The main reason I chose to make this system is to try and streamline the way I score and how people view my scores. The arbitrary system of 1-10 doesn't really help anyone in telling why they chose such a score and seems to cause a disconnect when trying to discuss what an appropriate score for a show is. This system is a work in progress and I would be very grateful to hear your opinion on how to improve/change this system.
9-enjoyed by anyone
8-7 depends on personal likes and genre
0-6 don't even bother
7 and 8 are strictly based on the general premise of the genre and show so, for example, konosuba would be an 8 as its great in the genre of humor but lacks in other parts besides its main focus and something like desert punk would get a 7 from me because its a show that misses the mark for what its trying to aim for because as a comedy its repetitive boring etc it doesn't get as far as other shows could in its respective genre. A 9 is for a show that does pretty much everything right from basic film sense soundtrack, animation, narrative etc. It has a big enough variety to be enjoyed by pretty much everyone and has high production quality, such examples are hunter x hunter and FMA. I'll always give a show a 9 for its own merits. A 10 is strictly awarded to a show that I personally think is fantastic and doesn't always mean it's going to be a 10 for everyone else. I like to leave room for some scoring on personal enjoyment so a show that is 9 and gets a 10 from me gets an extra 1 point from said enjoyment. So do take my 10's with a grain of salt.
"at its core, literature is the exploration of the human condition; the rest is furniture" - George RR Martin
"In Order To Create, One Must First Destroy" - Lelouch
"I much prefer the sharpest criticism of a single intelligent man to the thoughtless approval of the masses." - Johannes Kepler
"I don't think people who only know one 'correct' answer can get themselves to reach even greater heights." - Soma
"Just as my arms can never be soft and warm like yours are" - Violet Evergarden
"Everything that lives is designed to end" - 2B
"Go beyond what you might be today and become what you could be tomorrow"
"There are no regrets. If one could be proud of one's life, one should not wish for another chance" - Artoria Pendragon
Look I really love anime ALOT, so uhh be free to message me whenever if you would like to discuss any in detail