Self-proclaimed isekai guru, edgelord appreciator. But I do like my shows good.
My 1 to 10 scoring:
I rate shows based on a balance of enjoyment and appreciation, weighed towards enjoyment. Scores are subject to change based on retrospect and re-watching, it's all a constant work in progress.
Specials and non-original OVAs generally won't get scored as long as they're just cheap shorts or more of the original show, side stories or the like. If I consider them significant enough or if they're straight up sequels they will get scored normally though. This is mostly for my own convenience for when sorting my list by score, I want to keep it uncluttered.
Don't take my scores of airing, on-hold or dropped shows too seriously. They are there purely to communicate how much I have enjoyed the show as far as I have watched it. They're not there to review the show as a whole. General rule of thumb is that only anime with 3+ episodes watched or manga with 10+ chapters read get scored. This is also for sorting purposes.
(!)Score explanations and examples(!)
10: Masterpiece. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Extremely resonant, visually compelling, either excelling in intrigue or at making your heart pound and welling up your emotions.
●
9: Great. Gunbuster
All the same qualities as a 10 except to a lesser degree.
●
8: Very good. Hidamari Sketch
The hardest score to explain. None of them would I consider a favorite, but all of them I would love to rewatch. I could see many of these going up a score or two on rewatches down the line.
●
7: Good. Toaru Majutsu no Index III
Enjoyable the entire way through or has enough good to outweigh weaker or outright detrimental aspects of the show.
●
6: Enjoyable. Isekai Maou
Undeniably enjoyable even if even if basic and uninteresting at a glance, or packaged with major problems that the show can't outweigh with the good aspects. If I had a net positive experience with a show, this is the lowest score I will give.
●
5: Average. Aho Girl
Average or throwaway, watchable. Probably struggled to finish. Mostly shows from my teens.
●
4: Bad. Rokka no Yuusha
Too mediocre or disappointing to give even a neutral score.
●
3: Irritating. Isekai Quartet
Transparently incompetent, lazy or cynical.
●
2: Garbage. Sword Art Online: Alicization - War of Underworld
Hideously badly executed or particularly laughable.
●
1: Horrendous. Berserk 2016
Emotionally resonant in the completely wrong way. Shitty, cynical and ill conceived adaptations of my favorite series.
About my dropped list; if a show is on there, it doesn't mean I will never try watching it again. I just don't want to have a hundred shows on my On-Hold list that I may never get around to, and I value my time too much to finish every seasonal I give a shot.
3x3 todo
Music
Favorites
Under 7 favorites
Favorite anime OST
Manga favorites
Best girls
Best guys
anime staff separated in music, direction and voice acting
All Comments (0) Comments