So, this is My rating system, as in it is my own, subjective, system and I am not claiming that the others aren't right. I rate mostly everything in an anime/manga - art, animation, sounds, music, story, script, plot, characters, voice acting etc.
Thus, here it is. It is just a general one because there are really some things that weigh more than others e.g. story over art, so sometimes one goes out of their way in order to give final mark.
(10) Masterpiece - Has little flaws to be stated. Overall, the art/animations/sounding/story/characters are greatly developed/used. (9) Great - Has some gaps in the development of the plot/characters/art/animations but nevertheless it deserves to be seen and I would
reccommend it. (8) Very Good - The overall presentation is sloppy e.g. is jumping fast from one moment to another, leaving some gaps in the development of the
story and key moments but has good animation/art/characters etc. that I give credit to. (7) Good - Technically and plot-wise the product is literally just good. In other words, it answers to the finances/work given into it. (6) Fine - I would still watch/read it but the plot is not developed nicely enough to take me in or there are some gaps in the art/animations that
don't showcase the final product in its best light. (5) Average - The product is literally an average work. I would still watch it and may like it thus giving it a higher mark if some aspects are
better covered than others e.g. animation over story etc. (4) Bad - The product is actaully bad as in overall the sounding/animations/art/story combined are not making the experience appealing /or/ I would
give this to an anime/manga if it fully strays from what I have expected of it but nevertheless I give credit to the work done. (3) Very Bad; (2) Horrible; (1) Appalling - I doubt I would give any of these marks to a product (manga/anime) because I rate the style/art/plot/story/
characters/sound/animations/presentation and so on. This case might happen if some of the afore mentioned aspects are badly used/outrageous etc. But I remind that I doubt these marks would come in use to me.[/b]