Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo (TV), Seishun Buta Yarou wa Bunny Girl Senpai no Yume wo Minai Recommendations
I initially went into both of these shows thinking they would be generic high school harems with some supernatural shenanigans thrown in, but ended up being surprised by how well these shows executed their premises with engaging interactions and solid characterizations through supernatural phenomena. While Yamada-kun does have the harem tag, it's really as much of a harem as Bunny Girl Senpai is with the protagonists only being interested in the female leads, who are quick to see through any misunderstandings which could potentially bog down the plot.
The Themes, Plot, And World Line Is Similar As A Male Character Is The One Who Solves The Problems (Which Are Somewhat Supernatural Phenomenon) Faced By The Female Characters And Most Of Them Later Fall For Him.
Both series' characters experience mysterious supernatural phenomena in a high school setting. Both male protagonists are at first loners, but they grow to support their friends and peers as the shows unravel the explanation behind their puzzling conditions.
Both series' characters experience mysterious supernatural phenomena in a high school setting
They both share similar feels and concepts of the MC fighting to resolve a problem someone with an special ability has created. Besides, both series have the same tone.
-different female characters have different insecurities that effect the main characters life similarly to Yamada-Kun
-Theres just a lot of similarities give this one a watch
Both are focused on supernatural things happening in school. They also have a great romance. MC are different, but the story is so enjoyable in both.
Both are definitely amazing.
Both have supernatural elements, decent sized cast of interesting characters, protagonists who help out many of those various characters with their problems (reluctantly at times) and in both the protagonist deals with a lot of girls however not all of them fall for him nor does he try to get with all of them (aka not a harem, even though in most anime it would be).