I've been watching anime on and off for years now, and have turned to writing reviews here and personally in my free time. I absolutely love the medium, and love to think/talk/write about it as well. I have many opinions on my list if you are interested, and am always down to chat!
In terms of how I rate, I use to have a real complicated system which I've since moved on from. The truth is I deeply think about these shows, but to make this simple:
If I finished the show = good
If I dropped it = bad.
Yeah, even If I rated it like a 1, 2, or 3. At the very least I finished them. The ones I couldn't I want to think are the "bad" shows.
If or if not it wasn't clear from my pfp, I'm a huge fan of the Fire Emblem series. My favorites are the Jugdral games (4+5), Three Houses, and FE6. I've played almost every game in the series, however and I love them all and strongly recommend anyone to play the series, especially the games I listed as my favorites. I'm interested in one day writing about them just like I do occasionally for anime.