Watching anime since 2005 so at this point it's pretty much established what i like or not.
My ratings do change if a show is getting better or worse.
My Ratings goes:
[1-3= I hate it and won't watch or recommend something like that]
[4= Most anime in this rating were mid af, i enjoyed it watching but it went down hill from there pretty fast]
[5-6= I enjoyed it but it won't stay with me for long or those are old titles, so i watched it
out of obligation in my teenage years or it got nostalgic connection with me]
[7= Pretty much i enjoyed this anime, might watch it again or might recommend it]
[8-9= I am Hoe/Trash for this anime, very high rewatch value and will also fight for it, highly recommended by me]
[10= This rating is rare but if you see then there must be a reason for it as i enjoyed it the most and
have a deep connection with it]
I like almost every anime or manga which gets me interested or stays with me for a long time after i finish it, i will hate an anime only when it degrades the source material (Ex: Berserk,Promised Neverland) or is an absolute shit from the beginning but i do give them a try.
I absolutely hate the elitist who are shitting on every anime which they can't enjoy and i also hate trolls who shit on anime just for fun and lastly but not the least i hate "EDGY" people the most who watched like 2500 titles but their mean rating is 2.35 to 4.35, i mean why the fuck are you watching anime at this point if you hate everything that's coming out. Motherfucker you are just edgy and it comes out too lame.
Just drop it and move on.
Being an ultimate douche who is "oH tHiS dOesn'T sUiTs mY rEfiNeD tAstE" won't get you anywhere.
MAL is a clusterfuck of a database tbh, most people here are mostly shitting on anime, reviews are not that of a worth if you enjoy something which is trash but that's the thing if you enjoy something you won't care about reviews. And Everyone is allowed to have their trash taste.
But not for ELITIST,TROLLS or EDGY FUCKS.
P.S watching or reading some unknown manga or anime won't make you special so stop acting like you are special, Also if you read Berserk, Vagabond, Monster or One piece or watched any of these titles, then you are NOT superior than the rest or have refined taste it's just you like popular titles. Because they are THAT good.