turtlebandit, based on meta I feel as though turtle tries to appear as town when he's scum. And when he's town he tends to be more carefree and even trolls a little bit. I have two questions about this.
1. Do you agree with that meta read?
2. If so, considering his play in this game, do you think that he falls under his scum meta or his town meta?
After answering that. What do you think of his vote in his 1343 and then admitting that he sheeped straight after that in his 1344?
Finally onto folie. I've been town reading her all game because she's very carefree in this game. Like she treats the game as hanging out with friends and joking about. I find this to be particularly town, because scum!folie would be more cautious of what she post. She would want to appear more town and therefore fabricate her posts a lot more. This is not the case in this game. Also, from what I have heard, folie got a lot more ragey and was less carefree in the christmas mafia game? I wasn't in that game so could you tell me if that was true? And since you have recent scum meta of folie, do you think that folie's play in this game is representational of her scum game? Yes or no and why?
You said this:
tinglespalace said: Also the comments she made that would look like pressuring, were more funny remarks. Not actual questions which could make someone perhaps slip. I’ve seen her play like this before, but can’t recall if town or not. Anyway.. It’s just not a very pro-town-way of trying to play the game.
Do you remember that game? Because I feel like it comes from town!folie more than scum!folie. And so if you remember that it comes from her town game it can help clear up this scum read on folie.
Karote I'm not going to waste a lynch on teemo when they can win alongside town meaning that I can focus on lynching scum. I'm only going to respond if tingles post now.
You're going to ignore that I gave proof earlier that I'm Thresh and tingles is obviously fake-claiming? 1408, 1418
Suzaku confirmed it for me, that he indeed did step on a mushroom and only information who should know this is Teemo & the guy who stepped on it,
I know for sure that Teemo is dead in my secret club. 1423
Pokeit definetly got killed by mafia because Karthus used his defile shot (erase role) on him, thus he can't be mafia for obvious reasons.
tinglespalace said: Nocturne’s 1-shot ability isn’t directed at one particular person but at everyone.
*reads role again*
Ah, you're right about that, I've misread it.
Well, that only reduces the number of roles I can have.
Soren said: Karote I'm not going to waste a lynch on teemo when they can win alongside town meaning that I can focus on lynching scum.
Though you say that, one of them is lying.
Either Karote is lying about being Thresh, then he is Teemo. He had the right target.
Or Tingle is lying, then Karote is Thresh and Tingle is either Darius or scum. Most likely scum to know Pokeit was Teemo.
In both cases, Tingle isn't Teemo.
karote said: Only thing Arrisu told me that she investigated Soren who was town, so only role can be is Nocturne if he's scum or just town aligned.
If tingles flips Nocturne, Soren is to be 100% trusted but if not, then dunno. (Figure out that later)
Well crap... I thought Soren was Darius... guess my long write-up is useless... Guess I'll go scum hunt someone else ;-;
KaitoKid said: @Tingle where did you place your first mushroom?
Asnwer this, tingle.
Vote: tinglespalace
Everyone else vote for her too.
I'll claim to be Thresh and tingles isn't the Teemo she claims, Pokeit was Teemo.
And I know the correct answer to that, there's a person in the game who will prove me right.
Tingles will get the answer wrong, unless gets super lucky to guess which person out of 19.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Only thing Arrisu told me that she investigated Soren who was town, so only role can be is Nocturne if he's scum or just town aligned.
If tingles flips Nocturne, Soren is to be 100% trusted but if not, then dunno. (Figure out that later)
One issue I have with this is that I wish you had more information to spare with the cop. We don't know which night she investigated Soren or why she only had one investigation. The good thing is that Suzaku collaborated with your story which makes it much more believable. If it wasn't for a few minor things which seem convenient in the way that they can't be checked in the event that Pokeit was thresh and you are scum, then I would be absolutely convinced.
Soren said: Karote I'm not going to waste a lynch on teemo when they can win alongside town meaning that I can focus on lynching scum. I'm only going to respond if tingles post now.
Tingle flips scum - We will know that Karote and Suzaku are good. Tingle flips town - We will know two remaining scum. In what situation wouldn't this be a good lynch?
tinglespalace said: Folie - Folie hasn’t been contributing too much to the game. She has only sheeped and her reads didn’t provide much input and seemed to be echoing what people had been saying before. Also the comments she made that would look like pressuring, were more funny remarks. Not actual questions which could make someone perhaps slip. I’ve seen her play like this before, but can’t recall if town or not. Anyway.. It’s just not a very pro-town-way of trying to play the game.
I am. Since I'm not exactly afraid of having a train on me I admit xD If you dun kill me at night, you sure dun wanna pick me at day time :3
And I'm lazy. Not a very helpful town. Sue me xD
I'll put the trust on Karoot for once o.O? when can we lynch soren again? xD vote: Tingle
I know that you want to win the game tingles, and I don't mind you winning as teemo. So lets work together, we have a mutual interest in catching scum. I hope you can come to the thread soon.
Soren said: Tingles come in the game so we can dissipate this wagon on you and focus on lynching scum. Me and you, we can do it.
Soren said: I know that you want to win the game tingles, and I don't mind you winning as teemo. So lets work together, we have a mutual interest in catching scum. I hope you can come to the thread soon.
Soren said: Tingles come in the game so we can dissipate this wagon on you and focus on lynching scum. Me and you, we can do it.
Soren said: I know that you want to win the game tingles, and I don't mind you winning as teemo. So lets work together, we have a mutual interest in catching scum. I hope you can come to the thread soon.
It's an act, right?
2h30min left and some players still haven't shown up. Even dead people are more active. (◕‿◕✿) You should have kept the rule, Pyro, if you haven't.