Reviews

Apr 10, 2019
[ ----- Short ----- ]
Tank Tankuro is historically important as a 1930s pre-war "manga", an early pioneer of story-driven manga, and an inspiration for Astro Boy and Doraemon, but the medium has come a long, long way since then. Pick this up for historical interest and the insightful essays bundled with the English print version, because the comic itself has little entertainment value.

[ ----- A bit longer ----- ]
Tank Tankuro is a "superhero" of sorts, but is basically just a weird guy in a ball who fights weird enemies... like a sumo wrestler in a tree and a big monk with a bell. Tankuro initially goes around fighting a bunch of different characters, but eventually the stories coalesce into one long, war-themed imperialist plot with a talking monkey.

Tank Tankuro feels a lot like its inspiration, older Sunday comics from the West. Each story is squished and condensed into very few panels/pages, with little room to tell a complete story. At the same time, it tries to pull off more action-y scenes typical to manga, with much less dialogue than Western Sunday comics. But combining these two makes a total disaster: there aren't enough panels to fully describe a manga-like action sequence, and there's not enough dialogue to make it interesting. Ultimately it comes off as... boring.

This series was directed specifically at children in 1930s Japan, so it's a bit unfair for a Western adult in 2019 to be dumping all over it. But from the choppy story to the un-endearing main character, Tank Tankuro is a series that doesn't even hold up to its Western counterparts at the time (Popeye and Little Nemo, for example), much less modern-day manga. Pass on this one.
Reviewer’s Rating: 3
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login