Kamisama Hajimemashita, Cheonnyeon Kumiho Recommendations
Similar main characters, romance, concept and plot.
Both main males are foxes with similar powers and a really bad temper. (Similar personality in genral actually) They both refuse to have a romantic relationship with a human girl. Both males also have a dark past, which led them to having to protect humans for several hundred years.
The main females are also similar in several ways. They both rely on the male's protection even though they really want to be able to protect themselves.
Both stories have similar plot, girl lives in a shrine and goes to school while the male is going to protect her from supernatural spirits
They have the same kind of plot of a fox guy forced to protect a priestess girl against his will. Then they have to work together to solve obstacle that occurs. And thru out their hardship, they soon fall in love. Typical shojo but really good, you should give them a try.