Kimi ni Todoke, Bokura wa Minna Kawai-sou Recommendations
•Both have calm School Life settings
•Both have a shy female MC
•Both protagonists are somewhat innocent to the core that want to love for the first time
•Both Romance/School Life/Drama with a sprinkle of Comedy
-Both main girl characters are shy and somewhat "loners"
-Both main guy characters try to get closer to the girl characters
-Both have unique art styles
-Both have honest, light-hearted, slowly paced love stories
A sweet love story between two wholesome characters both including very introvert girls who are misunderstood in their expression of how they feel. Both girls were outcasts early in their schooling for coming across as scary/mean.
They both have the same type of innocent romance. The female leads are both incredibly adorable. I highly recommend giving this a shot.