Wanna take this more seriously and vote as a group on which works should be added to the anime/manga relations? (no more Miru Tights and One Room!)
This could also serve as a recommendation area where people who are interested in quality works can look for stuff to watch/read.
I'm not entirely sure about the most efficient way to go about voting (maybe a Discord gc where you add a reaction like a check mark or an x to a message containing the title of the work). Edit: I'll probably make a Google Forms survey every now and then and share the results.
For adding an anime, the requirements should be something like: 1) at least 3 club members (in total) have completed it, 2) votes will be decided by simple majority; in the case of a tie the anime will not be added to the relations.
For adding a manga, the requirements should be something like: 1) at least 2 club members (in total) have completed it, 2) votes will be decided by simple majority; in the case of a tie the manga will not be added to the relations. (more people watch anime than read manga so the requirements are looser - also, these requirements are subject to change)
*Completed means: For anime, 1-18 ep - must be completed, 18-37 ep - at least 1/2 must be completed, 37+ ep - at least 1/4 must be completed. For manga, at least 1/2 must be completed. If it is currently airing/publishing the same rules apply, except it is determined by the latest episode/chapter. Always round up.
Of course, anime and manga on the relations will not be guaranteed a permanent spot. *This section will be updated at a later date, along with a more organized nomination process.
If anyone wants to participate in this, reply with a list of anime/manga you believe to be exemplary (featuring good execution of themes, strong characters, solid plot, etc.). To easily check if others have watched/read whatever you plan to nominate (as to satisfy the requirement for minimum number of ppl), go to the anime/manga in question, click "stats," and scroll down to see if any of your peers have watched/read it.
I am bored and this seems like a fun thing to do; plus, it could shed light on more obscure works that are worth checking out.
I'll come up with a list of anime/manga that satisfies requirement #1 (minimum number of people) later today. Hopefully other people will do the same so I can create a Google Forms survey putting the nominated works up for voting.
Anime:
Angel Beats!
Barakamon
Clannad: After Story
Cowboy Bebop
Hyouka
K-ON!!
Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon
Koe no Katachi
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion
Ookami to Koushinryou
Perfect Blue
Planetes
Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi
Serial Experiments Lain
Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso
Shirobako
Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Sora yori mo Tooi Basho
Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu
Usagi Drop
Violet Evergarden
White Album 2
Yuru Camp△
Feel free to nominate something even if it was already nominated by someone else; in other words, just nominate whatever you believe is good and satisfies the 3-person requirement (or 2-person for manga). I'll create a Google Forms survey once a bunch of people nominate stuff.
Great Teacher Onizuka
Monogatari Series Second Season
Oregairu (all seasons !!)
Neon Genesis End of Evangelion
Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu
Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu
Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai
Rascal Does Not Dream of A Dreaming Girl
Your Lie in April
Manga
Great Teacher Onizuka (again!!)
One Piece
No one reads same manga as me so sad
Barakamon
Charlotte
Hinamatsuri
Hunter x Hunter
Hyouka
K-On!
Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Tensai-tachi no Renai Zunosen
Made in Abyss
Monogatari Series Second Season
No Game No Life
No Game No Life Zero
Noragami
Sakurasou na Pet no Kanojo
Shelter
Shigatsu wa Kimi to Uso
Tenki no Ko
Manga:
Act - Age :(
Barakamon
Grand Blue
Horimiya
Ib: instant bullet
Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Tensai-tachi no Renai Zunosen
Kono Bijutsubu ni wa Mondai ga Aru!
Medaka Box
Ookami Shounen wa Kyou mo Uso wo Kasaneru
Spiral: Suiri no Kizuna
Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou
Zetsuen no Tempest
Tim nominations (I interrogated him via Discord), for Jacob I'll automatically nominate everything on his list that meets the requirements.
Anime:
Amagi Brilliant Park
Angel Beats!
A Silent Voice
BanG Dream Garupa Pico (this man is legendary)
Blue Exorcist
Clannad
Clannad: After Story
Code Geass
I want to eat your pancreas
Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid
Mob Psycho 100
Naruto
Non Non Biyori
One Punch Man
Sora yori mo Tooi Basho
Tokyo Ghoul
Toradora!
Violet Evergarden
Yuru Camp
Now I can finally make the survey (after reading some manga like Reversible and All You Need is Kill so it meets the requirements; I'll also nominate Madoka Magica, Death Note, Anohana, and Kimi no Na wa since those are epic and have not been nominated).
A Place Further Than The Universe
A Silent Voice
Amagi Brilliant Park
Angel Beats!
Anohana
Assassination Classroom
Attack on Titan
BanG Dream Garupa Pico
Barakamon
Blend S
Blue Exorcist
Charlotte
Clannad
Clannad: After Story
Code Geass
Cowboy Bebop
Death Note
Death Parade
Girls' Last Tour
Grand Blue
Great Teacher Onizuka
Hinamatsuri
Hunter x Hunter
Hyouka
I want to eat your pancreas
K-ON!
K-ON! Movie
K-ON!!
Love is War
Lucky☆Star
Made in Abyss
Madoka Magica
Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid
Mob Psycho 100
Monogatari Series Second Season
Monster
Naruto
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion
No Game No Life
No Game No Life Zero
Non Non Biyori
Noragami
One Punch Man
Oregairu (all seasons !!)
Owarimonogatari (s1 + s2)
Perfect Blue
Planetes
Rascal Does Not Dream of A Dreaming Girl
Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai
Serial Experiments Lain
Shelter
Shirobako
Spice and Wolf
Spirited Away
The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya
The Disastrous Life of Saiki K
The Helpful Fox Senko-san
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
The Pet Girl of Sakurasou
Tokyo Ghoul
Toradora!
Usagi Drop
Violet Evergarden
Weathering With You
White Album 2
Working!!
Yakusoku no Neverland
Your Lie in April
Your Name
Yuru Camp△
All You Need Is Kill
Attack on Titan
Barakamon
Demon Slayer
Girls' Last Tour
Grand Blue
Hitori Koukan Nikki
Horimiya
Ib: instant bullet
Kono Bijutsubu ni wa Mondai ga Aru!
Love is War
Medaka Box
One Piece
One Punch Man
Ookami Shounen wa Kyou mo Uso wo Kasaneru
Reversible!
Sabishisugite Lesbian Fuuzoku ni Ikimashita Report
Spiral: Suiri no Kizuna
Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou
Let me know if any anime/manga are missing, I did remove a few because they did not meet the requirement of minimum number of people and I could have missed some by accident too.
A Place Further Than The Universe (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
A Silent Voice (4 Y, 1 N, 3 IDK)
Angel Beats! (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Assassination Classroom (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
BanG Dream! Garupa Pico (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Barakamon (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Blend S (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Clannad (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Clannad: After Story (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Code Geass (4 Y, 1 N, 3 IDK)
Cowboy Bebop (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Girls' Last Tour (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Hunter x Hunter (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Hyouka (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
I want to eat your pancreas (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
K-ON! (5 Y, 1 N, 2 IDK)
K-ON!! (5 Y, 1 N, 2 IDK)
K-ON! Movie (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Love is War (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Lucky☆Star (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Made in Abyss (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Madoka Magica (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid (5 Y, 1 N, 2 IDK)
Mob Psycho 100 (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Monogatari Series: Second Season (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Monster (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Naruto (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Neon Genesis Evangelion (5 Y, 2 N, 1 IDK)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
Noragami (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
One Punch Man (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
Oregairu Zoku (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Owarimonogatari (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Owarimonogatari Second Season (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Perfect Blue (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Serial Experiments Lain (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Shirobako (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Spice and Wolf (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Spirited Away (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
The Disastrous Life of Saiki K (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
The Helpful Fox Senko-san (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
The Pet Girl of Sakurasou (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Toradora! (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Usagi Drop (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Violet Evergarden (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Weathering With You (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
White Album 2 (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Yakusoku no Neverland (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Your Lie in April (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
Yuru Camp△ (4 Y, 1 N, 3 IDK)
Amagi Brilliant Park (2 Y, 2 N, 4 IDK)
AnoHana (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
Attack on Titan (1 Y, 2 N, 5 IDK)
Blue Exorcist (0 Y, 2 N, 6 IDK)
Charlotte (2 Y, 2 N, 4 IDK)
Death Note (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
Death Parade (2 Y, 2 N, 4 IDK)
Grand Blue (2 Y, 3 N, 3 IDK)
Great Teacher Onizuka (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Hinamatsuri (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
No Game No Life (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
No Game No Life: Zero (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
Non Non Biyori (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Oregairu (1 Y, 4 N, 3 IDK)
Planetes (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Rascal Does Not Dream of A Dreaming Girl (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
Shelter (2 Y, 3 N, 3 IDK)
Tokyo Ghoul (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
Working!! (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Your Name (2 Y, 3 N, 3 IDK)
All You Need Is Kill (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Attack on Titan (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Barakamon (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Girls' Last Tour (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Hitori Koukan Nikki (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Horimiya (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Ib: instant bullet (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Kono Bijutsubu ni wa Mondai ga Aru! (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Love is War (1 Y, 0 N, 7 IDK)
Medaka Box (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
One Punch Man (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Ookami Shounen wa Kyou mo Uso wo Kasaneru (1 Y, 0 N, 7 IDK)
Reversible! (1 Y, 0 N, 7 IDK)
Sabishisugite Lesbian Fuuzoku ni Ikimashita Report (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Spiral: Suiri no Kizuna (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Demon Slayer (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Grand Blue (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
One Piece (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
4
Cowboy Bebop (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Girls' Last Tour (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
K-ON! (5 Y, 1 N, 2 IDK)
K-ON!! (5 Y, 1 N, 2 IDK)
Made in Abyss (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid (5 Y, 1 N, 2 IDK)
Monogatari Series: Second Season (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Owarimonogatari (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Usagi Drop (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
Violet Evergarden (4 Y, 0 N, 4 IDK)
3
A Silent Voice (4 Y, 1 N, 3 IDK)
Clannad: After Story (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Code Geass (4 Y, 1 N, 3 IDK)
Hyouka (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Lucky☆Star (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Neon Genesis Evangelion (5 Y, 2 N, 1 IDK)
Owarimonogatari Second Season (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Perfect Blue (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Serial Experiments Lain (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Spice and Wolf (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Yakusoku no Neverland (3 Y, 0 N, 5 IDK)
Yuru Camp△ (4 Y, 1 N, 3 IDK)
2
A Place Further Than The Universe (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Assassination Classroom (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Barakamon (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Clannad (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
I want to eat your pancreas (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
K-ON! Movie (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Madoka Magica (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Mob Psycho 100 (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
Noragami (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
One Punch Man (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
Oregairu Zoku (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Spirited Away (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
The Disastrous Life of Saiki K (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Your Lie in April (4 Y, 2 N, 2 IDK)
1
Angel Beats! (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
BanG Dream! Garupa Pico (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Blend S (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Hunter x Hunter (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Love is War (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Monster (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Naruto (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Shirobako (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
The Helpful Fox Senko-san (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
The Pet Girl of Sakurasou (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
Toradora! (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
Weathering With You (3 Y, 2 N, 3 IDK)
White Album 2 (2 Y, 1 N, 5 IDK)
0
Amagi Brilliant Park (2 Y, 2 N, 4 IDK)
Charlotte (2 Y, 2 N, 4 IDK)
Death Note (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
Death Parade (2 Y, 2 N, 4 IDK)
Great Teacher Onizuka (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Hinamatsuri (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
Non Non Biyori (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Planetes (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Rascal Does Not Dream of A Dreaming Girl (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai (3 Y, 3 N, 2 IDK)
Working!! (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
-1
Attack on Titan (1 Y, 2 N, 5 IDK)
Grand Blue (2 Y, 3 N, 3 IDK)
Shelter (2 Y, 3 N, 3 IDK)
Your Name (2 Y, 3 N, 3 IDK)
-2
AnoHana (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
Blue Exorcist (0 Y, 2 N, 6 IDK)
No Game No Life (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
No Game No Life: Zero (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
Tokyo Ghoul (1 Y, 3 N, 4 IDK)
-3
Oregairu (1 Y, 4 N, 3 IDK)
2
All You Need Is Kill (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Attack on Titan (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Barakamon (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Girls' Last Tour (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Hitori Koukan Nikki (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Horimiya (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Ib: instant bullet (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Kono Bijutsubu ni wa Mondai ga Aru! (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Medaka Box (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
One Punch Man (3 Y, 1 N, 4 IDK)
Sabishisugite Lesbian Fuuzoku ni Ikimashita Report (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Spiral: Suiri no Kizuna (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou (2 Y, 0 N, 6 IDK)
1
Love is War (1 Y, 0 N, 7 IDK)
Ookami Shounen wa Kyou mo Uso wo Kasaneru (1 Y, 0 N, 7 IDK)
Reversible! (1 Y, 0 N, 7 IDK)
0
Demon Slayer (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Grand Blue (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
One Piece (1 Y, 1 N, 6 IDK)
Calculated by subtracting "No" votes from "Yes" votes. "IDK" votes do not affect the score. Note that this is most likely not completely accurate, it is only a general estimate.
For anime, 4 is the best and -3 is the worst. For manga, 2 is the best and 0 is the worst.