Back to Lighto98's Profile Lighto98's Profile

... Sigh. "Would you like a one way ticket to lack-of-fulfilment-ville? How about a trip down regret lane? Some sadness sherbet to whet your pallet??"

"Well, I'd prefer to just watch School Days."

"*Depression Dan whispers to his colleagues before looking frightfully at me* Woah kid, that's way out of our league. Good luck."

I could have taken that as a sign that this anime was not going to end happily. That, the "tragedy" tag on certain sites, and the general lack of friends willing (or able) to talk about their experience with this show could have made me decide that perhaps it wasn't worth watching. But, ... curiosity (and naivety?) getting the best of me, I decided to give it a try.

I will begin by saying that this is not a bad anime quality-wise. No, to a robot with no emotions or sense of impending disaster, this could have possibly scored higher.

Given the content, 7 was the highest I could muster.

Our story begins much as MAL describes it. Makoto is an initially-likable, though highly unmanly specimen just looking for a date. He has a love interest and someone who is interested in him (both seem normal enough), and initially it's a triangle. Makoto does his best and has a shining performance. One would be apt to conclude that for the first few eps, it's a fluffy and comedic world!

Then the world falls apart.

The characters are done well, but I had so little sympathy for the "protagonist" by the end that I really found myself just... Unhappy at him. It is revealed that there are a few psychological issues present in these "normal" young adults: OCD, attachment issues, inability to let go of the past, addictions, irresponsibility and ignorance/ apathy/ unawareness on a wonton scale. It all adds up to success :p

My biggest issue with the characters is that while there is progression, it isn't in the way that I am used to (IE the opposite of positive). That said, I did not dock characters for this. In addition, there could have been more development given to the characters (Flesh-out explanations of their behaviour?)

The music is decent, but after watching the EDs change, I began to feel that something was afoot in the story. I was correct.

The art is also good.

Overall, the anime was good in terms of its plot and I felt the feelings of tension, upsetness, etc.; the art and music were good; and the characters did have some development. However, the tangled and depressing mess at the end just made me feel... Depressed. Depressed and hopeless. The light I saw at the end of the tunnel was extinguished in a single movement. Enjoyment suffers because of this.

But don't let me dissuade anyone else from taking the plunge: There is some psychology here, and it might prove to be an interesting study of how to induce a feeling of hopeless despair in someone :p

In reality, it is an alternate take on the tragedies I have seen: the tragedy is entirely preventable and in the hands of the humans who had their parts in it.

So much of our suffering is caused by ourselves. We have the capability to become aware of our effects on others and build a better world!

If you are looking for an alternative tragedy experience, School Days is worth your time.

"You eventually awaken from a dream, but... memories sparkle forever..."
'*As the scene opens there is a soft voice* "I love you" what wondrous words. The moment I say them, the world changes. Magical words... I'm going to say them... to you. *cue shot of cute girl*'

"Such a lovely if straightforward way to begin a romance/ comedy anime!" one may be tempted to think. And in a way that person (We will call him Bob) would be correct. School Rumble has these things. There are elements of comedy that will have Bob nearly crying from laughter and harem/romance elements that will have Bob smiling and ... possibly blushing at the mishaps our characters make as multiple relationships (real and pseudo) are explored.

But if Bob had expectations of a genuine Love Hina clone, Bob will be surprised (And most likely pleasantly) to discover that these elements are only the beginning.

School Rumble is a show which is less than simple to characterize. In addition to the humour and relationships standard to the listed genres there is action, fighting, 3D animations, drama, and much more. And for the most part, it is done in a logical and realistic manner with a +2 continuity bonus.

One might find themselves captivated by this anime as it is so... Generally enjoyable. One may indeed find themselves preparing the better part of entire days to watch all of the episodes consecutively (The author concedes that he was one of these people).

On this note, what follows is a short synopsis and review.

Tenma Tsukamoto is an energetic second year high school student "and just as all young girls," has fallen in love. The object of her affection is one Oji Karasamu, who is a bit unusual. On the other side of the fence is Kenji Harima, one of the rough-exterior, soft-hearted "delinquents" of the high school. Unbeknownst to Tsukamoto, Harima is intensely in love with her (Claiming that she is the reason he is still in school) and what follows is an entertaining, humorous, and charming experience that combines a myriad of supporting characters with a plot that provides surprises and laughs in many interesting ways.

Story
There is a weakness that is evident in many anime placed in similar categories: No real, overarching issue or plot device other than finding love and reconciling the multiple relationships, especially concerning the main protagonists. In addition although it deals with relationships, there are fewer (really) gooey romancey portions of the story than a romance-lover may enjoy.

That said the story as a whole is well done, combining multiple characters with multiple plotlines into a large intertwining story that is entertaining right to the end of every episode. The pacing is done realistically, with the small portions of filler and fan service material generally placed in synergy with the main story material. There is a consistent feeling that there is little seriousness; this anime likes to make fun of anime clichés, itself, and culture: In one episode a seaman washes overboard during a storm and rather than helping one crewman yells, "[he] can't swim!" after a few seconds one replies, "Why is he working on a boat!?". And while it can be argued that there are not a large number of passionate love scenes, this does not detract from the story which is upbeat and focussed more so on the general experience of being in love and "In a dream season of adolescence" than on any one situation. The ending... Well, that has to be experienced.

Presentation:
The animation for some of the scenes was less than amazing, and there was an occasional replaying of a song.

However the art was well implemented, in many cases switching between and combining chibi art, standard 2D fare, a hand-drawn look, and 3D animation for some scenes. The still pictures of the girls and the environments were expectedly top-notch. Above par for an anime aired in 2004 (my gripes about some of the animation would likely go away if I had seen it in 1080). The intelligent usage of transitions and timing for the scenes helped to increase the enjoyability by cutting and panning at just the right time. Looking at the characters from the proper perspective gave extra immersion to situations. Despite some minor repetition the music was actually quite impressive, managing to add to the impact of events; at most points, it was used flawlessly.

Characters:
School Rumble's characters shine radiantly. The characters are diverse and dynamic; hardly relegated to the standard archetypes long-time watchers of anime would be used to. These archetypes are apparent when the characters are introduced, but soon give way to their inner workings as they struggle and triumph, fall and regain composure, and are exposed to a variety of different experiences. Bob might be shocked to learn that indeed Harley-riding, school skipping, fighting for fun Harima (one of the most badass and well placed male characters in a romance anime ever, in my opinion) can be both the most hardcore delinquent and a big softy at the same time. This is a massive difference from the far too common highly unmanly male protagonists that aren't particularly skilled or pronounced (the author might reference a certain Keitaro in this instance). School Rumble peels back the psychological onion of many of the characters through direct action and indirect characterization, providing a gentle yet lively pace of discovery that is very interesting. Characters are often quite logical while still being comical.

In conclusion, School Rumble is an experience that can be summed up (and I imagine Bob would agree) as an immersive, enjoyable experience with few downsides. A good story, great presentation and fantastic characters combine to provide a memorable experience. One will find enough light-hearted enjoyment to pass time laughing, and enough depth and characterization to actually provide a reason for one to care about and become psychologically involved with the story.

There is another season of this extraordinary experience. The author is excitedly planning, between work and school, the next few days that can be devoted to immersing himself in the next chapter. If you haven't had the pleasure of watching this one, the author (And Bob, the author is sure) recommends you do so as soon as can be managed.

ef- a tale of memories is a slice of art masquerading as an inspiring, emotionally-charged anime that asks us to fight for our dreams, take charge of opportunities, and to break free of the proverbial ``chains`` that bind us.

In this review I'm attempting to go for a somewhat more "minimalist" feel which will hopefully appeal to those who want straight, fast, hard-hitting investigative reviewing.

Quick synopsis:

"Do you have any memories you don't want to forget?"

ef- a tale of memories is an arresting story which follows our main characters as they each struggle with the discovery and procurement of their most treasured dreams. Depending on ... how one counts, there are no less than SIX (6) main characters (Alternatively, one or two of those can be argued as more minor for the count to be dropped to 4 or 5); their adventures are chronicled in the space of 12 highly-acclaimed episodes.

Breakdown of this anime:

Art: 5/5
+ Unconventional usage of perspective and colouration adds heaps to an extremely well-drawn set.
+ Lighting effects are used to great advantage here.
+ Particle effects and mesmerizing skies, water take the art from beautiful to extraordinary.
+ CG and drawn animations add to the depth of the art.

Story: 4.75/5
+ The story is impressive and includes a colourful cast of characters with all sorts of haunted pasts and character "flaws".
+ Well paced, with each episode opening and closing parts of the past or the present.
+ Any show that attempts to fit six interconnecting character arcs in a 12 ep series is laudable; this series manages to do this without any noticeable discomfort.
+ Underlying symbolism abounds, with references to connectedness and "breaking free" artfully executed throughout.
- The few minor charcters are not really explored, instead giving occasional cameos.

Sounds: 4.5/5
+ Soundtrack is well executed, being used at the right times for the majority of the show.
+Sound effects are realistic, from the clasping of a bag to the wind.
+ Japanese voice acting is right-on.
+ Euphoric Field by Tenmon and ELISA was a fantastic piece for the OP's. I prefer the Japanese version (OP2), but both versions really fit the anime.
+ Both OP's and all ED's are well made in general.
- Music in some instances was slightly overplayed.

In conclusion, ef- a tale of memories sets a new standard for any modern love-romance anime hoping to compete in a crowded market of mediocrity. Combining a revolutionary CG/ drawn/ SFX style with a heartwarming, emotional, and empowering story, ef manages to stand head and shoulders above competing love-romance titles.

I watched this in 720p, and if you can find this title on Blu-Ray I highly recommend it, as the incredible aesthetics are best viewed and can be fully appreciated in HD.

In mentioning that this series sets a new standard, I say so because I truly hope that other series producers can capture the beauty and style reflected in this title, innovate a bit, and port it to other stories.

"Put your wishes into the memories you do not want to forget..."

9.5/10

"Do you like this school? I really, really love it. But nothing can stay unchanged. Fun things... Happy things... They can't all possibly stay unchanged. Even so, can you keep on loving this place?"

How does one cope in a world that is always changing? And are we ever truly alone?

The above questions are foundational to the series of Clannad After Story, a story of love, loss, redemption, happiness, sadness, togetherness, and change.

I will start by commending Key, the brains behind this show. Like other works of theirs, (Notably Kanon, Air, and the first season of Clannad), it is beautifully written and incredibly aesthetically ... detailed, with well designed environments and a soundtrack that fits the context to a tee. Added to the compelling characters, this anime is in my somewhat biased opinion a masterpiece. I'll start with the story.

As a story by Key, I went into the anime with some expectations. Not only was I not disappointed, I was sent from small fits of laughter to open sobs and bawling more quickly than I would have liked (very manly, testosterone-charged sobs and bawling, of course).

The anime starts right near the end of the first season of Clannad and picks up quickly. Nearly all of those "minor" characters from the first season are given more time, their stories are displayed in a very accessible manner, and there is a feeling of very little "filler". Almost all of the characters have you caring about them (and feeling happy or sad for their situations,) by the time the story ends.

These stories play out against the backdrop of Nagisa and Tomoya's relationship, their trials and happy times, as Tomoya becomes a man of society. A distinct shift of the angle and scope of the anime is witnessed, as Tomoya moves into the "real world". One of my favorite parts of the story came from the implementation of Nagisa's parents, Akio and Sanae. I will discuss this implementation later.

During most of the story, I felt as if I was actually living the lives of the characters I was watching. Realistic scripting, well chosen voice actors (Mostly the same from the first season), and strong writing right from the beginning gave me the impression that this could actually be a real story, happening somewhere on the planet (with some minor exceptions that are related to the story).

The themes of change and family are expressed continuously, from the changing city to the powerful interconnectedness of family, friends, or larger communities. The OP and ED become more powerful as the story continues on, and the connections made to the first season are near perfect.

There is more than one climax to this story, and it is barely short of amazing how there can be so much emotion packed into 24 episodes (though the 24 of the first season play a role here).

The ending was very pretty, I especially liked the ending of the 24th "recap" episode (which I would consider a part of the After Story experience as it provides some final closure).

Overall, the story is so beautifully done that aside from one potentially confusing part near the end, the plot is watertight and expressed in a way that is easy to connect with. Next I will discuss the art and sound.

If the entire After Story anime consisted of just the OP and ED, I would have awarded it somewhere around an 8.5. The combination of theme song (Toki wo Kizamu Uta by Lia,) and stunning visuals sent shivers down my spine many of the times I watched it. Both the OP and ED gain more as the story goes on, as more subtle details are revealed in the plot.

I have always been a big fan of the Key visual style, but the visual style of this anime is very impressive. The characters as can be expected are very well detailed, but what is stunning about this anime is the amount of detail in the environments. Every building and nearly every person, near or far, important or not, is well detailed. Seeing the wood grain in a power pole when the pole is barely hanging in the scene. Or the swaying of each individual plant in a field during sunset, as the orangeish hue nearly matches that of a sunset in the real world. This and more all combines to produce a very appealing look and serves to immerse the viewer in a world that is not their own (though one might wish it were, for how pretty it is).

The soundtrack is impressive. Many of the songs come from the first season, but some less well used songs in the original get used more often in this season. The choice of where the soundtrack is implemented is pivotal, and this anime is very good at knowing when to emphasize the emotion or when to provide a contrast that might nudge the viewer, "Time still goes forward; life still goes on!"

Lastly, I will talk about what I believe is the most important portion of any story, and especially so for this one: the characters.

After Story provides an amazing level of character depth. None of the first season of Clannad is forgotten, and various past issues and memories are brought back.

The development of the "minor" characters plays a very important role in this anime. Though Tomoya is the main character, one gets the sense that there are no arbitrary characters in the anime at all. Everyone has a past, a story, and a place where they can fit into the extended family of Tomoya.

Tomoya is one of the most realistically portrayed anime characters I have seen in some time. Viewers will remember him as the slightly hot-headed but caring figure from the first season. Tomoya undergoes a remarkable transformation in this series, and the contrast (which is well-emphasized in After Story) is very well done. Finally, I want to take a quick second to recognize something I liked that Key did with this anime: the implementation of Nagisa's parents.

Though they had relatively brief appearances in the first season, Akio and Sanae play incredibly powerful roles in After Story. They are characterized as deeply caring parents that will do anything for the happiness of their family. They stand as a beacon of love and support for both Nagisa and Tomoya, and can be as funny as they are compassionate.Though not always on the front lines, viewers can expect any issues encountered by the characters to be thoughtfully and thoroughly dealt with by these two.

In conclusion, this anime is borderline phenomenal. In between moments of laughing and crying, there is a plethora of amazing characters, portrayed with the right music, detailed in beautiful environments, and built into a fantastic story that is very pretty, both in concept and implementation. I would heavily recommend this anime to anyone who is into Key stuff, who has seen Clannad, or just someone who wants to use a whole box of tissues from all of the happy/sad crying one is bound to do.

In response to the first quote of this (longer than I had expected) review in the words of Tomoya,

"Just find them; just find new fun and happy things. C'mon, let's get going."