I'm a clan leader and a former leader of several forums and sites. Currently working as a private tutor and making cheats for offline games.
I watch and rate anime based on personal interest. Usually i try my best to give a fair score for them, depend on its chosen path. If it excels in its category and turns out natural, i rate it highly, simple as that, no biases whatsoever.I often rate 7 for every anime that i pick myself with that much expectation in mind, then giving it a plus or minus while watching. So you can pretty much view my list with that noted.
Another thing is that i don't ever rate the animation or arts, so 3D, CGI are not a problem to me unlike most people do. Though i do care deeply about the soundtrack or BGM, but not as in OP or ED yeah, again unlike most people. For example, to name a few:
No. 23 from Darker than Black.
Determination from Giant Killing.
Farewell from Steins;Gate
Light your sword from SAO [Yes, even from that series]
I'm available on Steam or Discord with the same username. Feel free to contact me if anything.
I also made a chatbox on Chatango for my clan but it's in Vietnamese only.