Reviews

Shy (Anime) add (All reviews)
Dec 18, 2023
7_3
I think it’s safe to say that as time has passed, anime has gotten much, much more advanced, becoming more capable in all aspects than ever before. We’re getting some serious level-ups here in visual effects, in music, in animation handling quality, in everything you can think of. I mean, look at the Monogatari series. Sure, it’s quite old at this point (the first anime, Bakemonogatari, aired in 2009), but you can really see that studio Shaft killed it with displaying Akiyuki Shinbou’s creativity in the visual effects, worked a stellar job on the animation handling using clever techniques, and the music was, well, certainly not the norm. It’s VERY ahead of its time, at least in my eyes. This season’s SHY has some pretty unique visual effects too.

And that’s about it for the notable stuff in it.

Think of a Krispy-Kreme donut, about to be finished and put on sale. The bagel’s fresh out of the oven and all that’s left is for the glazing to be put on. But wait, the bagel was actually half-baked, and someone dropped it on the floor by accident. On the way to the baker-thingy-whatever, someone somehow rapid-fire sneezed in every corner of the room possible, and all that stuff landed on the unbaked bagel. After being half-baked, the delicious, appetizing glazing is put on, making the bagel a finished donut, and giving it a pretty touch-up. That donut is SHY. If you didn’t catch on to anything I said, basically what SHY is, is a poorly-conveyed, poorly-directed anime with a horribly overpompous attempt at being meaningful, and flashy, over-the-top visual effects to draw people in and make the dummies think that the anime is actually good by that quality alone.

I was extremely disappointed that, when I opened Crunchyroll, searched up SHY, and clicked on the title and its first episode, I was greeted with an overused excuse of a weak, insecure and socially inept MC, because I actually expected this to be something new, refreshing and different after the high and almighty visuals that came before. Instead, after upping your expectations, you’re smacked with that MC, and later presented with the most generic plotline in the world. Not just generic, but predictable as fuck too. It’s about these magical girls—ahem, superheroes—that each represent a country and together have to fight off some similarly one-dimensional villains threatening… the world? (I swear, they’re there just for the superheroes to find them and go all gung-ho on them). And all the while you are watching, it bombards you with super COOL and SLICK and MODERN visual effects and camerawork, all for you to lick up off the dirty floor. I shouldn’t have listened to the one person on an unreliable part of the internet cheering SHY on, claiming it’d be the anime of the season, because holy shit, it is not.

A lot of the time there are underlying messages in anime, hidden under the surface of its main attraction. A perfect case for this kind of anime is Cossette no Shouzou, a three-episode OVA with a similar score to SHY on MAL, filled to the brim with clever and appealing visual effects, accompanied with masterful animation handling and a similarly masterful soundtrack. Its main plot is drenched in the ‘donut glazing,’ so much so that it becomes hard to understand what actually is happening anymore. SHY does the exact same thing, only it wouldn’t have been so unnecessarily bad without its 'glazing'. Cossette no Shouzou needed its fanciness to portray the rest of its story and so the viewer wouldn’t be turned away due to the weird plot behind it, but SHY on the other hand just throws it all at you with a completely normal, completely fine-on-its-own message of ‘even if you’re a socially weak mess that looks like your textbook American nerd, if you believe in yourself and gain enough courage, you can be a normal woman’. It puts all its good qualities to waste and makes everything ten times more dramatic and serious than it needed to be, and it often becomes laughable. At least it was laughable, though.

You know, my expectations might have been a bit biased, as I’d seen someone praying that SHY’d be the anime of the season, and I’d also watched the PV that really, REALLY gaslighted me into thinking it’d be a unique anime. But I wasn’t expecting at all, even with my lowest expectations, that there’d be fillers. I thought we were past that era, I thought we’d learned from that. But no, no! Our author really wanted to stretch their story on and on! If these fillers were meant as a break from all the mess, they should’ve just toned the mess down, not strip the anime of its last bit of meaningful sense and reduce it to a dull and drab slice of life with no relation or necessity to the plot.

It's a shame that the animation handling was actually somewhat well-worked compared to the rest of this anime. Wasted budget and effort went into animating this godawful experience, and I can’t help but feel a strange pity for the animators that worked so hard to actually make this some good eye candy and not some poorly-worked garbage of abject misery. But I’m going to beat the dead horse here and say the animation handling isn’t anything amazing. I may have praised it, but that’s just because it’s not absolute rubbish like most of everything else in this anime. There are clear flaws strewn throughout (like Pepesha literally popping into frame out of nowhere) and some questionable usages of CGI, namely with Ebio-san. More on the directorial side of things, the animation handling can sometimes, out of nowhere, get overly flashy for no reason whatsoever, especially when random trivial scenes play out as opposed to where it’s really needed: the action scenes.

I love spending my time on YouTube, and I’m sure many others reading this do too. It’s an unavoidable part of the internet that’s just about held captive over two billion souls. And a big chunk of those two billion souls know the horrors of the cringy intros and outros that were prolific in every YouTube video back in the late 2010s. And now this year we had to relive that horror again, this time in the form of an anime. Not only is the OP a horrific vomit-inducing vertiginous mess of overused transitions with nauseating camerawork and overdecorative everything, but the visual effects ejaculated everywhere throughout the anime’s runtime doesn’t make it any better. That’s right, I’m bashing the visual effects even more. Oh, we’re going over a tragic event? Let’s add thirty spinning camera transitions and a snow filter so the viewer can’t see shit! Are we explaining some unnecessarily ostentatious lore that’ll change these characters’ lives forever? Let’s put on a film grain filter and make twenty-two triangles and eighteen squares ease into the screen, all starting at a thirty-four-degree angle and ending at a ninety-two-degree angle using keyframing! There might not actually be that stuff, but that’s the kind of stupidity you’ll want to expect. There’s a reason the manga is rated higher: It probably didn’t try to win a fucking Nobel Prize with dizzying visual effects like the anime did. The Nobel Prize for the most detriment to human eyes is what the anime is winning.

For how outwards they went with making the visual effects look like unicorn barf, the artstyle is probably the most non-infuriating, plain and normal thing in SHY. It’s like a ‘wake the fuck up, motherfucker’ call that snaps you out of the trance the visual effects threw you into. It reminds you that you’re not always experiencing Satou Yoshiteru-style directing and xXStickyHotdogGamingXx YouTube intros. It reminds you that at least this travesty can at least be mediocre and not all crapola. What I wrote just before might be the tiny little praise I’ll give to the artstyle in light of the rest of the garbage, but I can’t find anything to criticize, which shows just how bland it is. It’s almost the same as every artstyle you see mangaka use nowadays when they’re too tired or devoid of creativity, or the artstyle big companies use when they have zero budget left to spend on the character designers. Oopsie-daisy, I just criticized it, didn’t I?

Seems like we’re taking a break from all the rubbish, because now we’re talking about SHY’s music. It’s far from great, but it’s at least one look away from this eyesore of an anime. The music director knew what they were doing, appropriately picking when to play and what to play. You might be watching that one filler part of an episode I talked about, and you’d be hearing pretty carefree, light music, and a few minutes later you might be watching an action scene, a battle between superheroes and villains, and you could be hearing intense or tension-building music, or that weird piano piece that plays two chords each three times exactly… (shut up i’m not good at defining music genres ok) The music itself, though, while fitting, is reaaally uninspired and average. Okay, maybe theres a track or two that are actually a bit surprising, but that’s really it. Are ya proud of me? I don't dislike TWO things from SHY now. Go me!...

Oh, back to the dumpster, are we? Let's see... so, what about the one-dimensional characters? We’ve already gone over Teru as a basic bitch in the ‘I hadn’t gone outside before this anime started’ world. The author just slapped the mundane introvert personality onto her, and there ya have it, that’s Japan’s superhero. The other superheroes surrounding her also have stereotypical and sometimes discriminatory personality traits too, like Pepesha, the superhero representing Russia, who we see as drunk more often than necessary. There’s also the useless, burdensome plot device of the anime, Koishikawa Iko, who is around more than half the time as nothing more than a superfan stalker of Teru, even after Teru failed to save her from getting injured from a disaster. As for the supervillains, they’re akin to cardboard in terms of writing. They exist for the sole reason of making this anime work, and nothing more. There is no depth to them; nothing telling us who they really are, save for a single backstory that’s so generic it hurts, and why they’re so goddamn mentally sick, but this anime just has to be some pretentious pile of garbage or else the author wouldn’t survive. It’s clear from the moment they’re introduced into the anime that they were attempted to be given a deeper, more extensive meaning, but it just doesn’t work when the characters don’t have any meaning in the first place.

That was a bunch to cover, but that was my view on this season's SHY to the best my tired brain can type out. To shorten my statements, SHY is a pretentious work about superheroes fighting against evil that smacks nothing but drivel into your face by its sad attempts at giving itself meaning with backstories, wacky, over-the-top visual effects that when watching are like being sick on a rollercoaster, and its paper-thin, depthless characters. The only good stuff you’ll experience watching this is the pretty decent animation handling that was given at least some care, the average at best artstyle, and the nice but flawed music. If you’re wanting to watch something with meaning and sense in what it’s trying to achieve, SHY isn’t that. If you’re looking for dumb, sometimes agitating stuff to turn your brain off to and pay almost no mind to, SHY might be up your alley.

You’re probably going to grow dumber if you try to actually pay attention to this thing anyway. Don’t end up like me.

Thank you for reading my review.
Reviewer’s Rating: 3
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login