| Really it's 7.86 not a bad score at all |
 "I want to show that woman the true Yoshikage Kira. I want her to hear how I feel deep inside. That I want to take your slender neck into these hands and strangle you to death." |
| People are probably more turned off by the furry society concept than the CGI Or turned off by both But yeah this show is worth atleast an 8 IMO and the manga a 9, sadly enough... the furry concept man... some people... Both the Manga and Anime score lower than I think they deserve, just my opinion tho. |
Xstasy said: I would've preferred if they didn't use CGI, but honestly it's not that bad. I think that frame rate drops are a bigger issue. It's a shame that this anime hasn't been done by a better studio. Imagine how more awesome it would've been if it was done by MADHOUSE or KyotoAni. Madhouse is a very average studio nowadays. Overlord CGI was a totally mess. Well, at least No Guns Life is not that bad, but Beastars CGI still way better. |
OttesOct 24, 2019 12:29 PM
| 7.86 for an airing anime thats not a sequel is pretty fucking good. Specially for a CG/''furry''/stuck in netflix jail anime. |
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
| Score's getting higher with time though, not mentioning near 8 is pretty good nonetheless and if you look at the stats you can see most people gave it a 7-8 score so far which definitely explains why it is stuck in that range. Anyway, MAL score being driven by a community to me makes it just as credible as a critical source than any user scores on Metacritic. |
| A lot of series on MAL are rated highly due to its massive fanbase and popularity in the media. Although their story, plot, etc. are mediocre and severely generic, they boast high scores due to those reasons. There are many series which suffer form low ratings due to their lack of a wider audience and publicity that their more popular counterparts revel in. |
| 臭い- |
| I think this show deserves atleast a score of 8.3 |
| Go check out my latest review: https://myanimelist.net/profile/YeeYeeAss/reviews |
| If it keeps this amazing quality it's sure to get at least close to Houseki no Kuni in score, if not surpass it by the end of the season |
 |
| It's probably lower because of Netflix jail, a lot people are actually giving positive feedback about this. |
| I thought the CGI was pretty solid |
| Why do you think 7.9 is a bad score? It's pretty high and it's more solid than all these shitty mainstream shows with 8.5+. It has really good CGI and the story is very promising. If it keeps going good I predict that its score will be about 7.9-8.2 |
Nemo_NiemandNov 1, 2019 6:57 AM
 |
| I found the art style pretty bad, to be honest. However, the score isn't low, it's a good score. |
 |
| The same thing happened to Houseki no Kuni (made by Orange as well), where it had around 6.00 I think but is now 8.4. I think once they give Beastars a chance, they'll find out it's actually an interesting story and that the animation isn't bad at all. |
 |
twoego said: I really don't get why every studio is forcing aesthetically-unpleasing ugly-ass CGI on every possible anime; it's pretty good in this one though, so it gets a pass. CGI isn't that bad overall honestly, but I'd prefer not seeing it every season minimally ten times. CGI saves time and costs less. Which I can understand, since the schedule for animating is really tight. |
| Sometimes it feels like people are brainwashed to believe that CGI = bad. It's one of the best looking shows this season and furthermore the highest rated non-sequel(I exclude Fate). |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
NotFred said: twoego said: I really don't get why every studio is forcing aesthetically-unpleasing ugly-ass CGI on every possible anime; it's pretty good in this one though, so it gets a pass. CGI isn't that bad overall honestly, but I'd prefer not seeing it every season minimally ten times. CGI saves time and costs less. Which I can understand, since the schedule for animating is really tight. And in the hands of good studios like Orange and Ufotable, they can actually enhance your experience by utilizing this method of animation instead of being more of a "We can't actually properly animate this in 2D cuz of the cost so let's just use CGI". |
| It’s neither about the furry thing or the CGI. I personally feel like the plot is still a bit too pretentious, but at least the tone and theme is very much there. I only care about Legosi in terms of characters, though. |
 |
| This definitely helps, but it's also because it's not shounen and because it doesn't have a 3 minute fight scene with ufotable production. Aparently this is what it takes for it have a good score on MAL. Anyway, if KnY have taught us anything, is that score here in this site shouldn't really be taken serious. Just enjoy the show |
 |
thiago52192 said: This definitely helps, but it's also because it's not shounen and because it doesn't have a 3 minute fight scene with ufotable production. Aparently this is what it takes for it have a good score on MAL. Anyway, if KnY have taught us anything, is that score here in this site shouldn't really be taken serious. Just enjoy the show Except that Beastars is published in a shounen magazine and has a good amount of fight scenes during the run. Stop trying to use KnY to justify x or y when has nothing to do with Beastars. |
Ottes said: thiago52192 said: This definitely helps, but it's also because it's not shounen and because it doesn't have a 3 minute fight scene with ufotable production. Aparently this is what it takes for it have a good score on MAL. Anyway, if KnY have taught us anything, is that score here in this site shouldn't really be taken serious. Just enjoy the show Except that Beastars is published in a shounen magazine and has a good amount of fight scenes during the run. Stop trying to use KnY to justify x or y when has nothing to do with Beastars. Except I clearly was referring to Shounen as the main characteristics of the genre, and not the magazine. And I clearly wasn't referring to the quantity of fight scenes in the show, but how it is portrayed, which focus much more in characters problems instead of cliche battle shounen such as KnY, which relies only in hype whithout making the background of the fight (character motivations and overall plot) interesting. And yes, KnY has nothing to do with Beasters, but it's the best example to understand the mentality of most people while rating a show in MAL, which is the main question of the OP. People won't care how much Beasters is developing it's characters and creating a good story, most of them just want a hype scene in order to increase the score. |
|
| It's sadly not that popular. That's one bad thing about Netlix jail. If this had more people watching, it would easy garner a fanbase to lift up the score. It'll probably reach above 8.00 in the end though, that's all that matters imo |
| poop |
| I remember I started reading the manga when it was like 8.12 and now its 8.53. It´s one of those stories that take its time to get interesting. I´d dare to say that´s a bigger consideration than the CGI being un-appealing for most anime fans. Wait till Gouhin´s arc (i don´t recommed reading his description if you are an anime-only, it´s almost a spoiler), the score could really rise up after that point. |
MichaelJacksonNov 2, 2019 2:55 PM
| :v |
| Since episode 4 got out, the score went up from 7.85 to 7.99 right now and still going up. Quality of the show is speaking for itself right now ! |
| Now it's at 8.00! The score is just rising higher and higher, excellent. |
| Don't question my antics. |
Ottes said: but the thing is we haven't see any of beastars great fight scenes yet in the anime, that's why it hasn't garnered enough attention to hype up the score. But when the fight comes (end of season 1), depending on how they animate the cgi, it'll for sure raise the score incrementally.thiago52192 said: This definitely helps, but it's also because it's not shounen and because it doesn't have a 3 minute fight scene with ufotable production. Aparently this is what it takes for it have a good score on MAL. Anyway, if KnY have taught us anything, is that score here in this site shouldn't really be taken serious. Just enjoy the show Except that Beastars is published in a shounen magazine and has a good amount of fight scenes during the run. Stop trying to use KnY to justify x or y when has nothing to do with Beastars. MichaelJackson said: gouhin's arc is when this story reveals its true self and you see just how different it is from the other typical school-romance whatnots, and how Beastars is a story that can only be told with anthropomorphic animals, and substituting them with human characters simply won't work.I remember I started reading the manga when it was like 8.12 and now its 8.53. It´s one of those stories that take its time to get interesting. I´d dare to say that´s a bigger consideration than the CGI being un-appealing for most anime fans. Wait till Gouhin´s arc (i don´t recommed reading his description if you are an anime-only, it´s almost a spoiler), the score could really rise up after that point. |
| Now the rating is pretty accurate :D |
| The show is not that good. I think the current score is too high. And I don't care about CGI. It does not bother me at all |
| The score isn't bad rn. And for me, the cgi isn't bad |
 |
Mattinator95 said: Jet44 said: I want this show to at least get 8.4 because of the manga, I don't know if they'll screw future episodes up, but if they don't then it'll be well deserved. The story telling(in the plot twist way) is on the same level as Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica if not better. Same or higher then land of lustorus would be good as well Yay, it definitely deserves better score than land of lustorus, the show is brilliant and I don't even see any pointabout people complaining about CGI!! Well, if land of lustorus is anything to go by, its score increased from 7.00 to 8.5. So, there is no reason beastars can't repeat it(specially when it started way ahead at 7.7). |
shubh_jain_2Dec 7, 2019 7:31 PM
| 'I have no bonds tying me down. That's why I can see things as they are!!' - Yugami |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Beastars Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Oct 30, 2019 |
112 |
by Kayarbee70
»»
Apr 10, 8:09 PM |
|
Poll: » Beastars Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Oct 16, 2019 |
178 |
by Kayarbee70
»»
Apr 10, 7:27 PM |
|
Poll: » Beastars Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Dec 25, 2019 |
199 |
by chittripper1
»»
Feb 18, 8:06 AM |
|
Poll: » Beastars Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Dec 11, 2019 |
114 |
by Kvistis
»»
Jan 11, 12:30 AM |
|
Poll: » Beastars Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Nov 27, 2019 |
115 |
by Kvistis
»»
Jan 10, 11:54 PM |