I'm what the kids call a "filthy casual"
The Rating Scale (since a 7 is apparently a 0 on this website)
10 - An almost perfect balance of story, art, and characters. Of course, nothing is perfect, but it's so good that I can safely overlook any flaws.
9 - Very impressive, but still has a few nagging flaws that prevent it from achieving a perfect score.
8 - Starts good and gets even better, to the point that it sets itself apart from the rest. Still, not what I would call a masterpiece.
7 - Enjoyable throughout. Has some considerable flaws to be criticized but otherwise pretty good.
6 - Above average. Shows potential to become something good but unfortunately gets bogged down by blandness. Still enjoyable.
5 - Average. Doesn't leave a lasting impression, but still enjoyable in its own way.
4 - Below average. Not offensively bad, but unfortunately the cons outweigh the pros. Leaves me wanting more than anything else.
3 - Mostly bad. Has a decent concept or characters that suffer from poor execution. Makes me ask myself "why the fuck did I watch this?"
2 - All around terrible, but has a few sporadic good things happen in it that save it from the pit.
1 - No redeeming qualities whatsoever, or does something so atrocious that it forces me to overlook anything it did right
* Ratings are mostly set in stone but might be subject to change
* Subjectivity does play a part in the ratings I give. I'm not gonna sit here and pretend I'm some hardass anime critic, especially when there are much better and more respectable things I could pretend to be.
Profile picture credit:
https://twitter.com/brnwen/status/966738119025446912
Join the official r/FullmetalAlchemist Discord!:
https://discord.gg/fQxgrEK
All Comments (3) Comments