I score anime solely on the enjoyment I get. Animes I have finished will recieve a grade from 1-10, animes I have dropped will receive a maximum score of 5 I re-adjust (and thus rewatch shows) every now and then to be able to have a clear ranking system based on enjoyment, ergo higher graded shows were more 'fun' to me.
I'm personally interested in human psychology thus slice of life/drama/sci-fi are the genres I mostly visit, but i'm open for other genres.
I typically start every season with sequels, up to 2-3 per genre of seasonals (total of max 10) and fill it up with my plan to watch list shows (up to 3 at a time).
My on hold list is sequels that are out but i've been holding of to watch and for movies i havent gotten around to.
10 - Best anime I have seen
9 - Very good, I consider these animes as my favourites
8 - Great, enjoyed every minute
7 - Good
6 - Satisfactory
5 - Did not like this
4 - Bad
3 - Very bad
2 - Absolutely disgusting
1 - Reserved for when I see anything worse than Pupa