| Tho if Eyeh is the vanilla cop, why the hell does he get killed if wolves are Dias'/awa Ohh god I hate night kill analysis |
Nibio said: How is it anglely?Actually I wanna hope she is real, because I think the tactic she is using is really anglely And she actually did get roleblocked, since Dias' confirms it So Dias/awa have to both be wolves in this case, or the wolves jail kept their own partner (in the case of awa being a wolf here) But on the other hand it doesn't help that she's been claiming every night tracker, and now when we need her track, and she doesn't get blocked, the story changes |
 |
| Wait NVM, he still confirms vanillas, bad logic Ignore #3751 |
| Unless a town pr is hiding but i find that to be unlikely. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC  |
Nibio said: They probably thought I lied about it being consecutive since they knew my full roleTho if Eyeh is the vanilla cop, why the hell does he get killed if wolves are Dias'/awa Ohh god I hate night kill analysis |
|
| vote: Dono Ya goodbye |
Nibio said: No, you're right.Tho if Eyeh is the vanilla cop, why the hell does he get killed if wolves are Dias'/awa Ohh god I hate night kill analysis If the wolves are vanilla he's useless. Wolves have to have a power role. It's jack and crossbell. |
| Vote Change: Crossbell |
| ONLY Vanilla scum have flipped so far. There needs to be 2 wolf PRs imo to make vanilla cop any good. |
| @marluxion Ya but mafia have to have 2 prs in this setup, and whoever he had checked tonight would be cleared if they were vanilla |
Marluxion said: jinxONLY Vanilla scum have flipped so far. There needs to be 2 wolf PRs imo to make vanilla cop any good. |
Marluxion said: Does it have to be Jack as his scumbuddy though? I'm still sure that Jack is town.Vote Change: Crossbell |
|
aa-dono said: not voting cross, but I think in a world where cross is mafia, then jack is probably his partnerMarluxion said: Does it have to be Jack as his scumbuddy though? I'm still sure that Jack is town.Vote Change: Crossbell |
Nibio said: Exactly.@marluxion Ya but mafia have to have 2 prs in this setup, and whoever he had checked tonight would be cleared if they were vanilla So it's either EXACTLY Dias and Dono Or someone else. I'm cleared. Cross has basically just been trying to sound towny all game and look like he's trying to solve. I don't like how quickly he came around to the karote lynch yesterday. I'm dead set on this one. If i'm wrong on cross, you can lead the town after i'm gone because i'll be dead. But i want this one lynch. Just this one. |
| Wasn't eyeh going to check cross last night? At least he made it seem that way. So either mafia are setting up that mislynch or he is scum and eyeh needed to die? I'll be looking at cross intertactions thia phase i guess. Let's not forget about shinichi as well. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Nibio said: The problem with this logic becomesMarluxion said: jinxONLY Vanilla scum have flipped so far. There needs to be 2 wolf PRs imo to make vanilla cop any good. If there are two wolf PRs, especially with a jailkeeper on average town will have 3, maybe 4. If dias and dono are the two wolf prs, it was just me and the vanilla cop. It doesn't add up. |
| Are these day phases still 3 days? |
logic340 said: Wasn't eyeh going to check cross last night? At least he made it seem that way. So either mafia are setting up that mislynch or he is scum and eyeh needed to die? I'll be looking at cross intertactions thia phase i guess. Let's not forget about shinichi as well. Shinichi is town Stop. |
| Hmm, that's a good point unvote |
| at least i think there's no way scum cares that little about the game for so long especially when they were scumread |
| Three possible scumteams in order from most to least likely in my mind Cross / Jack (could be wrong on one, if i'm wrong on one it's jack) Disa / Dono EXACTLY. Nibio / Shinichi EXACTLY. all could still be scum i don't see logic tunneling so hard on LHF as wolf here cantrips catch up has been towny |
| @Shinichi-kun and @Cantripmancer we need you to post today. Your participation moving forward is paramount. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
| Nibio / Shinichi is least likely as nibio has openly been vouching for his brother's alignment and the arguments d1 with mood in thread |
| Cross / Nibio would be a hilarious team because they are the only other players here i think that deserve to win which might make it the truth if i'm wrong on jack / cross |
Marluxion said: wait why?logic340 said: Wasn't eyeh going to check cross last night? At least he made it seem that way. So either mafia are setting up that mislynch or he is scum and eyeh needed to die? I'll be looking at cross intertactions thia phase i guess. Let's not forget about shinichi as well. Shinichi is town Stop. Is it because he's considered LHF here? Nibio/shin unlikely to me nib doesn't stick his neck out this much for a teammate. But I'm not sold on the meta or the interactions. You got something else? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Marluxion said: lmao would be a good team if it was trueCross / Nibio would be a hilarious team because they are the only other players here i think that deserve to win which might make it the truth if i'm wrong on jack / cross The other possibility is cross/cantrip |
logic340 said: wait why? Is it because he's considered LHF here? Nibio/shin unlikely to me nib doesn't stick his neck out this much for a teammate. But I'm not sold on the meta or the interactions. You got something else? Scum WIM should be at an all time high right now his attitude doesn't add up with that i could be wrong and it could be fake but dono can clear him tonight if we dont lynch her |
Nibio said: maybMarluxion said: lmao would be a good team if it was trueCross / Nibio would be a hilarious team because they are the only other players here i think that deserve to win which might make it the truth if i'm wrong on jack / cross The other possibility is cross/cantrip |
Marluxion said: this must be about shin....thinking....even with the undesireable d1? They unexpectedly lost a teammate. They lost what might have been an easy mislynch in yurkin. They got no night actions N1. So for me dejection is certainly a possibility for his lackluster efforts here.at least i think there's no way scum cares that little about the game for so long especially when they were scumread |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
| We probably should start humoring that there is at least one wolf in cross/jack based on Mood's calling them both out as obvious wolves |
| Would rather get cantrip out today if he doesn't post anything that sways me, just want to get this out there |
Marluxion said: honestly in this case I would rather lynch shin and use dono to clear/catch cross or even jack. logic340 said: wait why? Is it because he's considered LHF here? Nibio/shin unlikely to me nib doesn't stick his neck out this much for a teammate. But I'm not sold on the meta or the interactions. You got something else? Scum WIM should be at an all time high right now his attitude doesn't add up with that i could be wrong and it could be fake but dono can clear him tonight if we dont lynch her |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: that's not happening if she's town and we don't hit the JkMarluxion said: honestly in this case I would rather lynch shin and use dono to clear/catch cross or even jack. Scum WIM should be at an all time high right now his attitude doesn't add up with that i could be wrong and it could be fake but dono can clear him tonight if we dont lynch her |
Nibio said: him and shinichi are in a similar place for me so either is acceptable. Would rather get cantrip out today if he doesn't post anything that sways me, just want to get this out there |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
| If we hit the jailor today, then Dias' and Awa are confirmed |
Nibio said: oh damn....you're right. Dias will be jailed again so Mafia just kill dono....fuck so we need to hit jk today. This means we should lynch in the vanilla claims again thenlogic340 said: that's not happening if she's town and we don't hit the Jkhonestly in this case I would rather lynch shin and use dono to clear/catch cross or even jack. Vanilla claims Logic Nibio Jack Cross Cantrip Shinichi |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Nibio said: Nah, if we hit any of the scum PR, then me and Dias confirmed. Coz I'm sure of scum PR roles now.If we hit the jailor today, then Dias' and Awa are confirmed But if we don't hit jailor, me and Dias have pretty much useless night ability. Me at least. |
|
| That's also a good point @aa-dono @albertinodias Little bit of flavor gaming, were you told you were jailkept? I cant remember if you answered this, or were u just told your action failed |
Nibio said: I was told I was jailed.That's also a good point @aa-dono @albertinodias Little bit of flavor gaming, were you told you were jailkept? I cant remember if you answered this, or were u just told your action failed |
|
| Two investigatives for town would align with mafia having a JK, since if it was a 1/1 ratio, and Dias' is real, then we would never be able to get an mechanical information, if the investigative ever outted |
| Mafia really isn't in a good spot right now, they don't win this by being lurkers |
| Night 1 reset non-consecutive actions, should any have existed. |
| Had I the heavens’ embroidered cloths, Enwrought with golden and silver light, The blue and the dim and the dark cloths Of night and light and the half light, I would spread the cloths under your feet: But I, being poor, have only my dreams; I have spread my dreams under your feet; Tread softly because you tread on my dreams. - WB Yeats |
| Well based off that flip I think Dono and Dias are more likely town as much as I would love my early scums reads on them being correct. I doubt we only have a cop and vig as PR. Since both claim being jailed it means both are scum or none are. On the ones remaining I still want to clear Nibio because of their interactions with Mood I think they can fake reactions but not that much, they is a world where still scum but doubtful either way that is Lylo for me. Logic and Shin are in a similar spot where both to me don't appear town but I think Shin is more likely town with his approach if he is scum that would be with Nibio and I dont want to look there just yet as said. So that leaves Cross and Cantrip who I could see being the scum team, Cross has being trying to figure it out but nothing big has really came from the slot for a while, I just feel like he is buying for time and living off his early game. He had interactions with Mood that make him look town but Mood was likely annoying his team mates as well so these points hold less merit so I could lynch here today. Cantrip has just being playing catchup all game his posts look good, but nothing has really came from this slot and I sort of want to live in the world where my guess yesterday is right and he is scum with Cross. So I'm good lynching one of Cross Cantrip and Logic today |
 |
aa-dono said: Nibio said: I was told I was jailed.That's also a good point @aa-dono @albertinodias Little bit of flavor gaming, were you told you were jailkept? I cant remember if you answered this, or were u just told your action failed same, i was told i was jailed |
 |
| @AlbertinoDias if the lynch hits the jailkeeper you are ALWAYS on awa if the lynch doesn't, you're wifoming protect whoever you think gets killed |
| Hi, still not scum Karote lynch was 100% my own fault but I still contend that that slot had to die that phase. He was never going to clear himself and was literally not posting. Why people join mafia games and don't post, I swear I will try to resolve again today but I am honestly pretty lost as to who the bad guys are; the problem is that both mood and roz are such erratic players it's hard to come to definitive conclusions about their spew Need to think about dono claiming nonconsecutive night tracker and what it means. Feels like there was a smoking gun somewhere itt about that but I need to check up on it Will catch up more in a bit Marluxion said: Tell me how I've been trying to "look" townie as opposed to actuary trying my best to solve the gameCross has basically just been trying to sound towny all game and look like he's trying to solve. I don't like how quickly he came around to the karote lynch yesterday. I wanted to lynch logic yesterday over Karote but I couldn't possibly justify lynching someone who was still playing the game over someone who was stone posting nothing. If we have 4 mislynches and lurkers to clear out, I'm always picking the lurkers because they cannot live to lylo |
| @crossbell would you take offense if I said I doubt you could fake all this content for this long as a wolf based on how I've seen you play wolf in the past? the problem right now for me I think is Cantrip, and I personally think he is one of the hardest players from MTGS to read |
| I know this is going to be shocking to you all, but I didn't spend any time on this during the Night. :( Weekends are my busy time, and I didn't do anything in any of my games. I don't really see how Karote and Eyeh flipping town change much of anything. Marl is still confirmed town, Nibio is still a super strong town read for me based on interactions with Mood early game. Dias and Dono are claimed PRs that make sense from, at least, a design perspective. I guess there's a slight possibility that Dono is scum and fake-claimed being jailed to buy some later game cred, but then why draw attention to herself with the "oops, I'm really non-consec tracker" admission rather than just faking something? We're still in ok position, though, so here's my likely lunch order preference: Logic Shinichi Jack Cross Me But I understand if people want to solve me toDay; I just know it won't get us closer to a win. I'll continue catching up on D1/D2; not starting over because we don't have any more red bodies to analyze, but at least I won't have to worry about Karote's non-commital posts any more. |
| No, I know full well my wolf game is awful If I replaced into a wolf slot after not playing for a year i would putter and die I'll take a deeper look at cantrip today |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8756 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 24, 8:27 AM |
|
» [READ THIS] - Mafia Colosseumosieorb18 - Jun 5, 2019 |
3 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 24, 8:27 AM |
|
» [GAME] Never have I ever... ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Jan 30, 2016 |
1623 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 20, 7:43 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1997 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 20, 7:42 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2878 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 20, 7:41 PM |