Reviews

Jul 11, 2009
Preliminary (25/40 chp)
Hehe,here comes my review and I'm second as I see.

Story 9/10
Very creative I have to say,very.Especially compared to other manga who usually take place in high school and such.This is a romantic anime indeed but I like how it starts how things progress and how the characters meet with each other.I'm also a big fan of manga/anime that have to do with history and such(ex.mthology) but also combines romance.The idea of a girl being sucked inside a book is pretty damn good,and I like the two worlds and the fact that she has to return to both.Makes things complicated like they already weren't.It also combines drama to the point where it's not just there all the fake cries,but you actually live the drama too and the agony.But I believe that's the mangaka's best ability,to make the viewer feel the story.

Art 9/10
ALthough a bit old fashioned and reminds me of 90s,I am pretty pleased.Being a fangirl I find the guys pretty handsome,like Uruki(hoho,sorry seems like my inner fangirl took over).Surroundings are pretty good as well.What really bothers is that,having read most of the mangaka's other mangas as well,I felt like the heroine is just the same based on appearance.That's the feeling I got,but I doubt you will if you haven't read the other manga by her.

Character 10/10
Nothing wrong to point out here.I'm pretty satisfied with the characters.They're pretty realistic such as their motives and the reasons they act that way are believable.Also the characters make mistakes too,sometimes even show a side we haven't seen of them but of course you come to understand why they did that.This is something I could really praise this manga for.

Enjoyment 9/10
To have given such a high rating means I definetely enjoyed it the only problem is the scanalations and translations that are slow.Why I didn't given this a 10,cause despite how good a manga/anime is or how bad it is if you start analyzing it,you can just have the time of your life and not be that much of a masterpiece or even if it is you just might not have been in the mood and didn't enjoy it as much.So yeah,just a bit more and I'd have given it a ten.I think it lacks good battles.I have high expectations when it comes to battles so this is case me.

Overall 9/10
I'd highly recommend this to anyone fan of adventure,romantic,drama.I think it's a pretty good manga and you wouldn't feel sorry for the time you spent reading it.Of course it depends on tastes but anyway.Pretty sad though that I haven't encountered any fans of it so far.
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login