| hopefully only anime originals are recognized as such, not 12 episode adaptations that only manage to tell like an introduction to a story. I don't see how is that a classic, even if it's good. Maybe the source can be a classic to its medium |
 |
| Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 for sure! |
| Literally none. All Anime today is bad, except for Mob Psycho 100. |
| Nande Koko ni Sensei ga?! and Domestic na Kanojo, probably. Classic trash. |
 |
| Kenja no mago will be a classic /S I am guessing kimetsu no yaiba or Carole and Tuesday will be a classic |
 It’s okay to look back at the past, just don’t stare too long |
| Maybe TPN, that thing is popular and was well-received enough to be a potential candidate. |
| attack on titan s3 p2 and tate no yuusha. |
| Vinland Saga hopefully. I want to believe Wit Studio won't disappoint us. |
 |
| I think Miru Tights #........................... |
 |
HopefulNihilist said: The Promised neverland, it was a perfect adaption Arkab said: Maybe TPN, that thing is popular and was well-received enough to be a potential candidate. What does TPN stand for? Is it a manga? |
It’s okay to look back at the past, just don’t stare too long |
| Promised Neverland seems promising i think |
| Attack on Titan is basically a 2010's classic at this point as is probably MHA, Mob Psycho 100 S2 should also grab a spot and maybe Vinland Saga if it gets a good adaption (WIT is making the PV's look very promising as a huge fan of the manga). Could get a lot of traction in the West due to its content though I don't know if a wider Japanese audience will grow for it. We do have a lot of action/adventure shonen adaptions this year that could bloom into popular titles or have already started to (TPN) but you need to give it a few years to gauge those I think. Plus some of these KnY and TPN are likely to be shorter due to the mangaka's request so I don't know if they will be as remembered as some of the older long running battle shonen. I would say Dororo too technically it is a classic already though I have heard a few more negative things about the second cour (not caught up). |
BilboBaggins365May 31, 2019 4:16 AM
| I have very high hopes for Toaru Kagaku no Accelerator. Origin story about Mc who previously was a villain, loner and overpowered. Pretty unique. It's manga adaptation. It's related to Toaru franchise and it can be watched without watching anything from it's franchise, so no doubt it will be somewhat popular. So depending on execution it could possibly become a classic. And i want to metion that stuff working on it is quite experiensed, they worked on many shows i liked. So if it won't become classic in the future, it surely will be remebered as classic in my book. |
| Miru Tights will easily be hailed as the savior of anime Dororo could've been, but the middle part has been pretty inconsistent But assuming it all goes well, I do think AoT S3 can be considered one, Carole & Tuesday seems like it could also If we count shows that started last year but continued this year, Run With the Wind can easily be remembered as a classic for sports anime |
 'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
| Not super popular, but Mahou Shoujo Tokushusen Asuka is bound to become a cult classic. It has a 90's OVA kind of violence that I found to be refreshing. |
 |
| Kimetsu no Yaiba is a strong candidate |
| Vinland Saga VINLAND SAGA ViNlAnd sAGa But I hope it won't have cancerous fandom |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Kimetsu no Yaiba will definitely become a classic legend. the story, art, music makes up what anime should be and what every anime/manga fans will ever dream watching/reading. personally, it should be like one piece and black clover (non-stop) and not like bnha (released season by season) |
| Mob Psycho 100 S2 = could be a classic Carole and Tuesday = elitists' classic Kimetsu no Yaiba & Dr. Stone = beloved by the main community classic (idk if they'll have longevity tho) Sarazanmai = ikuhara fans cult classic otherwise most of the other shows are long-running continuations or have been "done before" in some way so they won't have staying power in the community's minds (like if anyone is talking about shield hero a year from now i will be very surprised) |
HopefulNihilist said: @TolkienFan365 Short_Circut said: Miru Tights will easily be hailed as the savior of anime Dororo could've been, but the middle part has been pretty inconsistent But assuming it all goes well, I do think AoT S3 can be considered one, Carole & Tuesday seems like it could also If we count shows that started last year but continued this year, Run With the Wind can easily be remembered as a classic for sports anime I don't think AoT will be remembered as a classic. A classic in terms of popularity, yes, but in terms of quality reception? I don't think so. 8.50 is a decent score. Plus the currently airing season is at 9.11 after 50% of the season has already aired. You don't like it doesn't mean everybody hates the show. When anime was dying in the west, AoT was a major game changer. AoT became a pop culture during its initial run and still is among the top ten selling manga either in japan or USA (it actually ranked 6th in printed copies for this 6 month period) and the digital sales still outsell One piece. AoT was received fairly well in the anime community and I can even say that it is still very popular. AoT and armin were worldwide trending on twitter for a day after tye current episode. |
ShinyHexMay 31, 2019 11:08 AM
HopefulNihilist said: @TolkienFan365 Short_Circut said: Miru Tights will easily be hailed as the savior of anime Dororo could've been, but the middle part has been pretty inconsistent But assuming it all goes well, I do think AoT S3 can be considered one, Carole & Tuesday seems like it could also If we count shows that started last year but continued this year, Run With the Wind can easily be remembered as a classic for sports anime I don't think AoT will be remembered as a classic. A classic in terms of popularity, yes, but in terms of quality reception? I don't think so. Dalkpro said: I have very high hopes for Toaru Kagaku no Accelerator. Origin story about Mc who previously was a villain, loner and overpowered. Pretty unique. It's manga adaptation. It's related to Toaru franchise and it can be watched without watching anything from it's franchise, so no doubt it will be somewhat popular. So depending on execution it could possibly become a classic. And i want to metion that stuff working on it is quite experiensed, they worked on many shows i liked. So if it won't become classic in the future, it surely will be remebered as classic in my book. I don't think A Certain Magical Index was ever critically acclaimed in the same vein as, say, Ultimate Survivor Kaiji or Monster. Unless this new adaptation will be considered that good, I don't see it becoming a classic. SawamuraJane said: Promised Neverland seems promising i think Arkab said: Maybe TPN, that thing is popular and was well-received enough to be a potential candidate. I read the manga, and it's amazing. Based on what I've heard, the anime follows the manga, so it's equally as good. However, until Neverland gets more adaptations that finish the manga (which won't happen anytime soon since the manga is extremely look and isn't anywhere near finished), I don't see it becoming a classic, despite the amazing reception. Pretty much what @ThatShiny_Hex said. As for quality wise, 3rd season is doing a great job so far with all the buildup that led up to the season, which is why I said if all goes well it could be a classic |
'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
HopefulNihilist said: ThatShiny_Hex said: 8.50 is a decent score. Plus the currently airing season is at 9.11 after 50% of the season has already aired. That is indeed a very high score. However, I think most of the reviewers and people scoring the anime, are biased fans; not critics who look at the series from a more objective viewpoint. ThatShiny_Hex said: You don't like it doesn't mean everybody hates the show. I never said anything like that: I said that, to my understanding, Attack on Titan isn't very highly received by critics. ThatShiny_Hex said: When anime was dying in the west, AoT was a major game changer. AoT became a pop culture during its initial run and still is among the top ten selling manga either in japan or USA (it actually ranked 6th in printed copies for this 6 month period) and the digital sales still outsell One piece. Even if it outsells One Piece, I don't think AoT is taken as seriously as One Piece in terms of quality. ThatShiny_Hex said: AoT was received fairly well in the anime community and I can even say that it is still very popular. AoT and armin were worldwide trending on twitter for a day after tye current episode. True, I don't think critics hate Attack on Titan, but I don't think it's loved critically either. To my understanding, critics think Attack on Titan is either an okay series, or just decent. Short_Circut said: Pretty much what @ThatShiny_Hex said. As for quality wise, 3rd season is doing a great job so far with all the buildup that led up to the season, which is why I said if all goes well it could be a classic I only watched season 1 of Attack On Titan, so I can't say how good the series actually is; my assumptions on whether AoT will be a classic is based on how critics view it. Because in my opinion, a true classic anime is an anime that is highly received well by critics. But it is well received by critics though? Both manga and anime have won a lot of awards and not just fan ones |
'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
HopefulNihilist said: ThatShiny_Hex said: 8.50 is a decent score. Plus the currently airing season is at 9.11 after 50% of the season has already aired. That is indeed a very high score. However, I think most of the reviewers and people scoring the anime, are biased fans; not critics who look at the series from a more objective viewpoint. ThatShiny_Hex said: You don't like it doesn't mean everybody hates the show. I never said anything like that: I said that, to my understanding, Attack on Titan isn't very highly received by critics. ThatShiny_Hex said: When anime was dying in the west, AoT was a major game changer. AoT became a pop culture during its initial run and still is among the top ten selling manga either in japan or USA (it actually ranked 6th in printed copies for this 6 month period) and the digital sales still outsell One piece. Even if it outsells One Piece, I don't think AoT is taken as seriously as One Piece in terms of quality. ThatShiny_Hex said: AoT was received fairly well in the anime community and I can even say that it is still very popular. AoT and armin were worldwide trending on twitter for a day after tye current episode. True, I don't think critics hate Attack on Titan, but I don't think it's loved critically either. To my understanding, critics think Attack on Titan is either an okay series, or just decent. Short_Circut said: Pretty much what @ThatShiny_Hex said. As for quality wise, 3rd season is doing a great job so far with all the buildup that led up to the season, which is why I said if all goes well it could be a classic I only watched season 1 of Attack On Titan, so I can't say how good the series actually is; my assumptions on whether AoT will be a classic is based on how critics view it. Because in my opinion, a true classic anime is an anime that is highly received well by critics. From critics point of view, season 1 is the worst among all of them. Shingeki's writing increases with season, and after the current airing arc, it increases drastically. ps: Some classics arent well liked by critics as well, something like Death note or haruhi suzumiya or even akira. Classical anime is something that was and will be well liked, influencial at their run time and would remain unique throughout the bonds of time. |
ShinyHexMay 31, 2019 12:32 PM
| I would say that Vinland Saga definitely could if WIT does a good job. SNK S3 Part 2 will I believe. Same goes for Bungou Stray Dogs S3, and Chihayafuru S3 that should come out later this year. I think JoJo Part 5 (if we can count it as 2019 show) is quite assured to become classic, since JoJo itself already is a classic. But besides Vinland all those are a continuations of already well established shows (and Vinland itself is adaptation of already very well establised manga). In terms of new shows I think this year isn't very impressive so far. I'm hopeful something will come out in next 2 seasons (although summer offerings don't look very impressive either so far, hopefully there will be surprise when they actually come out). |
MrZawaMay 31, 2019 12:30 PM
| Miru Tights, probably the only one. |
 |
| @HopefulNihilist That's is just a subjective opinion on what a classic entails though. I don't really believe quality is the main factor as that is a subjective opinion people often can dislike things that are considered classics. Obviously it needs to have some collective agreement that it is a quality show which it does as many people really like it. The most important thing is staying power and influence on the industry though and AOT has easily been one of the most popular action series of this decade. The writing to me really started to get better starting with this arc and the majority of the audience seems to have had a positive response to it. It probably will end up this generation's Code Geass. Again it's just theorizing you can't really predict this stuff until the series ends however, as long as AOT gets a decent ending it will continue to be seen as an easy intro to anime like FMAB or Cowboy Bebop and therefore stay relevant rather than seasonal show x. @BlakexEkalb Fair though technically its a manga from Tezuka being remade but yeah I get the feeling a lot of people have stopped talking about it. |
BilboBaggins365May 31, 2019 2:06 PM
| Since when was Kill la Kill considered a classic? |
| Who even determines what is a classic or not. Hard to go wrong here. |
  |
HopefulNihilist said: @ThatShiny_Hex I thought Death Note, Haruhi Suzumiya, and especially Akira, were beloved by critics. TolkienFan365 said: That's is just a subjective opinion on what a classic entails though. True, it's subjective, but I've noticed that every anime that I've heard that is considered a "classic" (Monster, Kaiji, Kill la Kill) has high critical praise, and an ending. If AoT right now has as much critical praise, then I can see it becoming a classic. TolkienFan365 said: The most important thing is staying power and influence on the industry though and AOT has easily been one of the most popular action series of this decade. AOT definitely has staying power, that we can agree on. However, influence? I haven't seen or heard any anime that was influenced by AOT. TolkienFan365 said: The writing to me really started to get better starting with this arc and the majority of the audience seems to have had a positive response to it. It probably will end up this generation's Code Geass. I'm not sure if that's a good comparison, from your point of view. Because Code Geass is highly decisive: there are many people who believe it's a genius series, but there are also almost as many people who believe it is pretentious and stupid. TolkienFan365 said: Again it's just theorizing you can't really predict this stuff until the series ends True, that's why I specifically said this thread was about theorizing, just for fun. TolkienFan365 said: however, as long as AOT gets a decent ending it will continue to be seen as an easy intro to anime like FMAB or Cowboy Bebop and therefore stay relevant rather than seasonal show x. Based on what you've said, it seems as though AOT has garnered more critical praise, but in exchange, its popularity has died down. I don't think I've heard people hype it as much as when it first aired. @Short_Circut AOT has awards?! I'm going to have to look that up. ye it won Tokyo Anime Awards in 2014 for best director, score, story and AoTY. I believe there's also some more |
'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
| @HopefulNihilist Its not 2013/14 anymore, the series isn't as hype as season 1, but it is still a popular series that is getting plenty of praise especially this season. The latest episode is literally ranked #1 as the best episode of all time on imdb. https://www.imdb.com/search/title?title_type=tv_episode&num_votes=1000,&sort=user_rating,desc heck 3 episodes from attack on titan is in the top 20. Its also rated highly on mal ranked 6th with 9.11, even exceeding my expectation. |
| @HopefulNihilist Well again as a manga reader pretty much almost everyone has loved the direction though again could just be more of an echo chamber since the people that like AOT keep up with it. This current season has gotten a lot of praise from anime onlys so at the very least I am not mistaken there. As for Code Geass yeah I have heard many contrary opinions though I have also for NGE and that one I think most would agree it is a classic (still waiting for the release on Netflix so I can form my own opinions on it). Same thing with Lain some who think it's forward thinking others over pretentious garbage. As for influence I was just saying that more generally few shows usually can be pointed to as starting a trend. Though those that do most will look back and say they are classics. As for popularity yeah it has died down it still is one of the most popular manga out there same for the anime. |
| 2019 will produce no anime classics, quote me on this in 2029 if north korea hasn't nuked japan by then |
| the official MAL hall of fame/cursed comments is now open for business - you are welcome to PM me any potential quotes to include |
| If I have to name one then Yakusoku no Neverland. Maybe Kaguya too. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| @HopefulNihilist No I don't consider you arguing with me lol What I meant is few shows are able to be influence the industry. Most are going to more push a trend than establish it. Those that do establish a new trend though almost always are considered classics because of that influence. I would argue you extend that to shows that shortly follow suit and help make the genre popular as well. I am not claiming that AOT made say dark fantasy/supernatural more popular at all just more continuing that genre's popularity and prominence if anything from say when FMAB ended (same kinda theme dark steampunk/dieselpunk fantasy). The major influence I would argue was mainly on the financial side where AOT really helped speed up the recovering of the anime/manga industry in the West after the crash in the late 2000's. It also was a major hit for Kodansha which they hadn't seen in awhile. As for AOT again I am just communicating how the current AOT anime only community feels about the show and how the manga community is reacting to new chapters. That response to recent developments could very different when certain portions of the manga gets adapted or when we see the conclusion of the manga. If AOT gets a bad ending again it could lose popularity and fall off in time. Which is why it is hard to judge but if Isayama can continue writing like he is of late I think it could establish itself there. |
BilboBaggins365May 31, 2019 4:17 PM
| If Kaguya-Sama ever gets a full adaption, it could definitely be considered a modern classic for RomComs. |
My Queens  |
| @HopefulNihilist No, I heard one of Breaking bad episodes was at number 1 for a good while now, until apparently, game of thrones fans down vote it. Its similar to mal ranking. |
More topics from this board
» Early-mid 2000s anime – what are your thoughts?Haneken2086 - 10 hours ago |
9 |
by LenRea
»»
29 minutes ago |
|
» Anime Misandry ( 1 2 )ColourWheel - Apr 21 |
92 |
by JaniSIr
»»
30 minutes ago |
|
» Do you drop shows?EverRealm - Yesterday |
49 |
by fae
»»
30 minutes ago |
|
» is ur fave genre ur most watched genre ?ame - Yesterday |
17 |
by Ratris_Decision
»»
35 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Bare feet or pantyhoses?Absurdo_N - Yesterday |
26 |
by LoveYourEyes
»»
41 minutes ago |