Don't forget, ratings are just part of my Point of View
10- A masterpiece, a show that knows what it is and doesn't drive away from its main idea to become meaningful
9- Almost a masterpiece, a show that knows what it is. It might drive away from its main idea but it keeps it closer.
8- Very good, an anime that will probably commit some mistakes, but in the end the quality of its main idea its still strong and meaningful
7- Good, enjoyable, most likely with various mistakes or overused ideas that with enough effort will become somewhat meaningful.
6- Average, it struggles with some mistakes. Still good for most of parts
5- Mediocre, not good, not bad.
4- Bad, laughable, the beginning of a train wreck
3- Very bad. If I ever laugh with one of this is because it manages to maintain its enjoyment value. A train wreck that doesn't seem to get any better
2- dreadful, might be extremely laughable or extremely painful, the amount of pointless and stupid decisions are really obvious unless you are a starter on anime
1- Masterpiece... of shit. can be absurdly laughable, or just garbage. a complete resonance of each 5 aspects to the lowest level. a Score that I might give to the likes of Mars of Destruction
Killer queen has already touched this ranking system