Hataraku Maou-sama!, Noragami Aragoto Recommendations
Both anime contains good mixture between action and humour! The main characters are not from this world plus they manage to get humans tangled in their mess. Both anime have male protagonist who delivers in the action and humour but gets shafted by the female characters. Definitely similar level of enjoyment.
The MC's are both careless teenage boys who are unaffected by what is going on around them. Though they also show great empathic ability especially regarding their friends. They are generally laid back and funny.