10 - A great one and a favorite that most likely speaks to me on a personal level.
9 - Great and a favorite, but it has a few issues or maybe it doesn't resonate that strongly with me.
8 - Just a good one with lovable stuff, although not all that appealing to me personally.
7 - Decent and sometimes interesting, but either too flawed, bland, simple, not really to my tastes, etc., although it is likeable.
6 - It has many or glaring issues or is uninteresting, but it is still enjoyable enough.
5 - Either it has good qualities but is too boring and unappealing to me, or it is just too bland or flawed to be enjoyable.
4 - Unenjoyable and strongly flawed, even though I might see one or two of its charmes.
3 - Boring and bad, with maybe only one likeable aspect.
2 - Extremely poorly executed, and failing to be entertaining in every way.
1 - Offensively awful and severely lacking effort, making me wonder why someone thought it was a good idea to make this.