Sixteen year old Emma finally arrives at the capital city Hawk Eye after escaping from being held captive for her entire life. But as soon as she arrives, every man in the city, including the king, falls madly in love with her. She is about to be forced into marriage, but is saved by a sorcerer. The sorcerer identifies himself as Shion, one of the youngest and most talented in the nation. They have met before, but Emma has no recollection.
Shion explains to Emma that she is cursed with the Echidna, a mysterious magic that appears every 500 years where a girl is born with her heart packed with such powerful dark magic that it has the potential to destroy the world. With such power, one could rule the world, and Shion explains to Emma that people are going to try and hunt her down to get her heart. However, Emma is told that there exists a ritual that will rid her of the Echidna's curse but doing so will require a long and arduous process. The first of that being Emma and Shion will have to marry each other...
I regret my first review for this. I was young and stupid. Stupid younger self. Don't read the old review under the new review
So I'll rereview it, without bias on what a shounen is.
When I was young, shounen was basically...One Piece. In a nut shell, shounen was One Piece. But then there were Psychological Shounen like Death Note. Shounen just means 'directed to young boys/men', it doesn't necessarily mean...One Piece.
So Magico, I considered maybe it was a romantic shounen, but it wasn't. It wasn't your usual romantic shounen, where the protagonist is dense and the harem punches him. So I concluded
that it was trying to be a battle shounen with romantic plot. Like Rave Master. Horrible example I know, but it's the only one I could think of right now.
Battle shounen tend to have an overall goal: Find the One Piece, Become Hokage, Find my dad, etc. etc. Magico's overall goal in the plot was: Remove the Echidna from Emma(our female protagonist) by going through MANY MANY rituals. So generally, I found the premise interesting, nothing truly captivating. So one would basically expect the manga to be about, Shion(male protagonist) going through many rituals with Emma.
And it's exactly what we got. But, it sometimes felt weak. The rituals were short, uninteresting and most of the time nothing truly ever difficult to Shion. The pacing was quick, there were certain moments where I felt the pacing was right, but couldn't avoid the other flaws. Skill names were cheesy, or skills were introduced blandly, sometimes a fight felt less serious because of someone's comment or reaction, this put the mood away.
Of course from a battle shounen, we are given fights that revolve not around the main goal, but rather the characters themselves. But those were pretty poor as well.
Many of the side characters were basically: "Monster of the week'' with some story. If they had a problem, Shion would fix it, end of problem. Generally if there was a problem, it would end way too quickly without any sort of tension. The development was quite small for our side characters. Some of them were just cut out from a piece of paper, glued on and that was it. They would come back later, but there was nothing really that motivated me to like a side character too much. Maybe one or two.
The main characters were more interesting, especially Shion and Emma, mainly because of the romance. The number of times they act lovey-dovey and cute, is just hnnnnnnnggg. Their interaction within another were just lovable.
Which comes back to another problem. I'm not saying romance in a shounen is bad, I'm just saying, there were soo many cutesy, romance quotes/scenes, as if they were taken from some shoujo manga. While even romance in a battle shounen is taken to a less cutesy extend. I mean one of the ritual, to get rid of Echidna, is to marry. It get's pretty obvious that those two will be a cute couple.
So as a battle shounen it was just not a success, probably why it led to it being axed. It was a heart-warming, romance with action.
I wouldn't say Magico is bad, Magico is enjoyable, it isn't the greatest thing in the world, but it's simple and nice. The ending for Magico was well done, it was rushed due to being axed, but it was one of the better endings. Giving a conclusion to the readers, trying to answer to as many things possible and basically still putting the element many loved.
I no longer base things on art, so that's something I won't point out.
Don't read whatever is under those lines. I'll hurt you.
2 different views. Because this is apparently a shounen, but shoujo readers would enjoy it more. So my point as a shounen and my point as a shoujo.
Holy cow.....this manga is intense Shoujo even though it is suppose to be SHOUNEN, but apparently the mangaka failed. Anyway, this manga has everything a shoujo manga has and apparently does not have have what a shounen manga needs.
It has romance, comedy-ish and cheesy parts. But has fantasy and action.
As a shounen romance reader.
Story: Story is basically okay, but it does go by pretty fast. Which tend to bug me and possible many boy readers out there.
Emma a girl who has the Echidna in her which is some sort of curse, than a boy who apparently loved her since childhood, is also apparently one of the strongest mages around the world comes and knows this ritual to get rid of Echidna.
Most boys at first chapter or first few pages turn it down and I see why. The first chapter includes the main male character, Shion to ask Emma, the main female character to marry him. Obviously this would end for a boy.
As story continues, it's basically most shoujo and most of the ritual didn't involve much ''fighting'' fights are short and and the 2nd characters don't get much introduction nor do they get much well anything. If there is a problem. BAM! MAGIC! Problem solved.
It also is a problem as Shounen manga should have a basic story and point for them to get into. The fights are too short, barely any other character developments and the comedy isn't that funny as it mostly involves around the 2 protagonists well later on in the series anyway.
Too much romance you can say, most boys would like their manga with the less romance possible in a romance, shounen manga. But this manga has so much romance moments, I wondered what was the Mangaka doing when he or she was making a romance and shounen manga.
ART: Omg that art is so, I mean they're 16 or something and they look like 10!
Anyway the other than that art is nice, detailed enough and etc.
The 4 mains. Acts like you could say ''a family'' which apparently can be a huge factor to the shoujo people but not so much for the shounen people.
At the first few chapters they have lots of comedy in them, boys would approve of this, Comedy is usually what would keep the boys for a manga. Especially for the character Anise, Anise was a funny character she showed a lot, but as the story continued I barely see her personality and etc. Really I was sad to see how they showed her less. I really liked her ''Big sister'' personality.
I really I mean really enjoyed it a lot in the beginning, but gave up on the shounen , basically around I think chapter 19 may have been sort of a enjoyment, with a certain characters power.
But I guess most boys would read 10 chapters and just quit.
It's a great series and all. But I'm a girl. For boys would say that it lacked everything in the end and they would just quit. So in a overall as a shounen reader I would base it as a 6 or go lower than that
As a Shoujo romance reader. Omg the shortness of this one.
People as a romance manga. Let me tell you something, I have never seen a fail, why? A romance has the to be one of the easiest thing you could write out there. You could write a cliché story in a website and have the top story in there.
In story wise I have to say as a shoujo romance reader, generally very interesting. You love every moment of the romance, it's cute, even the guy character.
And do I need to continue?
Art is ADORABLE, MOE, KAWAII and that's what a fan girl would say. But I'm not a fan-girl. So I would say, very nice, I could practically say sort of chibi style.
The relation between Shion and Emma(2 of the mains) is just something to love. In fact all the characters are just something to love, well some begin more annoying than others. But you begin to love them afterwards.
For all the females who enjoy shoujo, romance and adorable. You are not going to like it, you are going to love it. I love it for the romance, not because of the fights. Fights are the least thing to love, but most fan-girls would say. It suits it, because of the speed of the manga.
In overall any fan-girl that reads romance would call it a a great manga and go over 8 or so. But I chosed a 7.
As the synopsis has already been provided for you on numerous platforms I will just dive into a quick overview on the story, art, character and my overall enjoyment.
STORY - 7
Magico holds a special place in my heart. Some of you might be wondering why I have allocated a "good" (7) instead of anything higher. For one, Magico has a well established plot line going for it. However, I can't help but feel that it would have easily enriched the characters' development or enhanced the audience's understanding of the story arcs if each arc were to be explored for a bit longer. The development of
the plot line (in my opinion) wavered from good to fair. Despite the pacing being somewhat hastened this does not lessen the quality of other dynamics of the manga. i.e. battle scenes and character chemistry. The action scenes are engaging however it is understandable that some people might not appreciate the light-hearted humor that seeps itself in every now and then. Magico highlights each of its themes and genres with ease encouraging its readers to cheer on its main characters. It doesn't fail to capture a soft spot in your heart accompanied with a dash of innocence and humor.
ART - 8
There have been plenty of moments where the art really shines. This is evidently shown from the detail of the character designs to the detail to the magic displayed - especially on the full page panels. There are times where it left me thinking, "wow, that must have taken a long time to draw," or "that looks so cool!" Other times, background illustration remain empty and simplistic but that doesn't cease to compliment the tone/mood being established.
Character - 7
Our main set of characters have their own quirks of pure straightforwardness. As well as being a close group of friends, together, they also form their own "family". This bond is what drives each of them to want to succeed and keep moving forward; creating more happy memories in the midst of their difficult adventure. I must say though, they are not anything out of the original (personality wise). But their backstories and experiences mold them into their own uniqueness. The experiences of the four (though only given a snapshot) allow the readers to sympathize for them and appreciate their growth from where they started to who they have become.
Emma is the kindhearted and fun loving protagonist - the mother of the group.
Shion is the badass magician who works hard for others - the father of the group.
Anise, the cat, acts as the elder sister of the group. She provides the calmer, loving support for the love birds Emma and Shion.
And finally Luu - the daughter of the group. Mainly for her child-like actions and her age. Side note: her strength is pretty epic and experience as a magician is something to admire in its own right.
The supporting characters fulfill their role of actually *supporting* in the manga. Just like how the story was a bit rushed so was the potential to connect with the supporting characters.
Enjoyment - 8
At the time of me reading this, I am in preparation of very stressful exams coming up soon. So taking time off to read through Magico was really refreshing and fun to do. I liked it so I binged read it in the span over two days (at night then in the following morning). It made me laugh and it made me sad at occasions. Most effectively, it made me become determined to aspire to work hard and have fun at the same time just as the characters have. I quite enjoyed reading this manga.
Overall - 7.5
Altogether, I'm on the ladder of giving it an 8 (very good) or a 7 (good). Strictly speaking I would give it a 7. On the contrary, out of my experience and enjoyment overall I would give it an 8. So I will stick with the latter of 7.5.
It does have its faults but has its own areas where it does well. It is a good read and something worth giving a go. Total recommendation to shounen manga lovers who enjoy the romance genre as well.
This is my first review so please feel free to leave any comments or send me messages on areas I can improve! Thanks for reading!
Magico a really well done manga by Iwamoto Naoki,it's a different kind of shounen with romance. A whole bunch of cute characters!!
I for one love Shion and Emma since they first met and I don't know what people meant by this seems more shojo when it isn't ,I read a whole bunch and this isn't corny as shojo manga.this has it's limits but it's so sweet and you just wish for the best for them.
The comedy in this manga is the best,a lot of nose bleeds from Shion and many other characters that will leave you laughing too.
The main story is too lift up the
curse Emma has because of what she is, and how love has their ups and downs what they(other couples)would do stay withy their loved ones or precious things.
Character designs so cute!!may look like Tegami Bachi
Go on many adventures tournaments and much more and the more and more Shion loves to see Emma smile and isn't afriad to show how he loves her by saving her and protecting her. The action scenes are worth reading and seeing, but it seems that they have met before only she can't remeber but Shion does.
Overall a great manga to read even though I feel it rushed, and it ended with sweet ending for them both.I wanted to read more they are such a cute couple thst I wantgto know what happened next.I loved this series and can't wait for the next from Iwamoto!!
I read this series a long time ago, and it has been one of the most memorable manga I have ever read.
The story is fairly straight forward with the usual flashbacks. Nothing out of the ordinary in that regard. What got me was the concept that the story was following. I think that quite a few of us have read manga where magicians are prominent. In magico, magic is based around the completion of rituals. The more powerful magics require you to undergo rigorous training or near impossible tasks. This series really provided a fresh twist to how magic works in that regard. it did
away with the archetypal magicians who are book smart, and are weak on a physical level.
The art work in this was also fairly exceptional at the time of it's release. It is very cartoonish, and child like in nature, but there is a strong maturity in the artwork that bellies the romantic elements of the series. Because of this the battle artwork is exceptional, and it captures the violence without being explicit. Overall, the artistry is very pretty, and highly conventional.
Another aspect of this series that kept me coming back was the relationship between the characters, and their individual personalities. Each character leaves you with a distinct impression, and all of the major heroes and villains are memorable.
Although this series was very short, I feel that in its time it created a rich and diverse universe through not only its artwork, but through its storytelling. The concept is really well thought out, the characters are incredibly real in spite of their obvious hero/heroine qualities, and the magic is extremely cool.
If you have the time, this is definitely one to give a read!