Reviews

Aug 8, 2022
I rewatched the entirety of the original Prince of Tennis, and also watched this entire OVA before coming to a conclusion: I don't like this show. It took over a hundred episodes, but yes, the only reason why I liked Prince of Tennis is due to nostalgia. I clearly was only able to rematch the orginal anime out of pure nostalgia, as watching the old episodes is like opening up an ancient crypt, the animation and story extremely outdated.
I give credit when credit is due: Most of Seigaku's cast of characters are well made, and they certainly have unique personalities. Each player has their strengths and weaknesses, their own quirks and special moves. Whatever it is about them, there's a lot of charm even over a decade later. The problem is actually the protagonist: Echizen.
He does not lose. I like OP protagonists when it's a gag manga, like One Punch Man, but honestly, it's so boring watching Echizen play. Every time I see Echizen losing, I think "well, the author is going to make Echizen overcome the obstacle or create a new move on the spot." There's no tension. Echizen. Will. Win. Every. Official. Game. He has no weaknesses. He's a freshman beating the best senior players in tennis. He will counter every technique, given time, and will always turn the tides. It's impossible for him to lose a game because he's got plot armor. The author makes sure he's untouchable at all times.
Echizen's personality is pretty fun. He's arrogant, kind of cold, but also can be amiable, and cherishes his teammates. However, that's only if his personality is paired with appropriate skill level. I really don't care that Echizen is a genius. He's the protagonist. He should be OP to an extent. However, that DOES NOT MEAN UNTOUCHABLE. It's poor writing. With losses, Echizen would be a more believable and loveable character. With a legendary win streak, he's kind of just a Gary Sue.
Whenever I see Echizen play, I root for him to lose. I want him to lose. I don't want him to win. Especially when he plays against characters that have been characterized and have their own ambitions. They're so much more human than Echizen ever can be.
Atobe's match against Echizen just sealed the deal. I'm done.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login