You'v activated my trap card!............for some reason............. |
  |
| @LucianRoy I don't think it is I can't remember when Shuuka was scum hunting or posting in general. I literally don't think it has happened unless I missed something (like I missed all of bioshadese posts initially) |
Soren said: Crossbell said: I wanted to do something else other than a rvs vote. Never really intended for this policy lynch to go through nor did I think it would which is why I never pushed it, as it was just a placeholder for a rvs vote. If a train did form I would start questioning it and see where to go from there.Was this serious? I assume that this was used to garner reactions. Soren: Was this a reaction test? If so, what reactions/insights did you get from posting this? Fudge. I thought you were serious about that. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Are you implying im white knighting to save dono because i wouldn't do that and she also knows i wouldn't lol. Not really fat fetched cause i pointed out changes in your playstyle. Why not you white knight everyone else. Siiiicckkk buuuurrrnnn |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Bee-Boy said: @LucianRoy I don't think it is I can't remember when Shuuka was scum hunting or posting in general. I literally don't think it has happened unless I missed something (like I missed all of bioshadese posts initially) But you have seen shuuka's posts/vote, right? Do you still have the scumread on them? |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Shinichi-Kun said: Soren said: I wanted to do something else other than a rvs vote. Never really intended for this policy lynch to go through nor did I think it would which is why I never pushed it, as it was just a placeholder for a rvs vote. If a train did form I would start questioning it and see where to go from there. I actually like this reasoning tho too bad your trap didn't really give you any info, but at the same time this could just be a great defense to get some people to look away from you. Smooth "I like this reasoning" coming from shin over here. Smooth fencesitting with the "this could just be a great defense to get some people to look away from you." Nice positioning you got going on here. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
LucianRoy said: Shinichi-Kun said: I actually like this reasoning tho too bad your trap didn't really give you any info, but at the same time this could just be a great defense to get some people to look away from you. Smooth "I like this reasoning" coming from shin over here. Smooth fencesitting with the "this could just be a great defense to get some people to look away from you." Nice positioning you got going on here. This a compliment or sarcasm :D |
  |
Arrisu said: Shinichi-Kun said: How do u read shuuka as scum lol if anything everyones read on her should be neutral cause she's done nothing significant to say other wise Her vote on Jack was not only insignificant, it was only adding to the biggest train. She could easily use that to add power to a town lynch as scum. So of course she would choose to join such a large train. I see. Bee-boy, like, did you read her insertion to the Jack train as scummy same as Ari? |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Shinichi-Kun said: This a compliment or sarcasm :D Mebbe it's both? |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
LucianRoy said: Bee-Boy said: @LucianRoy I don't think it is I can't remember when Shuuka was scum hunting or posting in general. I literally don't think it has happened unless I missed something (like I missed all of bioshadese posts initially) But you have seen shuuka's posts/vote, right? Do you still have the scumread on them? I don't intend on capitalizing on it but I still feel as though Shuuka is lurking. |
Shinichi-Kun said: Bee-Boy said: Like this only works if aa-donho and Shinichi-kun vote each other. Woudln't vote a neutral read She's a neutral read despite voting the same person as you? How do you read her now D1's all said-and-done? |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Bee-Boy said: LucianRoy said: But you have seen shuuka's posts/vote, right? Do you still have the scumread on them? I don't intend on capitalizing on it but I still feel as though Shuuka is lurking. I wouldn't consider it lurking cause Ik she gets busy quite alot and over work herself. |
|
LucianRoy said: She's a neutral read despite voting the same person as you? How do you read her now D1's all said-and-done? I read her both as slight scum and slight town, because her questions give off a "I'm townie that want's answers", but at the same time she's not really doing much to help town or stand out as a scum hunter. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: Not one to tell you how to play your games, but in H VH he got replaced and the replacement died lol. He is a bit off lately that is true but with mafia you have to see this as a scum mindset most of the time. Oh ya i forgot he got replaced, but even so he was weird that game but this game he's posting a decent amount which is why i give him that slight scum read. Do you know Soren's meta? Why are you pointing out his activity as scummy in the first place? Activity=null, no? |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
LucianRoy said: Shinichi-Kun said: Oh ya i forgot he got replaced, but even so he was weird that game but this game he's posting a decent amount which is why i give him that slight scum read. Do you know Soren's meta? Why are you pointing out his activity as scummy in the first place? Activity=null, no? Because lately hes been strange so wanted to see if it had any effect on his alignment |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: LucianRoy said: She's a neutral read despite voting the same person as you? How do you read her now D1's all said-and-done? I read her both as slight scum and slight town, because her questions give off a "I'm townie that want's answers", but at the same time she's not really doing much to help town or stand out as a scum hunter. Ok, is that still your read now? Why did you feel it was ok to send a neutral read into the twilight phase? I don't know if she provided more yesterday because I'm on page 12. If she did, does she ever follow up on that huge questioning purge she did a while back? |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
LucianRoy said: Shinichi-Kun said: I read her both as slight scum and slight town, because her questions give off a "I'm townie that want's answers", but at the same time she's not really doing much to help town or stand out as a scum hunter. Ok, is that still your read now? Why did you feel it was ok to send a neutral read into the twilight phase? I don't know if she provided more yesterday because I'm on page 12. If she did, does she ever follow up on that huge questioning purge she did a while back? Hmm not like I had much control over her going there or not, I didn't have the mean's to defend her so how could i stop other's from voting her? Not sure if she ever did |
|
Day 2 START KitSith (bioshade2) was killed. He was... Arrisu was killed. She was... >> Time until the phase change << |
 |
| Aww, that sucks. |
| Hmm |
|
| Well whomever is the Vig they messed up big time. |
|
| Ya and our vig also sent us to mylo... Our vig sucked on so many different levels. We should probably mass claim though is everyone down? |
Bee-Boy said: Ya and our vig also sent us to mylo... Our vig sucked on so many different levels. We should probably mass claim though is everyone down? With fake claims not sure how much good a massclaim will do us, all that does is show all the power roles. We should be able to find a scum without putting all our power at risk, but whatever everyone else wants to do. Viglante has ruined us in a big way though as you say but they can still redeem themselfs. |
 |
| I need to think a good bit right now so going afk. |
|
| Mass claim would be good to narrow the PoE pool, given that we are in lylo. Double lynching is also good today since we will lose regardless. |
| Not sure why our vigilante would shoot on night 1 >_> |
|
| I wouldn't shame the vig in all honesty. They shot a consensus null/Not Town read, and it was just bad luck that the vig shot the Flavor Cop. |
| Done thinking. There is another Alternative. We go into Twilight & No Lynch. |
|
| Damn tho was wrong about arrisu, gotta revalute my reads now. |
|
Crossbell said: I wouldn't shame the vig in all honesty. They shot a consensus null/Not Town read, and it was just bad luck that the vig shot the Flavor Cop. Why do u think vig shot bioshade? |
|
| That way we get 1 more Day for sure to work with. |
|
| I think the person we should look at the most is followind Also Trying to figure who killed who might give us a better understanding of who could be scum. |
|
Crossbell said: I wouldn't shame the vig in all honesty. They shot a consensus null/Not Town read, and it was just bad luck that the vig shot the Flavor Cop. It is more they shot at all in a game where we can't afford any mistakes as it is. The fact that it was a cop makes it worse of course if they did shoot them anyway. Possible Viglante shot Ari as well but that would make even less sense. I would normally agree with a viglante shooting but in this setup a lot more caution then a random null read was needed. |
|
| Unsure, and if we're mass claiming today then the vig will have the chance to go over his/her thought process, so it's unlikely that that question would yield much of anything. |
Crossbell said: Unsure, and if we're mass claiming today then the vig will have the chance to go over his/her thought process, so it's unlikely that that question would yield much of anything. I think if anyone should claim it should be the vigilante might help us deduce his thought process and if we can figure who he targetted we can figure out why the other victim was shot by mafia. |
|
| Honestly the vig made such a bad move (sorry vig) |
| -Sigh- |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: Damn tho was wrong about arrisu, gotta revalute my reads now. Ari is not that agressive as scum in my exp so not sure how you saw her as bad. mad question Shinchi but I feel a need to ask it did you shoot Ari because if that was the viglante kill I can only see you been mad enough to do it. |
|
SightlessReality said: That way we get 1 more Day for sure to work with. This is probably the best move honestly. |
Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Damn tho was wrong about arrisu, gotta revalute my reads now. Ari is not that agressive as scum in my exp so not sure how you saw her as bad. mad question Shinchi but I feel a need to ask it did you shoot Ari because if that was the viglante kill I can only see you been mad enough to do it. No i wouldn't i don't shoot people solely on emotion >_> smh for even thinking I did it lol. |
|
Crossbell said: I suggest we massclaim, but power roles only need to say they are power roles without any more info. We should then lynch 2 from the pool of vanillas.Mass claim would be good to narrow the PoE pool, given that we are in lylo. Double lynching is also good today since we will lose regardless. |
 |
| rip me. :'( Good luck town. |
 |
Togs said: Crossbell said: I suggest we massclaim, but power roles only need to say they are power roles without any more info. We should then lynch 2 from the pool of vanillas.Mass claim would be good to narrow the PoE pool, given that we are in lylo. Double lynching is also good today since we will lose regardless. Eh, we aren't done yet. It's honestly better if we No Lynch today (as bad as that is ordinarily) because it gives us 1 more day for sure to ultimately work with. Rather then hedging our bets today. |
|
Togs said: Crossbell said: I suggest we massclaim, but power roles only need to say they are power roles without any more info. We should then lynch 2 from the pool of vanillas.Mass claim would be good to narrow the PoE pool, given that we are in lylo. Double lynching is also good today since we will lose regardless. too risky if we lynch 2 vanillas its gg if they both flip town. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: It's actually gg if we lynch one and guess wrong, so we might as well double the odds.Togs said: I suggest we massclaim, but power roles only need to say they are power roles without any more info. We should then lynch 2 from the pool of vanillas. too risky if we lynch 2 vanillas its gg if they both flip town. |
|
| I have another party to go to tonight. Sorry guys. No lynch option sounds best to me. If we do that, we can save the massclaim for later and give the PRs another night. That's just solid play. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| I think the vig should claim at this point regardless the course of action we take today. In all honesty, I hope they did not shoot Ari because she was a strong town read based on the general consensus of the town. I predict the mafia would kill Ari since she claimed and was essentially "confirmed" town by that point with the exception of a few. As for no lynch. It sounds tempting since we need as much info as possible, but I still want to drive this into the twilight phase so we have that additional 24 hours to work with and add pressure on to a narrow list of suspects. I never condone mass claiming in any game I play, but if this is what town sees as the best course of action, then I will have to comply. |
|
SoulEaterQUEEN said: I think the vig should claim at this point regardless the course of action we take today. In all honesty, I hope they did not shoot Ari because she was a strong town read based on the general consensus of the town. I predict the mafia would kill Ari since she claimed and was essentially "confirmed" town by that point with the exception of a few. As for no lynch. It sounds tempting since we need as much info as possible, but I still want to drive this into the twilight phase so we have that additional 24 hours to work with and add pressure on to a narrow list of suspects. I never condone mass claiming in any game I play, but if this is what town sees as the best course of action, then I will have to comply. Oh I completely agree about bringing the game into Twilight. Though doing so could be tricky since Mafia are so close to winning they could mass vote at the end of the day to win. |
|
SightlessReality said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: I think the vig should claim at this point regardless the course of action we take today. In all honesty, I hope they did not shoot Ari because she was a strong town read based on the general consensus of the town. I predict the mafia would kill Ari since she claimed and was essentially "confirmed" town by that point with the exception of a few. As for no lynch. It sounds tempting since we need as much info as possible, but I still want to drive this into the twilight phase so we have that additional 24 hours to work with and add pressure on to a narrow list of suspects. I never condone mass claiming in any game I play, but if this is what town sees as the best course of action, then I will have to comply. Oh I completely agree about bringing the game into Twilight. Though doing so could be tricky since Mafia are so close to winning they could mass vote at the end of the day to win. This is true but it is a risk I am willing to take if there are enough trustworthy active town players by the end of the phase, by this statement we are assuming that all mafia are active at this stage, and I am definitely willing to bet on the lurker list that there's definitely scum there. |
|
| Lets claim in this order, or as close to this order as possible. If you are vanilla, claim your flavor as well. If you are a power role, ONLY claim that you are a PR without flavor. If you want to claim your full power role for whatever purpose, please wait to do so until at least the first half of the list has claimed. I'll go first since I might not be able to post until later. I'm TK, town vanilla. 1. @Togs 2. @followind 3. @LucianRoy 4. @Shuuka 5. @Jackrito 6. @aa-dono 7. @SightlessReality 8. @Bee-Boy 9. @SoulEaterQUEEN 10. @Crossbell 11. @Shinichi-kun |
|
More topics from this board
» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fo - Jul 10, 2014 |
3747 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 24, 9:02 PM |
|
» [GAME] Q&A ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )khonsutora - Aug 30, 2014 |
2405 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 24, 9:01 PM |
|
» [GAME] Say something about the person above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Haine - Jul 19, 2014 |
3813 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 18, 1:10 AM |
|
» [GAME] Give something to the user above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Soren - Oct 9, 2015 |
1395 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 13, 9:10 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8755 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 11, 7:29 PM |