I'm just here to learn/see the art and the culture and to have discussions. (I mostly watch ''one of the best animes'' that people recommend to me.)
My main view how to critique:
It's nearly same as Maslow's pyramid. Everything has a base what makes us create , think , study , laugh etc. So in anime the base is the main idea main emotions and their purpose. If your base is durable enough you can keep adding on the base: characters , suspense , world , designs , music , ambiance , uniqueness , occurances etc. If you make the top parts of the pyramid dense and heavy and if the base is'nt durable to handle the heavy part , the pyramid would fall off because the base would dissappear in the cluster or densness of addings and uses. So that you have to make the top parts from less dense materials to make the pyramid stay in one piece.(notheanimelol) Thats when mostly the characters , music , world etc. decreases in quality because the base is'nt well built enough. The idea and emotions must be denser than everything that you want to add to the top to achive your goal succesfuly. If you want to make your pyramid seen from further distances you can add more height and use more materials , make replicas and add flashy stuff to your pyramid. But It takes effort and most the people try to be seen as much as they can. Thats when effort and time mostly goes to waste. Neons and height depends on base. How big and dense your base is , the longer you can make your pyramid , more attention and more the pyramid will be seen by more entellectual community. If humans can improve from their faults (monotone and similar plots , characters , fanservice , forced meaningless emotions etc..) the anime films , series and Hollywood films etc. would be at European film quality mostly...
What is important in anime?
1- idea, uniqeness and purpose (and if it does'nt have incoherent fanservice) 3 points max.
2- how the anime shows us the idea and is it improving? (plotline) 3 points max.
3- characters and world design 2 points max.
4- aesthetics , animation , art , music and ambience accordance 2 points max.
5- extra features and humor. 1 point max.
the max point makes 11/10 but that would mean the ideal anime for my system.I try to write some of the flaws of the anime in my anime list.
the scoring system changes to animes' genre. But not much.
My all time favourite musics from mixed genres that I suggest to everyone to listen:
.Bach: Air on the G string
.Philanthrope & Omaure& Flitz&Suppe - Solitude
.Pola Bryson - Unsaid ft BLAKE
.T Matthias - Too Late (ft. NK) (Uplink Remix)
.Kendall Miles x sweetbn_ - flowers
.Flite - Dive
.josh pan - roses are dead
.Cowboy Bebop - Tank! (Holder's TF2 Version)
.SoUs Prod Katia Q - With U Radio Edit
.Uppermost - Night Walk (Azaleh Remix)
.Bonobo - Eyes Down feat Andreya Triana
.Sabre Stray Halogenix Ivy Lab Feat Frank Carter III - Oblique
.Josh Pan - Perfect
.Prokofiev - Dance of the Knights
.Alina Baraz & Galimatias - Make You Feel
.j^p^n - Lullaby
.90sFlav - i n n e r
.Brahms - Symphony No. 2 in D major Op. 73
.Dirtyphonics - Holy Sh!t
.BWV 1007 - Cello Suite No1
.AK - It Takes Time
.LAXX Dion Timmer - Join Me
.vaselin - golden
.Lars Beck Henri Purnell - Silent Games feat Zekt
.MONDO GROSSO - Planetary Tantra
.MONDO GROSSO - labyrinth
.Lana Del Rey - Blue Jeans
.NuTone - Tides feat Lea Lea
.android52 - Real Love
.Element - Dimensions
.Ariana Grande - Into You Chartwell Remix
.deadmau5 & Kaskade - I Remember
[you can see more at my anime list.]
[Everyone can criticize and friend request.]
Everything is perfect. Everything has flaws to help you improve. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
'Best' animes for now:
Eve No Jikan
Serial Experiments Lain
Tenshi no Tamago