Reviews

Jul 13, 2015
Mixed Feelings
Lupin III: Princess of the Breeze - Hidden City in the Sky is like a cake that has beautiful icing but tastes bland. The plot summary and promo art raised my hopes pretty high, but this ended up being one of my least favourite Lupin TV specials. It tries too hard to be epic and touching and ends up accomplishing none of what it's attempting to do. There are individual scenes that are funny or well done, but there is rarely any natural flow between the events.

The premise is that Lupin and Jigen take an ugly baby along as they go on a new treasure hunting adventure. Well, there's also a European nation that went through a coup d'état, a rebel group consisting of people still loyal to the old royal family, a legendary treasure and an evil businessman pulling the strings, but none of that was particularly interesting or well-developed. Lupin, Jigen & ugly baby really were the best part.

As I said before, the movie's main problem is that it tries too hard. There are entirely too many characters in it, and most of them barely get anything more to them than a catch phrase that they repeat in a desperate attempt to come off as memorable during their short screen time. This is particularly obvious in the evil enforcer who leads the villain's men. There's also a completely unnecessary doctor character who really stands out as overly hammy and a princess character who does nothing. Now, the Lupin franchise rarely has new characters who are particularly memorable or interesting, but that's never a problem if the main cast gets to shine. More about that later.

With all the characters and the various plot points, there's enough material in this movie to fill a normal anime series. As a result, the movie just moves from one point to another without taking the time to develop anything properly. There was no time to get attached to the new characters, so when their done-by-the-book emotional scene came along, I didn't feel anything, except embarrassment that everything was so predictable. Perfect examples of this are when two characters sacrifice their lives to protect the others and when one of the villains has a break-down towards the end. The movie makes you watch a tired cliché after another and you can always tell what they're trying to make you feel, but it just doesn't come together.

The most cringe-worthy part for me was when the movie used the opening song from the Castle of Cagliostro as background music. That did nothing except highlight how Princess of the Breeze can't even hope to reach that level of quality.

With so many new characters, the only members of the Lupin gang who get to do anything are Lupin and Jigen. As usual, Goemon is written out of the plot for almost the entire duration of the movie, only to show up when there's a fight. However, the reason he leaves (twice!) is actually really charming and funny, so this time I give it a pass. Fujiko does disappointingly little (aside from positioning herself so that we get a good shot of her butt or boobs) as does Zenigata, even though he actually gets quite a lot of scenes.

The animation and backgrounds are mostly great and the characters look fine, even if they sometimes made me feel like they didn't belong in a Lupin title. I liked the detail put into the rebel group's clothing, which I think was supposed to be traditional to their country. The only visual part that bothered me was the car chase that was done with CGI because it stood out so much next to the 2D animation.

With all that said, the movie isn't total trash. There's enough to keep you interested, especially if you like stories about fallen royalty and their hidden treasures. It's mostly beautiful to look at and the beginning is quite enjoyable, about up to the part when the rebel hideout gets attacked. And as I said earlier, Lupin and Jigen interacting with the baby is quite fun. Seeing the baby pull Jigen's beard made the movie worth watching for me.

In short, I feel that this would have been better if it had been a series and if it had been an entirely original title without any connection to Lupin III. As it is, the Lupin characters don't get to spend enough time in the spotlight and it feels too much like they're supporting characters in somebody else's story. This isn't the only Lupin movie to have that problem, but that doesn't make me any more forgiving.

PS: I lied about the most cringe-worthy part. That was when the characters find out where the mysterious gem is hidden.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login