5: Why am I watching this show there are better anime/manga out there. Very few/Nothing I liked. Should I drop?
6: Liked some parts. But generally ok anime/manga
7: Nice! I wish there were more anime/manga like this. Was an enjoyable watch/read
Criteria for favourite anime/manga : I would not mind having my memories wiped of the show and watch it again
Criteria for favorite characters : I wanted more screen time/appearances of this character and want him/her to win/attain goal etc.
But of course it 's not only limited to the above criteria
For manga that have not updated in 365 days, they’ll be moved to the dropped list
Manga that have already ‘ended’ but are still publishing on MAL will also be moved to dropped