DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| I got really confused five minutes in. They all walk onto the planet with their helmets on so I think "oh yeah, the atmosphere must not be breathable" but then a second later they all just have the helmets off. I thought it was a mistake like "wait, where did the helmets go, why aren't the choking?" Eventually I realised, it was just bad directing in that bit. Rest of the episode was good though. I like the imagination put into the plant life. |
| Somehow I didn't enjoy this episode as much as the previous one. It even felt too long and dragged on despite being half the length. I actually learned some spoilers about the main twist and it could be quite interesting but watching this episode was truly boring. The characters seem bland and the power of friendship is getting annoying. |
  |
| Another Great Episode! It’s hard to believe 5 Chapters were adapted in this Episode but here’s to hoping it keeps up the good work! It’s really hard to tell who could be the culprit is given everything that has transpired thus far but a part of me for some reason suspects Aries to be. Lol @ that hilarious laughter though, totally lost my shit there xD. A bit of foreshadowing there I suspect with those camera angles during the moment, I don’t know it just sort of reeks of something suspicious. I don’t suppose her photographic memory has to do anything with this, but who knows. It’s a pity because I’m really starting to like her and that “waah” moment to the shy glasses girl was a very delightful treat. Anyway, that aside, it was nice to see some more of Kanata this episode and the Quitterie/Funicia bit was handled pretty well too. Comedy, imo, was far better this episode so another plus. A little bit of convenience factor on a couple of occasions admittedly but it was still very fun nonetheless! ED song was amazing too, I’d love to hear more of that, and another round of applause to the brilliant usage and mix of soundtracks! Off to a flier certainly, this show! |
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni  |
Crashmatt said: nanashi796 said: everything in this anime is generic shit Yes because we get loads of space anime all the time..... Plenty of isseki for you this season you forgot to mention that there are so many characters with photographic memory, who are decathletes and want to go into space exploration i don't really see anything generic apart from their personality types and even that is questionable as we see them exhibit traits that aren't bound to their stereotypical first impression like a tsundere actually admitting their mistake and faults, and apologizing for example. To an extent they may be, but i don't see whats so bad about it. So i totally agree with you. |
You son of a .. turtle  |
| It's definitely gonna be a complete adaptation. So, let's see what we have here for the source material: - Ranked in Kono Manga ga Sugoi 2019 (3rd Place). √ - Winner of the Manga Taisho Award for 2019. √ - Majority of the readers opinion: That second half of the story.√ - Nothing but positive reviews (8/10 or more) in most of the popular sites.√ Ah! People will go like "Oh, this is so generic and boring." and then leave early and then come back again when the overall score jumps roughly around episode 6 or 7. Hmm. I can totally see that happening. Also, weekly appreciation of the beauty that is Quitterie. ❤  |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
Rowan_F said: I got really confused five minutes in. They all walk onto the planet with their helmets on so I think "oh yeah, the atmosphere must not be breathable" but then a second later they all just have the helmets off. I thought it was a mistake like "wait, where did the helmets go, why aren't the choking?" Eventually I realised, it was just bad directing in that bit. Not really. They wore their helmets initially as a precaution b/c they were unsure of the breathability of the atmosphere, then removed them once they had verified they could breathe the air. Very sensible thing to do actually. Didn't really need to be called out as they wanted to give priority to the plot and character development. Thank you for this. Early Best Girl frontrunner. |
| Set SCE to AUX |
| Eh when Funi got snatched up it felt pretty emotionally manipulative. If anyone else was in that kind of danger I wouldn't have cared in the slightest. The scene only had stakes because it was a cute girl in danger, but she was put in danger because she wandered off on her own. It's hard to feel sympathy for someone who's in danger when it's they're own fault. Anyways plot armor saves her because Kanata has superhuman strength, still I appreciate he's dealing with his own flaws. This episode was a major tonal shift from tense drama to fun excitement to explore a new planet. It was obvious something dangerous would happen again. Lo and behold another black hole orb tried to eat them. Aries has some nice photographic memory if she can't even remember the last planet they were on sent them to deep space. Anyways next episode will be some more interpersonal drama in the group. At least Quittere and Funi are closer now. |
 |
| I wouldn't even call this writing, it's just shit strung together at break-neck speed. I laughed when she said she didn't need friends and one flashback and a scary situation later she loves her friends. Should have stopped when Aries revealed her photographic memory. Oh and by the way the guy is an athlete, fuck these people. Awful. The comedy in the beginning was kind of fun, but I don't think I can sit through another episode of this. Planet hopping space adventures have never looked so shitty. |
syncrogazerJul 10, 2019 10:57 AM
| Not a good episode. It's generic as hell and I simply don't care for the characters, especially for that one girl that wandered off on her own. Stupid girl smh. That laugh was very odd. |
 |
gotta hope all these fact claiming complainers drop it fast so we don't need to read their unconstructive comments anymore xD SleepySnowSpirit said: actually second best(new) anime of the season after Dr.Stone for me.... glad I read the synopsis cause the art wasn't much. Yea look forward to a lot of good stuff in the 2nd half. shanimebib said: It's definitely gonna be a complete adaptation. So, let's see what we have here for the source material: - Ranked in Kono Manga ga Sugoi 2019 (3rd Place). √ - Winner of the Manga Taisho Award for 2019. √ - Majority of the readers opinion: That second half of the story.√ - Nothing but positive reviews (8/10 or more) in most of the popular sites.√ Ah! People will go like "Oh, this is so generic and boring." and then leave early and then come back again when the overall score jumps roughly around episode 6 or 7. Hmm. I can totally see that happening. Also, weekly appreciation of the beauty that is Quitterie. ❤ beautiful shot :D i hope they drop it fast, they are so annoying like really its fine if someone doesn't like it, but they state their opinion as facts and thats just so annoying and stupid, its like watching 5 year olds run against walls, thats just a sort of stupidity you feel ashamed when you see it can't wait for the 2nd half. |
You son of a .. turtle |
| btw a funny dialogue that was cut this ep  syncrogazer said: I laughed when she said she didn't need friends and one flashback and a scary situation later she loves her friends. ah yeah that  RebelPanda said: Eh when Funi got snatched up it felt pretty emotionally manipulative. If anyone else was in that kind of danger I wouldn't have cared in the slightest. The scene only had stakes because it was a cute girl in danger, but she was put in danger because she wandered off on her own. It's hard to feel sympathy for someone who's in danger when it's they're own fault. Anyways plot armor saves her because Kanata has superhuman strength, still I appreciate he's dealing with his own flaws. really? you cant sympathise with a little kid running off and getting in danger? so decathletes have superhuman strength? its pretty normal strength for a decathlete just for reference, in the manga kanata also stated the length of the jump was something slightly above 7 metres, professional grown decathletes jump over 8,5metre, the world record is close to 9 and the spear throw wasn't particularly far either syncrogazer said: Oh and by the way the guy is an athlete, fuck these people. Awful.. Eww look mum there is an athlete over there, such an awful group of people fuck them right? |
Nim0174Jul 10, 2019 11:24 AM
You son of a .. turtle |
Nim0174 said: gotta hope all these fact claiming complainers drop it fast so we don't need to read their unconstructive comments anymore xD They won't. They get off on the reactions they get from people who actually enjoy and defend the show. Best policy is just to ignore. I got into it with one of those jackasses earlier today and it was a mistake. Don't feed the trolls. |
| Set SCE to AUX |
| @Nim0174 Thanks for the manga screenshot that tells me nothing. And improve your reading comprehension, I'm obviously making fun of the cliched writing. |
syncrogazer said: @Nim0174 Thanks for the manga screenshot that tells me nothing. And learn some reading comprehension, I'm obviously making fun of the cliched writing. it tells you nothing? really? you said "I laughed when she said she didn't need friends and one flashback and a scary situation later she loves her friends." Quittery says " I CANT SET MY PRIDE ASIDE TO SAY WHAT I MEAN" logical conclusion any person can draw she didn't actually mean what she first said === (she doesn't need friends) and what she actually meant was something completely different amazing right, and im not even Sherlock Homes. |
You son of a .. turtle |
Kimurah said: Spaceship said: I'm 12 years old and I'm butthurt. Stop shitting on muh animu No can do kiddo. Don't like different comments/opinions, don't log in to a discussion board Don't like a show, don't watch it. |
 |
| @Nim0174 And? It doesn't change the fact that it happened in a span of less than five minutes. |
syncrogazer said: @Nim0174 And? It doesn't change the fact that it happened in the span of less than five minutes. And? "she said she didn't need friends and one flashback and a scary situation later she loves her friends." she didn't mean it, she always liked her friends. She just didn't say it. therefore the switch in her actual feelings doesn't occur like u stated. people in real life too tend to say things on the spur of the moment that they do not mean |
You son of a .. turtle |
| @Nim0174 Fucking hell. I get it. My problem is with the pacing. I don't care about the logic of her behavior or her background. |
syncrogazer said: @Nim0174 Fucking hell. I get it. My problem is with the pacing. I don't care about the logic of her behavior or her background. then fucking say it no need to act like a douchebag i wouldn't have an issue with it if she actually felt that she hated them etc, but she didn't i personally don't think that this event even mattered in the relatively fast pace if you don't like the pacing just say that you don't like the pacing and felt it was too fast no need to call it out as if it was a fact with insulting words i do agree with you there to some extent it felt fast, sadly we only have 12 episodes, but it was logically consistent because she didn't actually feel that way and the way you phrased it made it seem like you had an issue with the logical consistency of that certain event as if a switch in her feelings occured, which in fact did not, i just wanted to clarify that. |
You son of a .. turtle |
Wut. But I did: "strung together at break-neck speed." I was just being honest, because I did laugh at how fast she resolved(?) her behavior, don't know how that equates to me being a douche when you're being super defensive about every negative post on here. |
Spaceship said: Nim0174 said: gotta hope all these fact claiming complainers drop it fast so we don't need to read their unconstructive comments anymore xD They won't. They get off on the reactions they get from people who actually enjoy and defend the show. Best policy is just to ignore. I got into it with one of those jackasses earlier today and it was a mistake. Don't feed the trolls. you are right actually xD the day i see a constructive opinion on a negative aspect will be celebrated as a national day |
You son of a .. turtle |
Nim0174 said: you did, but your intention flies out the window when you phrase it as a fact This is how people talk. Not sure how you want me to phrase it so it doesn't offend your sensibility or whatever. When I start off with "I wouldn't call this..." that seems like a good indication to me that what follows is an opinion, and should be obvious anyway in a discussion thread. I don't like the anime, I don't like the way it's written. If I'm being too harsh it's probably because I wanted to watch a fun space show this season. But I guess I'm an 'asshole' despite the fact that you are literally the only one here specifically insulting other people for not liking the show you like. |
Nim0174 said: you are right actually xD the day i see a constructive opinion on a negative aspect will be celebrated as a national day For the record, not everybody in here posting quibbles with the show is a troll. It's not a perfect show---personally I wish it were a little more serious and scientifically rigorous---but it's pretty easy to tell apart the people who are open to a healthy back-and-forth and the morons who just want want to crap on those who like the show and get a rise out of them. Anyway. I enjoyed the episode (though less than last week's double-length one) and I'm optimistic for the future of the series given that everyone says it just gets better from here. 7.5/10. |
| Set SCE to AUX |
Spaceship said: Nim0174 said: you are right actually xD the day i see a constructive opinion on a negative aspect will be celebrated as a national day For the record, not everybody in here posting quibbles with the show is a troll. It's not a perfect show---personally I wish it were a little more serious and scientifically rigorous---but it's pretty easy to tell apart the people who are open to a healthy back-and-forth and the morons who just want want to crap on those who like the show and get a rise out of them. Anyway. I enjoyed the episode (though less than last week's double-length one) and I'm optimistic for the future of the series given that everyone says it just gets better from here. 7.5/10. I've seen a lot of good arguments actually in general, just not on this Show's Episode Discussions. Except for last Episode actually, like i said myself i wasn't a fan of the handchain. I thought it was bad writing, personally. Or rather directing. syncrogazer said: Nim0174 said: you did, but your intention flies out the window when you phrase it as a fact This is how people talk. Not sure how you want me to phrase it so it doesn't offend your sensibility or whatever. When I start off with "I wouldn't call this..." that seems like a good indication to me that what follows is an opinion, and should be obvious anyway in a discussion thread. I don't like the anime, I don't like the way it's written. If I'm being too harsh it's probably because I wanted to watch a fun space show this season. But I guess I'm an 'asshole' despite the fact that you are literally the only one here specifically insulting other people for not liking the show you like. You are right there. But the way you phrased the second sentence "It is just" always makes it sound like fact claiming, sorry if you felt offended. I hate it when people fact claim their Opinions. I don't give a shit if someone doesn't like an Anime i like. I don't like people who claim their facts as opinions, is all. Because they sound like assholes to me, you clarified yourself so there is that. |
You son of a .. turtle |
| Aries though is soo cute. Seems she's able to find joy in any kind of situation. Its unfortunate but i guess on this planet common earth knowledge looks to be useless here on an alien planet. Quitterie really has quite the personality flaws within her. Still the fact that she had such a complex family situation was the main cause of her existing personality. Despite the danger Kanata's attempt to save Funi sure was impressive. Looks like the twin regrets of not embracing sports and the death of his teacher provided some painful lessons to Kanata that served to make him realise just how important bonds and training was. Though they managed to secure some supplies they really need to ration it. An interesting ep that while doing well in showing the kind of dangers that the team can encounter also served to expand upon Quitterie's character while also allowing the team to forge stronger bonds with each other.The fusion of survival elements, exploration and character expansion was used really well here. The reveal of a spy within the team though is an interesting angle to take. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| @Nim0174 I'm not offended, I just found parts of this exchange to be very ironic. I don't like it when people cook up bullshit reasons as to why a show doesn't make sense, or isn't explained or whatever. But that's not what I was doing. It's a fact that I think the pacing is too fast and things happen too conveniently, I don't think I need to qualify that, because it should be obvious that it's my opinion. |
syncrogazerJul 10, 2019 2:49 PM
| Impressive quality of the animation, and impressive soundtrack as well. I was expecting much more seriousness, but this is a shounen so it was to be expected Wasn’t expecting a traitor among them, this sounds like Rokka no Yuusha all over again lmfao |
| It was a nice episode, had everything and well balanced. So there is a traitor, no wonder that black hole popped up so conveniently again, it's probably artificial. |
| Lol that freaking drag scream was kinda scary. A dramatic episode with lots of emotions and I freaking love Kanata . He is totally the type of mc i like to watch.Also i wonder if some romance will be shown between Kanata and Aries , I hope they do. Quiterrie finally became honest with her feelings and gd thng she made up with funi and all the others. Man I freaking loved that scene where Kanata tried to save Funi. Overall another awesome episode . |
 |
| So, none of the so-called critics above would mention the only thing that actually could ruin someone's suspention of disbelief? After seeing the orb on this planet, they decide to wander off into the wilderness without their helmets. They clearly aren't wearing their suits and the orb is by far the most dangerous thing on the entire planet by a long shot. It's only natural to prioritize the safety of the entire group in a situation like this. Not to mention, there are no obvious drawbacks to wearing them. Every other complaint seems nitpicky to say the least. "Oh, a character mentions her trait when it's convinient! I would never do that in real life!" Really? Bruh. "I would definetly do x thing in a scenario like that." Says a guy with a 20/20 hindsight. I'm not sure if anyone understands, but you watch shows like this not to see a group of people be correct every single time, quite the opposite. "How would a smart guy do smart guy things? That just seems improbable to me." Would you have been convinced if he explained it with pseudo-scientific liguo? Sci-fi is basically just fantasy with a sciencey flavor. It might make more sense than magic, sure, but only because it pretends to be making sense |
| That was a pretty good episode.the sabotage at the end adds a bit of intregie to the story. A bit like Rokka in that respect. I'm also curious as to why the white sphere keeps showing up. |
TsukuyomiREKT said: Kimurah said: No can do kiddo. Don't like different comments/opinions, don't log in to a discussion board Don't like a show, don't watch it. What an insigtful comment Here's another one, if you don't like to read disenting opinions don't log into a discussion message board |
| Why is the stupid pink hair girl HA HA HA the "main" Heroine. The blonde is more interesting have a brain but is tsundere. And even looks better. Still like the show overall. |
Kimurah said: What an insigtful comment Here's another one, if you don't like to read disenting opinions don't log into a discussion message board I'm only telling you to do the same thing that you're telling other people to do. The "don't like it, ignore it" argument goes both ways. |
|
TsukuyomiREKT said: Kimurah said: What an insigtful comment Here's another one, if you don't like to read disenting opinions don't log into a discussion message board I'm only telling you to do the same thing that you're telling other people to do. The "don't like it, ignore it" argument goes both ways. No it doesn't you pretty snowflake Discussion boards are there for people to discuss X titles. Not to be lectured and be told what to do by kids. I'm allowed to discuss my gripes about a title without the need to be bossed around by salty and rusty jimmies that love every piece of media. You can do whatever you want with your time and life, but you can't tell me what to do with mine. If all you're going to do is just bitch at me for not liking your precious title (wich btw I haven't read at all any opinion on the series on your behalf in this thread, so that just tells me the lvl of butthurt on your behalf), go ahead, but not only you're already wasting your time, but you're also wrong on the very basics of discussion boards. |
| So, there is a saboteur among them. |
| A solid 2nd episode. As Stark said, there is a strong No Man's Sky vibe in this episode as we can explore a new planet with its own fauna & flora. Looking forward to the rest of the story. 4/5 |
| damn that ending. Who could it be, the most suspicious person is Yun Hua, but that might be too cliche. |
Spaceship said: Nim0174 said: you are right actually xD the day i see a constructive opinion on a negative aspect will be celebrated as a national day For the record, not everybody in here posting quibbles with the show is a troll. It's not a perfect show---personally I wish it were a little more serious and scientifically rigorous---but it's pretty easy to tell apart the people who are open to a healthy back-and-forth and the morons who just want want to crap on those who like the show and get a rise out of them. Anyway. I enjoyed the episode (though less than last week's double-length one) and I'm optimistic for the future of the series given that everyone says it just gets better from here. 7.5/10. You're obviously not talking about yourself when you're speaking about healthy back and forth discussion kid. You started with a "go away" quote on me. Stop acting like you're some saint when you're just another butthurt fanboy |
Kimurah said: TsukuyomiREKT said: I'm only telling you to do the same thing that you're telling other people to do. The "don't like it, ignore it" argument goes both ways. No it doesn't you pretty snowflake Discussion boards are there for people to discuss X titles. Not to be lectured and be told what to do by kids. I'm allowed to discuss my gripes about a title without the need to be bossed around by salty and rusty jimmies that love every piece of media. You can do whatever you want with your time and life, but you can't tell me what to do with mine. If all you're going to do is just bitch at me for not liking your precious title (wich btw I haven't read at all any opinion on the series on your behalf in this thread, so that just tells me the lvl of butthurt on your behalf), go ahead, but not only you're already wasting your time, but you're also wrong on the very basics of discussion boards. Lol, I expected you to basically call me a fanboy because that seems to be your default response. I haven't actually watched the show btw. I just looked at the discussions to see what people think about it. The only reason I even replied to you is because you don't understand common sense and are contradicting yourself. You saying that other people should just ignore your posts or these threads all together if they don't like what you have to say is stupid because you don't follow your own advice and just drop the show that you obviously aren't enjoying. If you don't like me pointing out your contradiction, then maybe you shouldn't contradict yourself. 🤷♂️ |
|
TsukuyomiREKT said: Lol, I expected you to basically call me a fanboy because that seems to be your default response. I haven't actually watched the show btw. Thank you, that's all I needed to know to offically state that you're a bitch. You haven't even watched the show, but you're entitled to tell others what to do. How cute. TsukuyomiREKT said: I just looked at the discussions to see what people think about it. The only reason I even replied to you is because you don't understand common sense and are contradicting yourself. Says the guy that hasn't even watched the show but feels entitled and knowledgeable to tell others how to act. yeah, I highly doubt you even know what common sense is and again doubt you even know how discussion boards work at all. TsukuyomiREKT said: You saying that other people should just ignore your posts or these threads all together if they don't like what you have to say is stupid because you don't follow your own advice Now you're just being a salty whinny kid with lack of the most basic reading skills. I said that if people don't like my opinions they should keep their mouth shut. They can obviously refute my points with arguments, and some of them actually have done so with back and forth "discussion" (A term you obviously can't even grasp despite having more than 2K posts) What you are doing in particular isn't even refuting any of my arguments, you're just being butthurt because someone else is dishing out a disenting opinion on a title you haven't even watched. TsukuyomiREKT said: and just drop the show that you obviously aren't enjoying. If you don't like me pointing out your contradiction, then maybe you shouldn't contradict yourself. 🤷♂️ Again, you're just some dumb butthurt kid that expects everyone to live to your own rules. But I'll give you a hint, life doesn't work like that. |
Kimurah said: TsukuyomiREKT said: Lol, I expected you to basically call me a fanboy because that seems to be your default response. I haven't actually watched the show btw. Thank you, that's all I needed to know to offically state that you're a bitch. You haven't even watched the show, but you're entitled to tell others what to do. How cute. TsukuyomiREKT said: I just looked at the discussions to see what people think about it. The only reason I even replied to you is because you don't understand common sense and are contradicting yourself. Says the guy that hasn't even watched the show but feels entitled and knowledgeable to tell others how to act. yeah, I highly doubt you even know what common sense is and again doubt you even know how discussion boards work at all. TsukuyomiREKT said: You saying that other people should just ignore your posts or these threads all together if they don't like what you have to say is stupid because you don't follow your own advice Now you're just being a salty whinny kid with lack of the most basic reading skills. I said that if people don't like my opinions they should keep their mouth shut. They can obviously refute my points with arguments, and some of them actually have done so with back and forth "discussion" (A term you obviously can't even grasp despite having more than 2K posts) What you are doing in particular isn't even refuting any of my arguments, you're just being butthurt because someone else is dishing out a disenting opinion on a title you haven't even watched. TsukuyomiREKT said: and just drop the show that you obviously aren't enjoying. If you don't like me pointing out your contradiction, then maybe you shouldn't contradict yourself. 🤷♂️ Again, you're just some dumb butthurt kid that expects everyone to live to your own rules. But I'll give you a hint, life doesn't work like that. And you're literally incapable of understanding that you contradicted yourself. I don't even give a shit about your opinion itself. That should be obvious. All I care about is your contradiction. |
|
Please enlighten all of us where have I contradicted my self? (Now I get the idea why you have so many posts in here) TsukuyomiREKT said: I don't even give a shit about your opinion itself. That should be obvious. All I care about is your contradiction. See, now that's a contradiction. You claim that you don't care about my opinion, yet you're here barking at me telling me what should I do according to your childish and petty life rules. But here you are, eating from the palm of my hand, I'm taking your time and tears on a show that you haven't even watched. If you didn't care for my opinion at all you could have stopped replying to me long time ago. But you're just acting all tsundere and telling me to shut up and stop watching |
KimurahJul 10, 2019 1:35 PM
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kanata no Astra Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 18, 2019 |
347 |
by naturalbrawler
»»
Mar 20, 8:24 AM |
|
Poll: » Kanata no Astra Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Aug 28, 2019 |
201 |
by naturalbrawler
»»
Jan 3, 12:55 AM |
|
» how this is not more popular.Sayms - Jan 15, 2022 |
21 |
by asalkur
»»
Jan 2, 10:45 AM |
|
Poll: » Kanata no Astra Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Jul 17, 2019 |
168 |
by asalkur
»»
Jan 2, 5:40 AM |
|
Poll: » Kanata no Astra Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Aug 7, 2019 |
236 |
by naturalbrawler
»»
Dec 30, 2023 9:53 PM |