Shin Shirayuki-hime Densetsu Prétear, Fruits Basket Recommendations
They both start out with simple girls. They both are then surrounded by boys who help them through troubles or special powers with secrets.
Each ha their own fantasy/magical element to them, and each has the central character as a kind-hearted girl. They have a healthy combination of laugh out loud humor and teary eyed drama. Both animes also bring a reverse-harem collection of character to support the central female.