Higurashi no Naku Koro ni, Kamisama Dolls Recommendations
Both centre around the unique features of a small, remote village and the events that have transpired there. Kamisama Dolls is less severe about it, since the majority of the series takes place in a more urban setting and deals with the repercussions, whereas Higurashi definitely tends toward the worst case scenario -- but as each piece of the backstory for Kamisama Dolls is revealed, it becomes increasing obvious that it's not exactly sunshine and lollipops either.
Oyashiro! : O
There is a shrine, a village, a boy included in massive murders made my insane murderer... Also we have cute girls.
Involves a series of killing. These supernatural anime is centered around a mysterious village with something dark inside it. Both of the main protagonists try to escape each of their ties with the town, however, it'll never be easy for them to do so.
Sounds dumb, but hearing Oyashiro reminds me of Higurashi.
Yup, old town with crazy people. But I guess Higurashi is more mind-bending still.