I just finished my 4th time watching this anime, and it's still absolutely incredible. The story shouldn't work. A fighting anime about food. But it does, and your blood will get pumping every single time. The characters are awesome. The humor is spot on, even translated, which is rare. The sexy-bits are sexy. And if I knew how I would fund this to be ongoing. It's absolutely phenomenal.
Story - The plot, while very battlemanga standard, is perfectly executed. The premise being food removes the immersion breaking "this character survived super crazy stuff" that most series have. The premise plays to it's strength to the point where even my 4th time watching the anime and my 8th time in the manga I'm still excited to see the story develop.
Art - The art is great. Smooth, creative, and the changes in art between regular time, battle mode, post-foodgasm, and during stress times make the story so much more intense. Everything about it plays a part and nothing is wasted. Gorgeous.
Sound - Incredible. The sound of food sizzling, eggs cracking, all of it is spot on. The music that ramps up during high intensity battle segments is immersive as anything ever has been.
Characters - I love the characters. All of them. Even the characters I usually detest (the whiny ones with no self confidence) such as Tadoroko I still love, because they have so much development. There is a MASSIVE cast to this anime, and yet it never feels overwhelming, everyone has their place and plays their part. And Soma/Erina's relationship alone could sell this to most people.
Enjoyment - Obviously, I loved this. This is definitely in my top 3 of all time now. I just can't stop loving it. Everyone should watch this. Binge watch it. Right now. Stop reading this. Go watch it. NOW.