i mean hey like the show however you want, anime is subjective, however when you take a beat by beat plot of another anime but do not any interesting about it, I found that frustrating. Like people would think witch academia is like HP however it started becoming it own thing. The maximum rating i can see the show people give it really a 7 max above that is stretching it. My problem is that the characters and robots look so cartoonish but takes itself so seriously if they really wanted to do this art style with character and robots they should have taken the Gurren Lagann approach. Its self-aware, but takes itself seriously enough, doesn't have the strongest writer, however, its so over the top it's perfectly fine and has amazing character designs. This show seems quite restrictive despite Trigger moto ( not actually but implied) is " original creative projects".
i would have given it a lower score however i stated its a frustrating seires as they is obviously a lot of care and effort put into the show with its directing, animation use of music .... however fails in basic components, i would have given it a 4/10 tbh however it not that poorly written to be that low and episode 6 seems to improve aspect of show alot and may fix this flawed series. Saying an anime is shit and not justifying it is bad, however, i did include key aspect on why it fails in alot of basic components and would be unfair of me reviewing this anime with the standards i gave in my example for great shows. This is a flawed series with alot of problems i would have given it a lower score but however MAL standards everything below 6 is trash, 6 means mediocre, 7 been okay/ good, 8 onwards been great, 9 fantastic
in reality, i would have given it a 5/10, however, when you take into account of how bad the ranking system is in my MAL i just made it 1 higher. You can watch the show and give your opinion if your opinion conflicts on mine however the people giving this 10/10 seems ridiculous.
I'd like to praise your review on death march show, it was a nice little read. You see, i'm still trying to like the show and all (and it's a surprisingly likable show), but i know for a fact that it isn't something you watch ep 1, set it as "dropped" and come out on internetz to tell everyone how much you hate it. You know, it takes some good balls to go and say what's in the first lines of your review, and that being said, we all know: every season there are 2 ~ 3 shows the communty says you must hate, and spread s**t about, or else they'll look down at you.
And i'd like to add: the smartphone show was really a pain to finish, (yet i was strong enough to do so) though that one was (ihavetosay) terrible from start to finish. It made me feel like i was being insulted in a different way with every new episode, but yeah, not even the cute little princess could save it, and it was hated by its LN fans.
Then again, i liked your review, and the way hit in the good points of the show. Piece~
Putting this on my one profile since I've been getting a lot of PMS regarding my Imouto review and general praise:
Firstly, yes, I'll review more shows. But like my profile says I mostly reviews show that I MYSELF feels that need it. Whether it was severely ragged on for no reason. Was a dark horse of a season, etc.
Secondly, I plan on rewriting my review/finalizing it at the end of Imouto's airing. The final score itself isn't going to change from what I've seen but some of the ratings I gave certain parts will. Plus it will be more longer and more review-esque.
Yeah, hiveminds on reddit and MAL suck. People start going after a show because a few say it's shit and eventually the whole community shits on it. Another good parody that gets destroyed by people missing the joke is twintails.
Awesome Imouto sae iraba ii review, I think you're the only reviewer who actually understands that it's a parody of shows like eromanga sensei. That and Nayu is best girl.
All Comments (27) Comments
in reality, i would have given it a 5/10, however, when you take into account of how bad the ranking system is in my MAL i just made it 1 higher. You can watch the show and give your opinion if your opinion conflicts on mine however the people giving this 10/10 seems ridiculous.
And i'd like to add: the smartphone show was really a pain to finish, (yet i was strong enough to do so) though that one was (ihavetosay) terrible from start to finish. It made me feel like i was being insulted in a different way with every new episode, but yeah, not even the cute little princess could save it, and it was hated by its LN fans.
Then again, i liked your review, and the way hit in the good points of the show. Piece~
just to be absolutely clear, you are inviting me to offer my thoughts on your review, correct?
Firstly, yes, I'll review more shows. But like my profile says I mostly reviews show that I MYSELF feels that need it. Whether it was severely ragged on for no reason. Was a dark horse of a season, etc.
Secondly, I plan on rewriting my review/finalizing it at the end of Imouto's airing. The final score itself isn't going to change from what I've seen but some of the ratings I gave certain parts will. Plus it will be more longer and more review-esque.
Thanks for the support in the PMs by the way.