One Piece

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

It is significantly hard to write a review of any manga that is more than 1000 chapters, and especially one as popular as One Piece and make it worthwhile, but I think there's a way.

Simply put I started One Piece expecting to give up around couple hundred chapters in when I got bored, when it was too filler heavy, or when it felt like it wasn't valuing my time. 1000 chapters later, I would honestly say it never even got close to any of those marks. I am honestly quite shocked because I intended to be extra critical.

There's a reason this ... series has the fans it has, has gone on for 1000 chapters, and still is popular as ever. It's extremely high quality, well writing and has characters that are interesting.

You can get a good grasp of the positives just by reading the first few chapters, so let's focus more on why might someone not like this manga.

One complaint I've heard from someone I trust was he didn't like how the character's don't grow and develop. Over 1000 chapters, I do believe that's incorrect, but they really don't grow that much outside of a few points in the story. The thing is, I don't see that as a problem. Luffy and his crew are the focus of the story in the way Frodo carrying the ring is the focus of the story. The story is just the ability of the author to build a vast and interesting world. Every major character Luffy meets whether friend or foe gets development and usually a back story. Every villain is unique and interesting, every location is fresh and new and novel. I'm surprised I can't think of a single concept that feels like it was used more than once, outside of "Fishing villages" early on, and yet each one is unique. That's why I love the story, and if you want a lot of interpersonal development of the main characters you're in the wrong place.

I will mention that Luffy is... a force of nature and after reading a bit, he's great at what he is, but he also will rub a lot of people the wrong way. He's a guy who falls ass backwards into treasure while not even meaning too. Also he's a pirate, but he's a "good guy" so no murder, no pillage, no looting, he's basically a bad pirate. "He defies the law" but even then... he doesn't really, he just fights corrupt law enforcers for the most part. If you want a "real pirate", this will definitely upset you. But I do think again this is perfectly acceptable, especially for the time it came out at, and the target audience.

At the same time, I do have one complaint and it's what keeps me from giving this a 10. The action. This has definitely improved over time, but I still feel like the action is very hard to follow at times, and at the beginning it was just the typical "Shout a move name, show it" and then that's it.

Now the action shows more of the background and areas. Battles are perhaps too large, and the combat is better. But it's still not "Epic level" And seeing stuff like Gantz (Which has too much action, or at least too in-depth) and Berserk, I start to realize why those mangas stand out, when this is more indicative of the typical action in manga. (Again it becomes better, but never truly epic).

The one other thing I'll say is I found Punk Hazard's arc to be a little messy. It made me worry that the writing/story was going to take a downward spiral, but it is probably the only arc I'll say was a step down in quality, and likely doesn't need to be mentioned in my review, but it is, so apparently it does.

Ultimately I'm onboard, I'm ready to ride this to the end and I'm ready to see what eventually happens to the entire Straw Hat Crew. While I've heard this will end in 2025? I don't believe it. Wrapping up everything in just two years seems impossible, and at the very least extremely rushed.

But at the same time, I also don't want it to end in 2025, this is a series that needs a satisfying ending, not an info dump, not a "That's the story". There needs to be multiple epilogues for all the characters if they're not all wrapped up, and I really hope it doesn't play out like some stupid "their stories don't matter any more because X happened".

I probably won't return to update this unless my score heavily changes, but at the same time, I'd recommend almost anyone to read a few chapters of One Piece. If you don't enjoy it, that's ok, your opinion is valid as is mine, (And don't be afraid to review it if it doesn't speak to you). But at the same time, if you do enjoy it, be prepared because you're not on the ride yet, you're only in the line waiting to get on the roller coaster, and even then we still don't know where it will end. But the one thing is you will almost certainly enjoy the trip.

PS. The only manga I can personally compare this too for its length is Hajime no Ippo. I prefer Hajime no Ippo more, it's a 10 in my book, HOWEVER, there are reasons I prefer Hajime no Ippo to One Piece, and there's are probably a thousands reasons I can suggest that One Piece is more popular or appeals to more people. And the fact is... They're both great mangas.

It's a pretty good manga. It's just not for me. And that's fine, if some people enjoy it, they enjoy it.

However, I will say my piece. The beginning starts off great, with the East Blue saga being a pretty good introduction to One Piece. We saw our first group of characters, Nami got her arc, and it was well done. The entire series is done fairly well. So why don't I like it. It is just far too long, with little to no stakes. I get that the journey is the point, you're supposed to derive enjoyment from just watching the gang have fun ... and wander around, but it's just far too dragged out.

The side characters constantly get sidelined and the main 3 guys always take the spotlight in every single fucking arc. I just don't like it anymore. I am also of the opinion that the writing went downhill post timeskip.

But that's just what i think. If you want a story that's decent at some points, a story that's just an adventure with almost nothing else to it (in my opinion), read the story. If you want literally anything else, don't read this manga. Lastly, this manga should definitely not be number 4.

I approached One Piece optimistically. A friend was eager for me to get into it. There's no shortage of rave reviews for it online. I heard time and time again that Oda was an exceptional world-builder. I don't read all of the big shonen mangas, but I know I love a couple of series within the genre, so I had no reservations about the format. I was excited to see what all the hype was about. After reading 500+ chapters, I've dropped the series. I likely would have dropped it earlier if my friend hadn't urged me to make it to later arcs where it ... "gets good." Needless to say, I'm not a fan.

The story kicks off well enough. Characters are colorful, the tone is light, there's a charm to its old-timey seaside aesthetic, and the fantastical elements are intriguing. I imagine most readers would be propelled to read further as they're promised a grand adventure in distant lands, where great dangers, unfathomable sights, and the ultimate treasures await the crew.

From that point on, I'd sum up my experience as slowly realizing that the story has no real intentions of progressing beyond its initial setup. The formula of OP's arcs described in others' reviews is accurate. It's reused again and again without any real twists or turns in the major plot. I know it's technically a serialized manga, but I find OP's story most comparable to episodes of a show like Scooby Doo. In a Scooby Doo episode, you know what you're getting: The gang visits a new town, investigates clues, confronts the monster, and solves the mystery. They get split up at some point, Shaggy gets scared, Velma loses her glasses, etc. Reusing a formula isn't necessarily a bad thing, but I found that OP's characters and the dynamics between them weren't strong enough to entertain me for hundreds of chapters and dozens of repetitive arcs. Their shticks grew stale. Nothing they do is exceptionally funny, badass, or touching. It's all serviceable until it isn't.

The big difference between OP and something like Scooby Doo is that OP props up the illusion that a larger plot is progressing. Yes, certain things in OP change permanently, but almost never in a way that changes the course of the crew's adventure. There's a reliance on manufactured milestones (e.g., Grand Line, Shichibukai, the crew's bounty). At the end of arcs, Oda will maybe drip feed the audience some lore or give a character a new power. This is the illusion of change. It's all a carrot on a stick—an RPG grind. It crosses the line between keeping the audience hooked and stringing them along, intentionally tricking them. It truly felt cynical.

The praise for OP's world-building genuinely confuses me. Yes, there's a lot of stuff in its world—a lot of characters, species, apparel, tech, etc. Still, most additions to the world aren't pieces of a larger puzzle. The inclusion of giants, sentient frogs, and zombies are all inconsequential. Non-human species simply act like humans. A big, mountable duck is functionally just a horse. These aren't bad things; they're just not really examples of world-building. It's set dressing. I bring this all up because the praise of OP's world-building was what convinced me to check it out. 1000+ chapters was nearly flipped into a selling point—imagine how rich, complex, and interconnected a world could be built in a series with that chapter count! In reality, the world is very simple. There's some factions, some history, some key locations—nothing I couldn't explain to someone in a couple of minutes. That gargantuan chapter count is instead largely spent telling the same, self-isolated story on one-off islands.

As I've seen other reviewers criticize, characters never die in OP. It's not that characters need to die for a story to be good. What's bothersome about OP is that it constantly sets up "life and death" stakes as its source of tension. Once a reader catches on to the fact that Oda is not willing to kill a character, subsequent battles are understood as simply going through the motions, getting from A to B (sometimes I could at least appreciate the fight choreography or some visual spectacle, but OP doesn't excel in these categories). There's no worry that a character will be lost, devastating those close to them and changing the course of the crew's plans. That brings me to another issue with OP's stakes. I've seen some people point out that there's no romance in OP. I think, more generally, the problem is that no characters share close bonds. Part of what's exciting about strong relationships between characters is that something stands to be lost. The OP crew, on the other hand, feels sterile—their character sheets would state that they'd do anything for each other, but I never felt that that connection was earned or believable. There's a distance between them. They each do their own thing and are never truly changed by one another. I can't imagine the death of one crew member affecting the rest of the crew in any significant, long-term way. Without real stakes, tension and excitement were elusive feelings throughout my reading of OP.

I don't knock any points off for OP's art. I think Oda is a good artist. He's not a master, but I'm not expecting that from everything I read. My most negative opinion surrounding the subject has to do with his character design sensibilities. I think OP was visually strongest in the beginning. Oda kept characters looking simple, which there's a charm and memorability to. As the crew gets farther in their adventures, they come across wackier or more powerful characters. Oda often misses the mark in portraying these characters as bizarre, godly, fashionable, badass, or whatever else. Their body types and/or outfits can be described as garish. So, I wasn't liking where that trend was headed at the time I stopped reading.

Ultimately, I feel burned by this series. I don't believe it has respect for the reader's time. It's artificially lengthened: In a later arc, Luffy is offered the location of the One Piece (the ultimate treasure), and he declines because "What's the fun in that?!" At some point, it's all too evident that OP does not continue because it needs more time to express certain messages, wrap up a complex plot, illustrate a strong character arc, etc. It continues because it makes money. I'm usually not the person to bring that up, but the thought became hard to ignore while reading something so bloated and meandering.

Ironically, OP is devoid of adventure—something it claims to be all about. Its arcs are predictable. There are no real stakes or sacrifices. There aren't strong bonds made. The plot doesn't take surprising turns. I can't describe OP as a story with real heart, joy, or impact.

If you love the OP crew and like seeing them do their thing on playfully themed islands, then I understand having a positive opinion of the series. I would just disagree with claims that the appeal of OP amounts to much more than that. I know I've only read about half of the series, but I think I've given it more than enough chances to prove itself. Thanks for reading.