I started watching anime when one of my best friends told me about Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso (Your Lie in April). Later, I continued watching similar anime series, those of the likes of Clannad and Angel Beats. After getting all my buckets full of tears, I decided to watch anime that are considered "popular". After watching Death Note, Code Geass and Steins; Gate, I then started watching anime for the "PLOT" and because of that, I now can watch "EVERYTHING" in anime. I mostly watch the Dubbed ver. but if the anime doesn't have a dub, then I just watch the sub, just like Kuroko No Basket and To LOVE-Ru.
What I do to watch "BAD anime" is just... yolo it and watch it on till the end... like High School DxD, Fate/stay night Unlimited Blade Works and Masou Gakuen HxH. To be honest, I love bad anime, cause they're there fun to just make fun of, if you understand what I said there.
Anyways. I hope you relate on myanime score and stuff! PM or whatever if you have any questions!