What exactly was Captain Blacks plan?! SPOILERS UNTIL EP19 OR VOL5

Fire_Sloth21 said:
to take all of kaya’s money and property. btw are u watching dub!!

Trickieking said:

I watched German Dub until mid fishmen island then rewatched all to date with english subs. Soo not rly
Except for the Manga, only english

MR-GOD said:
You literally just explained a simple story line… is this not supposed to make sense? This is a really dumb post

FMmatron said:


The plan makes sense, you just seem confused about some of his actions because you haven't seen the arc in a minute?


He ignored eavesdropping Usopp at first because no one would believe him anyway and he was right. The villagers chased him away/Merry shot him in the arm. During the raid he would've killed him along with everyone else.

He planned to silence his crew forever from the very beginning. He wanted peace of mind above anything else and to achieve that every potenial threat had to be eliminated.

He attacked Luffy obviously because he stood in his way.

FMmatron said:
@Trickieking


He was tired of being a pirate, tired of being hunted like an animal, that's why he thought up his plan in the first place.

Framing pillaging pirates is the logical thing to do. Attacks happen on a daily basis.

If he killed Kaya immediately without spending 3 years at her side it wouldn't have made any sense for him to inherit her fortune. He had to become the loyal butler first to not raise suspicion + her parents were still alive when he was employed. It was them who took him in.

He couldn't care less about the lifes of the villagers. They were mere pawns on his chess board. The difference between a plan and a plan that's likely to succeed are the time invested and the sacrifices made. He's a "perfectionist" who needed to add layers. Of course he didn't expect that someone like Luffy would arrive.

Your plan sounds more convoluted tbh(look for another excuse xD)

Trickieking said:

Wow I have never been insulted like this before! 😂
But okay I forgot about her parents bringing him in in the first place and I see the perfectionist part and that (bc of natures tendency to only adjust to the patient ones) he went through all those years. I still don’t see how stubborn he must’ve been to put up the image of the loyal butler in the first place, when his plan (maybe but probably) already included the death of every last villager-witnesses of his legitimacy as a loyal butler as well as his origin in piracy haha
Quite a guy to mess with!
Only his way of readjusting his glasses, hinting at his weapon of use-past, apparently wasn’t relevant enough to be bothered with.
But to downgrade my argumentation to that rather irrelevant detail! You deserve my eulogy you highness of such bright argumentation.

I still will remember your insult against my perfect, impeccable plan, carefully adjusted to Captain Blacks psychopathic being.
I understand your mastery of emphasizing with such a maniac perfectly, to the point where you can reveal his devilish plan, his motivations and desires, as a warning to society my friend!

Trickieking said:
For all who remember or recently watched the Syrup village Arc (Usopps Hometown):
What was Captain Blacks plan?

To summarize:

He was chased by marines,
wanted to leave piratehood for good,
started new as the butler of Kaya,
remained that for years,
comes out it’s only to gain her trust,
invited his former crew, that he intentionally left befor, for an invasion,
planned the timing of raid with them (I guess),
threatens, then straight up ignores Usopp after he found out,
no one believes Usopp,
Luffys crew beats half of the crew,
Black reveals himself as a killer/captain black to Kaya anyway,
talks about his actual plan to legally inherit Kayas belongings after her near NATURAL death,
does the exact opposite,
FORCES/THREATENS her to sign the last will contract,
“kills“ Luffy bc he beat his men (why?!),
slaughters his people himself,
also attacks the random pirate Luffy,
still wants Kayas stuff the legal way,
looses against Luffy,
Like WTH?!
Did I miss anything?!