I just think and search what I wonder. I'm just here to learn/see the art and the culture and to have discussions. (I only watch 'one of the best animes' that people recommend to me.)
Pefection in anime culture must mean the ideal design of a world , ideal personalities that are unique and improvig for us. New combinations of thoughts that can show us other paths in a different way. Or just an unique entertaintment.
Basic critic system:
What is important in anime?
1- idea, philosophy and uniqeness (and if it does'nt have illogical fanservice that much) 3 points max.
2- how the anime shows us the idea and is it coherent? (plotline) 3 points max.
3- characters and world design 2 points max.
4- aesthetics , animation and ambience 2 points max.
5- extra features and humor. 1 point max.
the max point makes 11/10 but that would mean the ideal anime for me.
the scoring system changes to animes' genre. But not much.
8+/10 = I suggest
[you can see more at my anime list.]
[Everyone can criticize and friend request.]
Everything is perfect. Everything has flaws to help you improve. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯