I'm me and your you. we are different people so I may not enjoy your favourite anime and you may not enjoy my favourite so i least expect the delicacy that you respect my opinion as i respect yours. I'm not an elitist nor a casual watcher but I have my own reasons for liking/not liking an anime, no matter how great or bad a particular anime is . You can see that if you check my list.
There are no such things as bad stories, just badly told ones.